Last Tuesday saw Sun announcing a Java platform for mobile media devices that could be its make or break move in the mobile world. Perhaps four years too late, Sun is finally turning its Java crown jewel to advantage, and taking on a welter of power players in the process, seeking its own key role in the evolution of the mobile internet. One of these players is Nokia – despite its powerful support for mobile Java, the Finnish company will not welcome Sun’s attempt to move into the area it regards as critical to its own success, the multimedia user interface.
This Tuesday, another Nokia enemy is to launch its own make or break product, as Motorola unveils its promised ‘media monster’ – a Java media handset aiming to fill the yawning gap in the company’s portfolio, and profit margin, left by the failure to replace RAZR effectively. It will be lost on few observers that Motorola’s CEO Ed Zander was previously second-in-command at Sun, and that of all the allies Sun could court for its quest for direct control of mobile Java, Motorola looks the most attractive.
There are many parallels between the two companies’ situations – both need to find a way to adapt their well engineered technologies lucratively for the mass emerging markets; both are in danger of being sidelined in the battle for control of the mobile internet; both are newly converted to open source models, but not entirely sure how to turn them to profit. And in a mobile world where power will increasingly revolve around the software – the user interface, the development framework, the browser – both are finding themselves up against some of the same rivals, most notably Nokia and Apple.
We have argued before how Nokia’s and Apple’s interests, despite the competition between their devices, often converge (see Wireless Watch January 15 2007). A parallel confluence of interests can be seen between Motorola, which is lagging behind the European phonemakers and Apple in the important area of the mobile internet software framework; and Sun, whose new mobile Java platforms so far lack significant device support.
Buoyed by the failure of corporate raider Carl Icahn to win a board director’s seat at last Monday’s annual shareholder meeting, Zander promised the investors a “media monster” with “unbelievable video capability” and increased focus on 3G, and gave a very bullish sneak preview of the new products at the Software 2007 conference later in the week. A range of new handsets is promised to try to woo back consumers and operators, one of them being a handset optimized for video with full motion, 30-frames a second display capability. The movies themselves will be held on ‘small removable storage cards’ that will fit into a slot on the side. The maker of these tiny SD cards is as-yet unnamed. There will also be music phones designed to take on successful models from Nokia and Sony Ericsson, and the imminent iPhone. All the models will be heavily oriented to 3G, where Motorola admits it has moved too slowly, and Java, where Nokia has recently stolen the initiative. The video phone will initially launch in Europe, since – despite investor concern about lagging in 3G – uptake in the US remains low to date.
Nokia – especially with its signs of belated success in Motorola’s US home territory, and its impressive lead in India – is the main target, but the headlines have predictably focused on the battle with the iPhone, which will ship next month. Zander chose to take a similar line to Nokia’s when Apple first announced its much-hyped multimedia device – that the product will be interesting, but too small scale to be more than a flea on the dragon’s back. When asked at Software 2007 “How do you deal with that?” Zander retorted: “How do they deal with us?” He did, however, agree that such high profile launches would enhance the market for everyone, saying “I think it’s going to, in some cases, reinforce what we have been trying to do and are doing with the mobile internet.”
But while the iPhone may not worry Motorola any time soon in terms of volumes, it does represent the kind of marketing magic that the phonemaker once enjoyed for RAZR, and has disastrously lost in recent months. It also promises a very advanced mobile internet experience, with fluid user interface, Ajax icons, the Safari browser and other hot-button features. Among the majors, only Nokia has such a sophisticated software framework for the internet handset, and Motorola needs to catch up.
Sun could certainly be a valuable ally, now it has decided, belatedly, to take direct action to drive the mobile Java market, rather than merely owning and licensing the core technology and letting the phonemakers and operators turn it to real products and real profits. Both Motorola and Nokia have been highly active in evolving mobile Java and implementing it on higher end devices, but recently Nokia seems to have put itself in the driving seat as it seeks to create de facto standards in mobile internet software, based around its Java-friendly frameworks such as the Series 60 interface platform (Motorola is using Sony Ericsson’s rival, UIQ, initially in its RIZR Z8 model). By contrast, Motorola has been a major driving force behind open source – open Java, Linux and other elements, and with strong support for the Apache Foundation for licensing. But it has not gained such a high profile in terms of actual Java products, certainly ones that have impact on the industry beyond the vendor’s own devices – the key goal for Nokia’s S60-related activities.
Sun could help it achieve this wider influence, provided, of course, that the Java owner actually delivers on its promises this time and gains serious support for its new technologies. Having sat on the commercial sidelines in mobile Java for years, letting Nokia, Ericsson and Motorola contribute the bulk of the product enhancements, Sun now wants its own slice of the action, as indicated when it acquired SavaJe and its Java-only mobile operating system last month (see Wireless Watch April 23 2007). It followed that announcement with the outline of new products at last week’s JavaOne conference, critically the JavaFX Mobile integrated platform, which combines OS, browser, user interface and other key elements of the mobile internet experience – all delivered in pure Java, and promising a far lower cost Java option, suited to midrange handsets and emerging markets as well as smartphones. Sun has also completed its project to make the bulk of its core Java technology open source under the GNU general public license version 2 (GPLv2).
JavaFX Mobile, which is underpinned by the new JavaFX scripting language, offers a complete mobile phone software system, available via OEM license to carriers, content owners and consumer electronics manufacturers. JavaFX sits on top of the secure Java platform already installed on 1.8bn handsets and is aimed at simplifying the creation and distribution of interactive content across platforms from handsets to set-tops to PCs. It will be available to the free and open source community via the GNU General Public License (GPL) license (not the Apache license favored by Motorola) and promises GUI building techniques to rival Nokia’s and iPhone’s, as well as effectively removing the need for a fat smartphone OS such as Windows, replacing it with a unified all-Java stack from OS to application (though unlike SavaJe in its original form, JavaFX Mobile can sit on top of Linux, likely in a more shrunken form than is seen on many smartphones).
Sun says it is now in talks with carriers and handset makers and hopes to see cellphones using its software ship in early 2008. It showed a demonstration running on a handset from Taiwan’s First International Computer, a device shaped much like the iPhone, and with an icon-based user interface also reminiscent of the Apple product. McNealy was not shy about going up against Apple, joking that Richard Green, head of Sun’s software group, who introduced JavaFX Mobile, looked like Steve Jobs. “We have our own shirtsleeve version of Steve Jobs announcing a phone,” McNealy said. More seriously, Green agreed that, by introducing a full software stack for a cellphone, Sun was going head-to-head with Nokia Series 60 and “I guess we are now in competition with them”. There is no indication of what Sun will charge for licenses, but it will distribute only in binary form to ensure compatibility.
Like the phonemakers, Sun wants to reap the rewards of the high growth mobile markets in developing economies, and has recognized that in many of these countries, the wireless handset will be the primary internet access mechanism, because of the low build-out of wired lines. That means that there should be high demand for internet phones, provided these can be produced at sufficiently low cost to tap a broad consumer base. This does not mean ultra-low cost handsets – the sector Motorola has over-enthusiastically chased, with the negative impact on its margins – but products geared to the growing middle and urban classes, which have at least moderate spending power. This is a tack also taken by Sony Ericsson and, to some extent, Nokia, hoping to preserve at least some of their margins by seeking to underpin the wireless internet in poorer countries, rather than chasing maximum market share by going after the voice consumer sector with sub-$50 phones.
Sun chairman Scott McNealy reinforced the company’s desire to drive Java into these new internet markets, rather than just focusing on its traditional high end smartphone base, by announcing JavaFX Mobile in a videoconference in Bangalore, India, as well as at JavaOne in San Francisco. He promised that Java mobile devices would enable low cost internet access and help bridge the digital divide, harping back to themes on which Sun has built its challenge to Microsoft for over a decade – that future communications and computing will rely not on fat PCs, but on thin clients with limited local intelligence but always-on wireless connections to the internet; plus software-as-a-service, large centralized grids, Java and open source software.
Not that JavaFX Mobile is all about low cost internet – it is also, as we have seen, about leapfrogging Nokia and others in the critical business of offering building blocks to create friendly and sophisticated user interfaces, so that consumers will finally feel happy actually to make heavy use of internet access on their phones, generating new business for the hard-pressed operators and extending their data revenues beyond SMS. It is too late for Sun to make a play to provide the operating system of choice for the handset, so the next best option is to make the OS less important, a process already recognized by Nokia with its shift of focus from SymbianOS to Series 60 and the browser, and to try to set new goalposts in the sort of tools that will be used for building mobile media products like the iPhone.
With the recent acquisition of SavaJe, whose technology is the basis of JavaFX, Sun is taking on not just Nokia but other powerful forces – Apple, Qualcomm’s Brew/UIone, Microsoft Silverlight, Adobe Apollo, and potentially the rise of Ajax-based techniques, (although if Sun has any sense, it will take a leading role in converging these with Java rather than seeking to kill the momentum created by Yahoo, Apple and others behind the online programming system).
Sun says that using SavaJe technologies, JavaFX Mobile will offer a unified runtime environment to drive rich, dynamic content which can be written once for many devices, from set-tops to PCs to handsets. Vodafone was on the Sun podium welcoming the JavaFX range and talking about using it to drive a unified Java solution on mobile devices, but clearly even greater prizes for the Sun concept of all-encompassing Java will be converged carriers delivering services across multiple connections and clients using common interfaces, one of the key goals of the quad play trend (and another area where it could work closely with Motorola, with its set-top business). In search of this largely untapped customer base, Sun will deliver additional JavaFX products for the manufacturers of set-top boxes, navigation devices and automobile dashboards. Sun’s message to operators and handset makers alike was that JavaFX Mobile, because it is built around standard Java APIs, will drive down porting costs and make it quicker to build new rich data applications.
All this sounds highly promising, and the emerging market story rings true because there is very little legacy to deal with. In more traditional sectors, though, Sun will face the same problems as other Java-oriented platforms before it, notably fragmentation and the challenge of supporting the huge installed base with new updates. Joint efforts driven by major operators, notably Vodafone, have pushed the industry into harmonizing their efforts rather more effectively, but one of the reasons for the interest in Ajax is the continuing presence of so many Java variants, a situation that the open source process is unlikely to help. The problem Java’s mobile version, J2ME, has faced, has been that the billions of handsets already in the market cannot usually be easily updated to support new technologies. This means Sun, Adobe and the others may release an advanced and largely unified technology for media mobiles, but they need to convince content and application developers to support technologies that are inaccessible to the bulk of the market. SavaJe, once its role as a political pawn for the operators in their war with the handset makers was exhausted, was unsuccessful in attracting many platform vendors or developers, and even Nokia and Apple face significant challenges in building up their developer base quickly enough to dilute Microsoft’s advantages in this respect – a huge programmer base and a forcibly unified platform.