Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 April 2007

Sun seeks a role in mobile Java with acquisition of SavaJe assets

As mobile device vendors become focused on 3G-plus and mobile internet applications, the user interface and software frameworks on the cellphones have become more competitively important than the operating system. The old battles between Symbian, Mobile Linux and Windows Mobile have become less significant in handset vendors’ strategies, with the differentiation – and attempts at political control – being built into higher layers. The main innovators here have been Nokia with Series x0, Apple with its Safari-based initiatives, Qualcomm with Brew/UIone, Opera and some open source community projects, themselves heavily influenced by Motorola. These contenders will now be joined by Intel’s ongoing development of an umbrella navigation architecture for ultra-mobile PCs (see separate item), and Microsoft’s belated efforts to move beyond Windows for mobile interfaces. The common factor in all this – even in the shadows of the Microsoft and Qualcomm approaches – is J2ME Java. Java’s owner Sun, poised to open source its greatest – and most under-exploited – asset, badly needs to assert greater influence over the mobile version of its software, after years of being wrong footed by the handset makers. A more concerted effort to reap the rewards of Java’s ubiquity in the mobile high end is signalled by Sun’s acquisition of the intellectual property assets of SavaJe, maker of an all-Java mobile operating system. Sun is vague about its plans for the product, though it promises to reveal more at next month’s Java One conference, but one option will be to use its muscle to make SavaJe a direct competitor to SymbianOS and the others. This would likely be a failure, since most operators want to reduce the number of OSs they support, not add a new one. Far more important will be influence on higher software layers, and a chance for Sun to reassert leadership in the mobile Java world in order to generate indirect revenue and control, just as it surrenders direct control to the open source community.

SavaJe has been seeking financial rescue since January, when it laid off most of its staff. The software house attracted considerable operator interest in 2004-5 as a possible weapon against the major handset makers’ OSs, such as Symbian, but the market has now moved on with all the big players supporting advanced Java options, which make the choice of underlying OS less important. Although Vodafone, Orange and others were early investors, these cellcos are now focusing on reducing the number of OSs they support.

There are two areas where SavaJe may be important to Sun in boosting its influence over the mobile platform. One is to counter the threat to Java ubiquity that may arise from the creation of mobile OSs that are open to direct downloading of applications, reducing the need for one of Java’s key functions on the cellphone. The other is to feed SavaJe’s strongest suits, notably its support for customization, into a potential Sun interface architecture that could challenge the existing players before the market gets too settled.

If a real mobile internet is to evolve, direct downloading from the open web will be an essential feature, though one long resisted by operators, worried about their control of revenue streams and also the security and capacity of their networks. This trend favors technologies like Ajax, which are being widely adopted by Nokia, Opera, Google and other movers and shakers, and could sideline Java. Sun, then, needs to update Java, and combine it with other technologies such as Ajax, so that it becomes relevant for more than just downloading apps.

Some useful aspects of the SavaJe IPR could aid in this process, particularly the high degree of customization it offers operators to differentiate their handset environment – something in which Qualcomm also excels since purchasing UIone. The all-Java OS uses deep theming functionality to implement operator-specified applications and menus, as well as color schemes, sounds, background images and icons that affect both built-in and downloaded applications.

It would be interesting to see Sun trying to turn its Java assets into real products by creating a new mobile software platform. It has made sporadic attempts to commercialize Java-oriented projects in the mobile world – for instance with its 2003 purchase of content distribution specialist Pixo, a challenge to Qualcomm Brew – but with limited success, and has largely seen the J2ME agenda wrested from its hands by the handset and operator majors. Last year, the Java One conference saw many valuable enhancements promised for J2ME, but most of them came from Nokia, Ericsson and other cellular players. For example, Nokia and Motorola led the development of the latest J2ME specification, Java Specification Request 232 for Mobile Operational Management, claiming mobile clients will, for the first time, gain the same type of middleware environment as the PC world. Other backers include Vodafone, NTT DoCoMo, IBM and SAP.

The operators have also been active, and may prove valuable allies for Sun if it can offer products that support their aims. Java is an important ingredient in some operator-driven initiatives, such as the Vodafone-inspired Open Mobile Terminal Alliance (OMTA), which is widely seen as a bid to wrest the handset agenda from Nokia and Motorola. And last year, Sun announced an pact with NTT DoCoMo centered on creating a mobile data services platform, codenamed *Project, based on Java and aimed at delivering rich mass market consumer applications that go beyond DoCoMo’s current capabilities. This is the type of agreement that Sun badly needs in mobile Java, and it will hope that SavaJe – whose own development agenda was heavily shaped by its carrier investors – will bring it some valuable technological bargaining chips to lure influential cellcos.

Otherwise Sun risks losing out in the technology it created. Perhaps the most important current mobile Java project, announced in August 2004, brings together Vodafone and Nokia in a rare show of unity, focused on unifying the fragmented standard and “simplifying mobile Java standards by defining the next generation, open standards-based mobile Java services architecture specifications’. Although Sun joined this effort, it has not taken a guiding role. Such projects, though they may take place under the auspices of the Java Community Process, are also increasingly driven by other industry groups and standards bodies, which seems to diminish Sun’s potential to become a primary mobile Java vendor itself, beyond the obvious licensing revenues.

Another blow came last year when Motorola stole the initiative in mobile Java with a pledge of support for the Apache Foundation’s open source licensing process (see Wireless Watch November 6 2006 edition), just as Sun was poised to adopt a rival process, the GNU General Public License (GPL). The potential stand-off shows the battle for control between Sun and the handset makers, with Motorola pushing hard for Apache to be the industry standard process for mobile Linux.

SavaJe’s products and IPR, and their single major licensee, LG, will not address these challenges for Sun, but they do act as a statement of intent that it intends to play a major role in the market it created; to preserve Java’s position while it remains the main mobile applications choice for operators; and to adapt it to a more open internet future.