Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 May 2007

Google’s spectrum auction proposal steps up pressure for new regulatory thinking

Nobody knows how to promote somebody else’s good idea like Google, and get it the attention it deserves. The company is throwing its considerable weight behind any changes that will open up more spectrum and so boost usage of the mobile internet – and with it Google-style online services and advertising. Its well publicized, if somewhat disappointing, backing of municipal Wi-Fi, lobbying for license-exempt allocations in 700MHz and elsewhere, even rumors it would purchase its own spectrum – all these show Google seeking to add to the capacity and economy of using the internet wirelessly. Now it has taken an idea more commonly associated with IBM and Sun, and proposed to the FCC a scheme that would support a common grid of wireless spectrum, that could be used and paid for by various providers on an ‘on-demand’ basis. This is a concept that is familiar in the enterprise technology sector, and in utilities such as power, but in wireless there has been little middle ground between fully owned spectrum (either directly operated or wholesaled) and unlicensed airspace. To add a Google-like twist, the company is suggesting that the mechanism for buying time on the spectrum should be a real time auction, with pricing therefore fluctuating according to demand rather like a commodities or currency market.

Basically, the Google system would allow potential service providers to bid in real time in an auction for the rights to use a piece of spectrum for a pre-determined period, which could be very short – “a year, a month or even two seconds”, as the filing puts it. It would be similar in concept to AdWords, a service Google offers in which companies bid against each other to have their adverts displayed against key search terms inserted in the Google engine. Primary licensees would acquire spectrum in the usual way, and then run the auctions for third party bidders. “Licensees in this case can in some sense be an intermediary between the airwaves and people who want to use it,” said Richard Whitt, telecom and media counsel for Google and author of the filing. “What we’re looking for is the FCC to give us the flexibility to explore the business and financial relationships between the licensee, those who build the infrastructure and those who want to be retailers.”

Google is taking a slightly different approach to a familiar problem – how to enable smaller, innovative providers to gain access to sufficient spectrum. There are two main reasons this is important – to encourage new and potentially disruptive applications, and to support operators that are prepared to build a business in underserved areas such as very rural regions. In many cases, these companies have to choose between buying spectrum in a pre-commercial phase, building a business with a view to selling out once the large players get involved; or relying on the vagaries of license-exempt bandwidth, a route that – as Wi-Fi has shown us – carries few obvious profit models. Regulators take various approaches to trying to redress the balance and enable smaller operators to acquire spectrum for sustainable long term business plans – excluding tier one carriers, as Japan has recently done in 2.5GHz; reserving certain licenses for new providers, as the US may do in 700MHz – but too often these good intentions become diverted by the lure of the major cellcos’ dollars. Also, artificially bringing independents into the market carries significant risk – that they will fail to build out at all, or will not be able to support a full service (remember the first incarnation of NextWave); or that they will merely sell on to large carriers anyway.

So the idea of putting some spectrum into a pool that is managed by a centralized body – whether a super-carrier or an agency – does seem to offer greater flexibility and the chance for companies to try out new models without massive upfront capex commitment and risk. Google’s view is that much of that problem would be “alleviated by a more open and market driven spectrum access policy”, although it said it would have no plans itself to acquire spectrum. Its suggestions will be welcome to other organizations that have been toying with more creative approaches to spectrum allocation and usage, but have lacked Google’s profile and ability to make market noise. In particular, the upcoming US 700MHz auctions will become a heated debating ground for these issues, since these bands are so valuable for rural access, with the large cell sizes; mobile and converged access with the low frequencies; and are also set to be a key element of the US’ public safety policy going forward. Frontline Wireless and Cyren Call, while focused mainly on public safety, have also favored flexible spectrum usage – with commercial applications giving way to emergency response when required, rather than all the bandwidth being reserved for safety at all times.

Google’s idea is presumably designed to provoke thought and continue to change the climate of opinion around spectrum, rather than having any real chance of being adopted as it stands. It highlights in a very public way the need for more spectrum, and a greater variety of service providers with more flexible obligations and pricing. It also addresses the issue of spectrum waste, where providers buy licenses that include more bandwidth than they can use, or to take the bands out of the market. The challenges and risks in building a system such as Google envisages, the powerful opposition of the established telcos, and many legal and technical issues, make the idea unworkable. But the more such debates are aired, the more likely it becomes that regulatory thinking will change in the major wireless markets, to reflect a more dynamic and multi-faceted mobile world.