The handset vendors have not been mincing their words recently about the difficulties of working with the US mobile operators, which demand a huge degree of control in their relationships with phonemakers. US cellcos rely on their own brands, and direct channels to market, more than their European counterparts, but lack the strong influence over handset specifications that the Asian operators enjoy. This combination makes them extremely aggressive in their negotiations with phone manufacturers, and they are even more dependent than cellcos elsewhere on choosing the right handsets. While Sprint Nextel may have the most innovative and forward thinking view of future mobile devices, and how they will drive new service revenues, currently it is overshadowed in this respect, as in other aspects of commercial performance, by AT&T and Verizon Wireless, which continued to steal share from their challenger during the first quarter.
Although Sprint’s performance was better than many analysts had expected – though, admittedly, their expectations had been watered down by recent poor quarters – the leading two operators were turning their newest choices of handsets and new applications into strong gains. Verizon Wireless remains the US’ fastest growing cellco, boasting 1.7m net customer additions during the first quarter, compared to 1.2m at AT&T’s wireless arm and 568,000 at Sprint Nextel.
On the all-important data services front, Verizon also has the highest growth rate among the majors, up 37.5% year-on-year to 36m data subscribers, while AT&T saw a 30% increase, to 33.4m. Verizon Wireless ended Q1 with 60.7m customers, in shooting distance of AT&T Mobility’s 62.2m, and claimed it has the largest number of direct users on its network, at 58.5m (the others are via resale or MVNO deals).
Verizon’s best claim to fame is its low churn rate, down to 1.08% in Q1, compared to 1.2% a year earlier, plus it saw 2.1% increase in gross customer additions. AT&T Mobility’s total churn rate stood at 1.7% and postpaid churn was 1.3%. In the crucial ARPU metric, Verizon saw an increase of 4.2% year-on-year to $50.73, but was flat sequentially. Data ARPU increased 54% year-on-year to $8.95. Strong ARPU boosted Verizon Wireless’ total revenues for the quarter to $10.3bn, up 17%, and operating income leapt 29% to $2.7bn.
Sprint Nextel continued to struggle with its worst short term challenge, the loss of high value contract customers, especially from the high margin Nextel iDEN network, and the consequent balance shift to prepaid users and lower margins. However, its performance showed welcome signs of recovery and its stock rose by 3% on announcement of the results. The carrier gained almost 568,000 net new subscribers despite continuing losses on iDEN. Postpaid subs declined by 220,000 during the first quarter, reflecting a loss of about 1.1m iDEN subscribers, but modest postpaid growth and churn reduction is expected in Q2, both by Sprint and its analysts. The first quarter losses were mostly offset by gains in CDMA sign-ups and the wholesale channel and its Boost Mobile sub-brand put the carrier in the black on net additions. Boost mobile virtual added 275,000 customers to bring its base to about 4.3m. Wholesale channels, including MVNOs and affiliates, added 467,000 subscribers for a customer base of 6.8m.
Sprint Nextel now has a total of 41.6m postpaid subscribers – 24.7m on CDMA, 16.5m on iDEN and 400,000 Powersource customers, who use a dual-mode phones to access both networks. The company’s postpaid ARPU stood at $59, a year-on-year decline of around 5% and sequential decline of about 2%. Most of the decline came from a 9% drop in iDEN ARPU. Sprint posted a net loss for the quarter of $211m, compared with net income of $419m in Q106.
Meanwhile, Alltel reported 13% revenue growth during the first quarter, hitting $2.08bn. However, its net income fell 23% year-on-year to $230.1m, but last year the carrier still had its landline business, which helped boost the bottom line. In wireless alone, net income was up 24%. The company added a record 237,000 subscribers during the first quarter, a 44% increase with the year earlier period, although fewer than half of the net adds were high value postpaid customers. It now has 12m customers, with postpaid churn of 1.3% and total churn of 1.8%, record lows for the cellco. ARPU was $52.49 for the quarter while the average data revenue per customer increased 64% to $4.70.
So with four of the big five relatively satisfied with their Q1 performance (T-Mobile has yet to report), the cellcos are talking up the handset choices that will influence results in later periods of this year. Alltel has added a new flagship, the Samsung Wafer, which boasts thickness of just 0.25 inches plus XM Radio Mobile, Axcess TV and Axcess Mobile Guide, a 1.3-megapixel camera with video capabilities, MP3 player, expandable memory, stereo Bluetooth and Alltel’s Celltop user interface. It costs $50 with a two-year contract.
But definitely stealing the highest profile, with the most creative new handset choices, is AT&T, which is set to start selling the Apple iPhone and Nokia N75 next month. The iPhone is important to its first carrier customer because it will be exclusive for a while, and has generated enormous (and largely unpaid-for) advance publicity on the back of the Apple brand and virtual marketing machine. However, the AT&T-Apple deal may prove a Pyrrhic victory, given that the cellco has had to make major concessions on pricing and distribution in exchange for exclusivity, and may be setting precedents for handset negotiations that could weaken the carriers’ stranglehold and cause future problems for the giant operators.
AT&T has a good track record in picking high profile phones. Cingular Wireless, the forerunner of AT&T Mobility, was the first and exclusive carrier for the iconic Motorola RAZR. Now the carrier is set to launch the Nokia N75, the latest in its range of ‘multimedia computers’ and significant because Nokia is taking the unusual step of allowing one of its flagship phones to take the operator’s logo as its lead brand rather than Nokia’s own. It will arrive at around the same time as the iPhone and the new consumer focused RIM Curve device, making AT&T’s shelves by far the most interesting in the US in the middle part of the year. The concessions Nokia has apparently made over the AT&T version of the N75 reflect the extreme importance of US growth to the Finnish giant’s strategy – CEO Kallasvuo recently moaned about the stranglehold of the large cellcos, but has also admitted that US expansion, especially now Nokia has finally pulled out of the CDMA market, is a major challenge and priority. ‘We are investing heavily in upgrading our U.S. position by simply tailoring products to the US operators,’ Kallasvuo said in a recent briefing to analysts. ‘Here, AT&T definitely is the most important target. The much deeper cooperation with AT&T is ongoing and we will start seeing the impacts already this year.’
The high margin ‘N’ series 3G models, like many Nokia (and Sony Ericsson) products, have been heavily pushed through non-carrier channels such as direct retail outlets in the US, reflecting the hard job the European GSM-only phonemakers have gaining top billing in the US cellcos’ portfolios. These alternative channels – which Nokia will tap into even more enthusiastically as it pushes its non-cellular internet tablets and enterprise products – are a thorn in the US cellcos’ sides, and the new accord with AT&T hints at an important compromise and a shift to find some common ground to benefit both giants.