As a lesson in marketing, last week should have been important to Motorola CEO Ed Zander and Apple chief Steve Jobs. Perhaps the key message – if you are going to oversell a future product, leave enough time between the hype and the reality to avoid the disappointment factor, and to ensure the world at large believes your messages. The iPhone is already taking on the guise of a classic, before it actually hits the streets, and each time attention threatens to be distracted by another handset launch, a further tidbit of information ‘leaks’ about the impending debut. As Motorola talked up its forthcoming ‘media monster’, we heard that AT&T was cancelling leave for salespeople in the first month of iPhone availability, and as that monster (actually, the Z8) emerged, wires were buzzing with speculation that T-Mobile was about to announce an iPhone deal for the UK and possibly other European territories.
Without spending many marketing dollars yet, Apple has achieved huge excitement about its iPhone, while its more established rivals are spending many millions on promoting their own newcomers, with less impact (despite the fact that the iPhone has certain omissions that would be unacceptable coming from a Nokia or Motorola, such as a 3G option or an open developer platform).
In the shadow of the impending iPhone launch, the handset majors are trying to raise their own profiles, none more than Motorola, whose CEO Ed Zander fell into the trap of over-hyping the company’s new handsets, which were unveiled the following week. Key among them are the Z8 media phone and the RAZR2, the latter the latest device to try to prove a worthy successor to its phenomenally successful, but now declining, namesake. After Zander’s promises of breathtaking video performance and other breakthroughs, the actual launches were a letdown, though on closer study, the phones do represent the first examples of some important changes in approach, which could help Motorola get back on track in terms of its handset market share and margin metrics – notably, as Zander had earlier outlined to shareholders, an intensified focus on Linux, Java, 3G and multimedia, which will now be supported by a Nokia-style reorganization of the product range.
First the new devices themselves. The Z8 had, of course, been already announced at the 3GSM show in February, hence the disappointment after Zander’s build-up – although it remains a promising phone for heavy duty multimedia users, and the phonemaker is promising deals with various film studios for preloaded movies on the supported SD cards. One of the new features it is pushing is ‘see what I see’, which lets the person you are talking to see your view in full video, which we presume can be used for videoconferencing too. The device comes with 2Gb of on-board memory to hold the 1,000 songs that everyone said the first ROKR phone should have had, plus full HTML web browsing and email access. The memory can go right the way up to 32Gb using expandable flash microSD memory cards – enough storage for 12 full-length movies or 70 hours of music, according to Motorola.
The company is giving away a copy of the film The Bourne Identity, in a 512Mb microSD card, in much the same way that Sony gave away movies to demonstrate the effectiveness of its PlayStation Portable.
More exciting was the announcement of RAZR2, which Zander introduced in Jobs-like style, and with heavy emphasis on the element the iPhone does not have, fast connections (RAZR2 comes in HSDPA, EV-DO and EDGE variants). The handset is slimmer than its predecessor by two millimeters and is built with chemically hardened glass, steel and aluminum casing. It is 10 times as fast as the original RAZR (which Nokia executives recently referred to disparagingly as a “low end phone with a nice screen”), boasting a 500MHz processor. The new generation of the phone with which Zander is inextricably associated also claims the largest external display of any clamshell, and a 2.2-inch internal screen with twice the resolution of the previous model. There is also USB 2.0 support for fast media transfer, plus a keypad with haptics and tactile feedback, and a technology called Crystal Talk, that filters ambient noise.
The most immediate challenge is to, as Zander put it, recapture the “wow” factor for Motorola handsets. Critics say that would have been easier to achieve by using a new name, since the once shiny RAZR brand is now associated with discounting and has been, perhaps, over-exposed. But Zander – who remains, despite recent criticisms, a huge believer in making RAZR the core underlying brand and design for generations of Motorola products – claims plenty of enhancements to maintain the excitement factor. Apart from the specific new features, he said the company would more generically focus on three main directions – Linux/Java, greater emphasis on 3G, and multimedia/messaging. ‘It’s not just about form factor anymore,’ he said. And these directions will underpin a whole range of forthcoming handsets, both RAZR branded and otherwise, and a restructuring of the cellphone family structure.
In a move reminiscent of Nokia’s 2005 reworking of its products into three categories – Mobile Phones, Media and Enterprise – Motorola will now build products around three market segments: ‘Everyday Communications’, for low cost and emerging markets; ‘Feature Phones’ which remain voice/text oriented; and ‘Multimedia and Messaging’, in which the phone function is second to entertainment and social networking. As with the Nokia changes, the underlying agenda is not just about branding and marketing, but about streamlining the range at every level of the value chain, to reduce costs and rationalize supplier relationships, something at which Motorola has struggled compared to its Finnish bugbear.
New chief marketing officer Casey Keller also stressed the customer facing aspects of a new portfolio structure that marks his first major impact on Motorola. Despite the power of some individual brands, he wants an approach that is more centered on consumer behavior, as the new structure shows – whether they are most interested in talking, listening to music, taking pictures or surfing the web.
“This is a change in our marketing and branding approach and ultimately in our portfolio-development approach,” Keller said in an interview. “We’re not just about form factors, colors, designs,. We are moving toward what we would call ‘experiences”how are people behaving with our products, what do we expect our products to do for them? What experiences are we delivering to them?” Thus the company will extend and embellish the ROKR music-specific line, the Z range for video, and so on (also not unlike Nokia’s recent changes of emphasis).
While the strategic decisions behind the new Motorola products may be more impressive than the devices themselves, the opposite may be true at Apple. Behind the (presumably) stunning handset and the superb viral marketing, some of the strategic decisions have been plain wrong, and display a superficial understanding of the workings of the mobile world that may harm Apple as it takes on its larger rivals. Most notable is the decision to keep third party developers off the iPhone, just as Nokia, Motorola and others have spent the past two years recognizing that extensive applications support and rich functionality, generated by a vibrant developer community, are the keys to success – and the advantages Microsoft so loudly claims. Well, it seems Apple’s Jobs may be rethinking his decision even before iPhone launches, no doubt with an eye on the huge efforts the larger phonemakers have put into boosting their developer communities through initiatives like Forum Nokia. Jobs recently said in a shareholders’ meeting that the company was “wrestling with” the decision to keep the iPhone closed, but remained concerned about the risks of impacting stability and performance by opening up at an early stage in the product’s lifecycle. It is likely that Apple will seek to make up for its closed platform by pushing the concept of web applications to a level few phonemakers have yet aspired to – but that will be virtually impossible without a 3G connection.
Other new Motorola phones:
Also unveiled by Zander were:
‘ The company’s Q smartphone will come in Q8 and Q9 versions for GSM/EDGE and HSDPA, respectively. The latter will reach Italian consumers first, later this month.
‘ The RIZR Z8 is a new iteration of the company’s slider, dubbed ‘the banana phone’, as it is intended to fit the human face.
‘ The new ROKR Z6 music phone will be launched in Europe and Asia, following on the heels of the ROKR E6.
As if to rain on Motorola’s handset parade, Nokia pre-empted Zander’s launch by one day with its own announcement, that it was increasing its market share forecasts for the current second quarter, news that boosted its stock by almost 4% to just over $26 a share. Nokia said it expected to gain share thanks to a reduction in ‘excess device inventory’ by its competitors. In its recent first quarter earnings announcement, Nokia said it did not expect its market share, which it says is 36%, to increase during Q2. It did not give an exact prediction for its Q2 gain.
‘In its first quarter 2007 earnings announcement, Nokia said that it believed there had been an impact in the market from the excess inventory of certain of its competitors’ products in the first quarter,’ the firm said in announcing its revised forecasts. Now, ‘Nokia believes that its device shipments in the second quarter 2007 will be positively impacted, as excess device inventory in the market has sufficiently cleared.’
However, some analysts also think Motorola is now stabilizing its own market share, which has been under intense pressure. For instance, Ittai Kidron of CIBC World Markets wrote in a recent investor note that: ‘Our mid-quarter checks suggest Motorola has managed to stabilize its handset market share in most regions. We have seen evidence of two trends that illustrate the progress Motorola is making internally to address its issues: adoption of a firm global pricing policy (and adhering to it), and a shake-up in the global distribution system, reducing arbitrage activity and forcing regional sell-through disciplines.’
Despite these hopeful signs, Motorola is expected to cut more jobs in addition to the 3,500 layoffs it announced earlier this year, with CFO Thomas Meredith telling an investor meeting that the company ‘would announce additional downsizing and restructuring” at the end of this month. Analysts say Motorola will target cost savings ‘at least as large’ as the $400m the company cited when it announced 3,500 layoffs in January.
‘ Several new versions of the Motofone and its series, the stalwarts of the onslaught on emerging markets.