Motorola shareholders decide today (Monday) whether to give a seat on the board to activist billionaire investor Carl Icahn, who has been bitterly critical of the current management of the company under the leadership of CEO Ed Zander. In many ways, success for Icahn would represent a judgement on Zander and the current strategy of Motorola, which has suffered poor recent quarters, largely because of its over-commitment to ultra-low cost handsets, and to market share over profits. Even if the corporate raider fails, his campaign has shaken confidence in Zander and the CEO urgently needs to deliver a convincing roadmap for recovery and medium term growth.
Unsurprisingly, Icahn’s bid for a board seat is opposed by management, and in the past weeks the battle has become colourful and personal, indicating the significance to the Zander leadership of the key test of shareholder support for his recovery plans. Icahn, Motorola’s largest non-institutional shareholder, has been steadily increasing his holding in Motorola stock, now at about 2.7%.
There have been some signs of hope for his bid to take a more direct role in pushing his view that Motorola must take a more aggressive stance. On Friday, he gained his first major shareholder endorsement, from ClearBridge, a New York-based money manager owned by Legg Mason, which owns just over 2% of Motorola (54m shares). ClearBridge is the handset giant’s eighth largest shareholder, and it could influence others by setting a bandwagon rolling and giving Icahn’s attempt greater credibility, from an investor respected for long term thinking rather than short term opportunism.
ClearBridge CEO Brian Posner said in a statement that his company was “deeply respectful of the quality of Motorola’s board. However, given recent events at the company, we believe it is in the best interest of all shareholders to have a new representative on the board.” He added that Icahn would contribute “positively to the dialog among the members of the board” and “offer valuable insights”.
A few weeks earlier, Zander had announced that he would be accelerating the size and scope of the current billion-share buyback programme, to $7.5bn – a move that was previously not on the management agenda, but which gives in to one of the key Icahn demands. Icahn wants the company to use all its $11.3bn in free cash to finance stock repurchases, so management presumably thought that, by making some concessions, they would reduce the strength of his appeal to shareholders and keep him off the board.
Icahn – with personal worth of $10bn, estimated to be the US’ twenty fourth richest man – specializes in leveraging his stakes in major companies that he regards as undervalued or mismanaged, to force change, often through asset stripping. His initial interest sparked a 6.7% rise in Motorola’s share price in February on the day his intentions were announced – reflecting a general feeling that there is significant value that needs to be unlocked within the corporation.
Since February, though, the arguments over Motorola’s approach to management, shareholder value and debt levels have degenerated into a bitter war of words and propaganda. Both have enlisted proxy advisory firms to support their cases – with Icahn winning endorsements from two, Institutional Shareholder Services and Proxy Governance, and Motorola from one, Glass, Lewis & Co. Such advisers’ recommendations can carry significant weight with institutional investors.
The two main protagonists have also gone for each others’ personal throats. On Friday, Icahn said in an interview that he would seek the resignation of Zander if Motorola does not turn around by the end of the year – a hardening of his earlier position that he merely wanted to add value through stock buyback, and had no desire to see Zander replaced.
If Icahn does gain his seat, he will be only one of 11 directors (a number that is being reduced tomorrow from 13) but he is well known for his powers of persuasion and his skill at exploiting the position of dissident shareholder. In particular, he would have the opportunity to seek a place on one of the board’s committees, and would likely favour ‘compensation and leadership’, which would put him in the best position to pursue the ousting of Zander.
Even if he fails – and that still seems fairly likely – the battle will have worsened Motorola’s problems by airing many unwelcome issues in public and making shareholders more alert to the need for a significant change of direction to boost value. And it has focused attention on the short term demands of investors rather than the strategic goals of Motorola, which of necessity, in this market, require some shareholder patience and will not all reap dividends immediately. All companies, especially those in high risk and wildly cyclical sectors like mobile communications, have to strike this balance between shareholder reward and long term growth. To survive, Zander does not need to give into all the demands of Icahn, which would take the company too far down the short termism route that has killed so many US organizations; but he does need to convince the other investors, and quickly, that he has a sound roadmap for generating medium term growth. That has not yet been forthcoming, and it will be far harder to win over the crucial hearts and minds with an influential corporate raider sitting on his shoulder.
The war of words heats up:
The Icahn-Motorola dispute, always acrimonious, sank into the gutter in the last week of April, when Icahn took out a full page advertisement in the Wall Street Journal, condemning a comment Zander had made in the same newspaper, when he said: “I love my job. I hate my customers”. Icahn used this as a hook to accuse the Motorola CEO of “critical failure in oversight and leadership”, claiming the company has “stumbled badly” under his CEOship.
A few days later, Motorola hit back by pointing to a televised interview with Icahn, recorded in November by CNBC, in which the activist commented on another director serving on multiple boards, saying: “How can a guy be on eight boards and know what the hell he’s doing? How can somebody sit on a board – even if he’s the smartest guy in the world – if he was Einstein – and understand what that company is doing?” Motorola pointed out that Icahn serves on 11 boards, is chair of four and is seeking election to a further three. “Motorola’s board of directors does not believe Carl Icahn treats public company directorship with the appropriate level of seriousness and commitment,” the company said. “We will not allow Carl Icahn to use Motorola as his self-serving platform.”
In a letter to Motorola shareholders and included in a filing with the SEC last Wednesday, Icahn said his $1.2bn investment was more than sufficient incentive for him to devote all of the time and effort required to help ensure that management is “getting it right.”
Icahn then said that he had offered to reduce his board positions to three or four if he were elected at Motorola, and to suggest “another large shareholder” to serve as director in place of himself, if Motorola could not work with him on the board. Also in a CNBC interview, Motorola executives said Icahn had not identified any such individual, and later stated that, although it offered to work with Icahn to identify two mutually acceptable independent directors, “Carl Icahn has refused to cooperate”. Instead, it said the shareholder had suggested that one of his employees, plus an additional indepdendent director, should replace him.