Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 May 2007

Cap on wireless access to Universal Service Fund raises rural fears

Mobile companies and consumer groups in the US are furious at a decision to cap grants to wireless carriers from the Universal Service Fund (USF), which is designed to aid the expansion of telecoms services in rural areas. While FCC chairman Kevin Martin has been vocal about promoting competition between telcos, cellcos, cablecos and broadband providers, he stands accused of failing to extend these policies to the remote rural heartlands, where it has often proved very hard to make a commercial business case. However, wireless networks – especially as the 700MHz spectrum, with its large cell support, becomes available – can often be a more economic way to bring broadband to sparse populations than wireline, and so the decision to limit help from the USF to these operators is widely seen as perverse.

In fact, the main motive behind the decision is to stem the flow of dollars out of the Fund until it can be totally overhauled. Few dispute that it needs reform, but many fear that the hiatus period while this is discussed will now prove very damaging to wireless operators and will delay consumer access to services for an unacceptably long period.

Earlier this month, the Federal-State Joint Board, which is dominated by Martin, recommended a temporary cap on USF support for wireless operators in rural areas, but did not impose any similar limits on wireline providers. With the Telecom Act in 1996, mobile operators were allowed to draw from the USF as well as their wireline cousins, to promote cheaper and more easily available services to low income rural areas such as native American reservations. All telecoms operators are required to contribute to the central fund, which is then dispersed among various programs, but the sum coming out of the USF has risen from $1.8bn in 1997 to $7.2bn in 2007 and critics claim the advances in universal access have not been anywhere like dramatic enough to justify this hike.

The decision to cap wireless, in particular, is not random – cellcos, because they can roll out services more quickly, are increasing their take from the Fund more rapidly too, with their share up to almost $1bn now, compared to $50m in 2002. Alltel is the largest recipient, drawing over $300m a year to serve poor counties in states such as South Dakota. Martin argues that providing high cost support for multiple cellular operators in the same market goes against the USF’s primary objective – to ensure there is a basic service at a reasonable price – and is financially unsustainable.

As with many subsidies, however, the USF can also have a negative effect on the competitive drive of the incumbents. As the rural landline operators lose custom to the cellcos, they actually get greater subsidy per line from the USF, and so have little motivation to fight for customers by introducing new services or tariffs, or by investing in wireless themselves.

The temporary cap is meant to end on November 1, when the Joint Board should have put together proposals on USF reform, and the FCC is under pressure to act on these within one year. However, none of these deadlines is binding and the process is widely expected to drag on longer, with a consequent blow to the growth of rural services.

The row is part of a wider debate in the US over the merits of subsidies versus open competition to make services, especially broadband, more readily available. The Bush administration, for instance, has eaten heavily into grants from the Rural Internet Access Authority, whose remit is to bring broadband access to the most remote areas of the country, and which has funded trials of WiMAX and other promising vehicles. The government argues that rural subsidies deter operators from investing in rural areas, and that a freer market would speed the adoption of new platforms. As the market matures, there is a case that the role of public grants may decline as broadband wireless, for the first time, gains the potential to support free market operators without subsidies, because of the lower cost of equipment, higher demand for broadband data and voice services and the availability of commodity silicon. For instance, Qwest, which sold its rural telephone business some year ago, has since relaunched into the market with services based on broadband wireless and satellite, for rural areas of the North West. If viable operators are seeing an economic reason to invest in such services, the need for subsidies is much reduced, except in extremely remote regions or hostile terrain, argues the anti-grants lobby. However, with the US having long ago fallen out of the world top 10 for broadband penetration, it seems premature to make that leap now.