With the iPhone due to ship in at last at the end of this month, rivals like Sony and Palm are marshalling their own forces, and Apple is showing larger phonemakers how to reassert the upper hand over the network owners.
The device maker has taken a leaf out of RIM’s book and used the huge profile of its iPhone to win many concessions from its first cellco partner, AT&T Mobility – concessions which give it a level of control that Nokia could only dream of in the US. It emerged from comments made last week by Charles Dunstone, CEO of Carphone Warehouse – which is trying to do its own deal for the European iPhone – that Apple will require its servers to be placed deep into the operator’s network. Only with the servers in place will the handset’s full range of functions work.
For Apple, this arrangement gives it a far closer, more co-dependent relationship with the cellcos than handset makers typically have, and almost certainly means it is taking a share of the revenues from the advanced services involved. This points to a new approach for device makers, and one that borrows more heavily on the internet model than the traditional mobile market. Revenue sharing and services that are confined to just one network both deepen the investment and commitment both partners are making, and make it harder for the carrier to sideline the handset once the next glitzy product comes along. This level of commitment will also benefit the operator by keeping iPhone users locked into its network, since inserting another cellco’s SIM card in one of the gadgets would mean losing many of the functions. This, in turn, will make the carrier more willing to subsidize the product, which may prove an important factor to Apple’s sales targets of 10m iPhones next year, given its high price tag.
Apple’s stance is not new – RIM also requires its operator partners to route all Blackberry traffic through its email servers and takes a share of messaging revenues – but it may attract more scrutiny because of the profile of the iPhone. In particular, any European cellcos that do not win an iPhone deal – currently, Telefonica is said to be heading the running – could seek to exploit the European Commission’s increasing sensitivity about mobile network lock-ins. And this structure would not appeal to Carphone Warehouse – Europe’s largest phone retailer – which relies on its ability to mix and match handsets and operator contracts for its volumes and differentiation. Dunstone may be particularly concerned by some of the tactics envisaged by Apple and AT&T for the US launch, which involve a higher than usual usage of direct sales via internet and stores.
While Apple’s approach has clear commercial benefits for both sides, if translated to Europe it will represent an unwelcome backwards step in the painfully slow progress towards an open mobile internet. Apple appears to have a non-standard, non-GSM way of authenticating its devices, which creates a new walled garden. While the iPhones remain GSM-based, this will not matter very much, since very few of the advanced multimedia services people envisage being driven by iPhone will work on such a slow connection. But as they are upgraded in 2008 onwards to HSPA, we will see the attempt to rebuild the garden walls around a specific mobile content experience and use the appeal of the Apple brand to lock users into a particular carrier’s services.
Meanwhile, the next big buzz in mobile phones could be the rumored Sony PSP handset. Last month, the Japanese giant struck a deal with British Telecom to turn the PlayStation Portable (PSP) gaming device into a VoIP phone, but now a US Patent and Trademark Office application filed by the company’s handset joint venture Sony Ericsson has surfaced, pointing towards a fully fledged PSP cellphone. The application, originally filed in November, shows diagrams of a device similar to a PSP, with a rotating display, and designed to be used as a mobile phone, TV or gaming console depending on the configuration. This would be a logical extension of Sony Ericsson’s successful use of classic Sony brands, notably Walkman and Cybershot, in handsets targeted at particular applications (music, photography and now gaming).
Meanwhile, Palm is also bracing itself to compete with the iPhone, claiming Apple and RIM are the only mobile device makers, apart from itself, that understand software and so can create a real applications ecosystem around their platforms. The Treo maker gained a new lease on life last week, taking on private equity funding after months of takeover rumors, and adding the cachet of hiring one of the chief architects of the Apple iPod. The move looks like a step by financiers to grab the Palm brand and turn it into an Apple iPhone rival, and in doing so, snatch some of the kudos associated with new handset user interfaces.
The deal is with private equity firm Elevation Partners, the investment arm of U2 band front man Bono. The company will plough in a mere $325m into Palm, but at the same time borrow $400m in order to sweeten the deal with a $9 a share cash distribution.
The Apple name is retired iPod engineer Jon Rubinstein, former senior vice president of hardware engineering and head of the iPod division at Apple, who will take over as executive chairman at Palm. Elevation directors Fred Anderson, who was once CFO of Apple, and Roger McNamee, a co-founder of Silver Lake Partners, will join the board and replace various board members, including Eric Benhamou who ran 3Com when it owned Palm.
Rubinstein’s lineage is what is driving this deal though. He joined Apple in 1997 and has been part of the company’s turnaround, overhauling engineering teams, product roadmaps and manufacturing processes, and making Apple the nimble CE manufacturer it is today.
Rubinstein’s CV says that he is credited with conceiving the iPod, but given what we know about Apple, this was likely a consensus design that went right to the top of the company.
Palm’s CEO Ed Colligan said: “Jon Rubinstein is one of the top engineering executives in Silicon Valley, and he will lead our product development efforts. As a significant new investor, Elevation brings onboard unique partners and relationships, plus a long investment horizon.’
Rubinstein said of the deal, “I am thrilled by the prospect of helping Palm deliver innovative products capable of transforming the mobile device market. Approximately one billion cellphones are sold each year, and mobile computing is a category with enormous potential. This is a company with an impressive history of introducing game changing products, and I intend to help extend that legacy.”
Under the terms of the recapitalization plan, Elevation will purchase $325m of a new series of convertible preferred stock. The conversion price will be $8.50 per share, which represents a premium of approximately 16% to the implied post-distribution price over the 10 trading days ended June 1, 2007, excluding the $9 per share cash distribution. Upon completion of the transaction, Elevation will own around 25% of Palm’s stock.
Palm says it will use the proceeds from the $400m of new debt to fund a cash distribution, but the total proceeds to be distributed to shareholders is around $940m, so it will also use up a lot of existing cash, suggesting they need to buy shareholder goodwill to avoid the deal being blocked. The distribution represents more than 50% of Palm’s current market capitalization and the company expects to have over $300m of cash after it is completed. Attempting to allay concerns about having to borrow cash to complete the deal, Palm CFO Andy Brown noted that the company’s ratio of net debt to its earnings remains quite low. “We feel very comfortable that this is the right capital structure and leaves us with a strong balance sheet,” he said on a conference call with investors.
The deal will close in the third quarter but this is a definitive purchase agreement and the board of Palm has already unanimously approved the deal.
But while the transaction will put Palm on a stronger footing and generally pleased analysts, it faces the same problems as before – falling market share, shrinking differentiation from other smartphone vendors, lukewarm response to its newest product, and a confused operating system strategy that has led to it developing and supporting three OSs. Rubinstein could help change all that, but at Apple he was working within a structure that was geared up to embrace new concepts and take radical steps. He may not find Palm so effective at turning bright ideas into commercial realities.