Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

25 June 2007

Brew wins with KTF and 3 balance further ITC setbacks for Qualcomm

Despite the best lobbying efforts of the US wireless industry, the International Trade Commission has upheld its ban on imports of new handsets containing Qualcomm chips. The chipmaker’s main hope is now a presidential veto of the ban, based on the damage a lack of new handsets would cause major carriers like Verizon Wireless, Sprint Nextel and Alltel. But whatever the outcome, the decision highlights what is well known, not least within Qualcomm itself, that a rethink of its business models will be required as it ventures forward into a more competitive market and one that will not necessarily be driven by its CDMA technologies. One sign of a possible new flexibility was seen in the royalty-free licensing of Qualcomm’s MediaFLO mobile TV platform to Siano Mobile Silicon. As so often, while the larger company remains obdurate in its core businesses, it tries out more innovative approaches in its emerging activities. Even more than in MediaFLO, the indications of the most creative thinking within the company are often seen on its emergent software side, and this was very clear at last week’s annual conference for developers on the Brew content platform, with Qualcomm coming to terms with Korean challenger WIPI and signing another non-CDMA operator, mobile internet flagwaver 3.

The ITC ruling, which followed a successful claim by Broadcom that Qualcomm’s chips infringed one of its low power patents, was upheld on Friday, but the larger company will now turn to the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in Washington DC, which typically handles appeals in patent cases. Qualcomm is also seeking to make a case that the ITC has “overstepped its statutory boundaries’.

In the mean time, it was focusing on Brew, signing content deals with MLB Advanced Media, the interactive arm of Major League Baseball, and Warner Music Group. Both will use the new BrandXtend Signature Solution, which enables content providers to deliver directly to mobile devices under their own brand and without necessarily doing a deal with a carrier ‘ a reflection of the multi-brand, multi-route strategy also supported by Nokia’s mobile content architecture, Widsets. This shows the content makers getting involved not just in distributing their wares to the new mobile platform, but getting directly involved in the quest to enhance the mobile internet user interface to boost usage ‘ Warner will develop a series of downloadable artist-branded themes for handsets using Qualcomm’s UIone interface technology, one of the most advanced attempts to provide an attractive internet experience on the handset.

Also new to the Brew content platform are the Client 4-Series developer tools, which Qualcomm claims will make it easier for phonemakers and programmers to work together, and therefore get attractive content to handsets more quickly and cheaply. The new client architecture lets OEMs expose hardware and software layers to their developer partners and gives developers content framework support, for improved discovery, delivery and installation of content. Brew Client 4-Series provides a highly integrated application execution environment with inbuilt support for security and digital rights management. The first user of the technology was CDMA stalwart KDDI of Japan, whose KDDI Common Platform (KCP) uses a specially tailored Brew Client 4. General availability of the technology is scheduled for the first quarter of 2008.

By making content creation in Brew easier, Qualcomm aims to steal a march on other environments, particularly those using native Java, which recently received a major boost from Sun’s launch of FX Mobile. While Brew is a natural choice for CDMA operators, it has far wider ambitions than that, representing ‘ along with the associated UIone ‘ Qualcomm’s best chance of gaining influence, beyond just chip sales, in the W-CDMA world. All the major vendors need to take a strong position in guiding the evolution of the mobile internet, and while Qualcomm has strong tools, it needs to ensure their impact is felt beyond the confines of the CDMA2000 platform.

Its first major victory in this respect was the 2005 signing of O2 for UIone, and it has also scored a win for its Brew Gaming Signature product at Telecom Italia, representing a gradual incursion behind the western European barricades, and also has smaller non-CDMAS wins in Sweden, Taiwan and Russia. Now it has followed that with a ground breaking deal with Hutchison’s 3G arm, 3.

3, which transformed itself last year from a leader of the walled garden movement to one of the most advanced mobile internet operators, will now tap into the Brew developer ecosystem to add new applications to its X-Series platform. Having found few differentiating applications for its 3G-only network beyond cheap voice, the European provider is looking to blaze a trail into open internet access from the handset and so steal a march on Vodafone and others. The company said that rapid and low cost deployment of new content services will be fundamental to the model and Brew will support this, with its readymade content aggregation and distribution facilities and advanced over the air capabilities. The relatively ‘out of the box’ qualities of the Brew platform are appealing to operators, and the various Java alternatives, despite their content richness, are still lagging behind in this respect, even with efforts like Nokia Preminet starting to close the gap.

Last November, 3 unveiled its X-Series broadband internet service, based on the combination that will be essential to all operators in mobile broadband – of flat rates; bundling of different content and media; multiple platform support including television; and web 2.0 functions and payment models. Following the trend for cellcos to get close to internet players, the offering was launched in partnership with most of the big movers of the mobile internet – Skype, Sling Media, Yahoo, Google, eBay, Microsoft and Orb, as well as handset makers Nokia and Sony Ericsson. 3 says it aims to extend core applications and functions from the broadband internet model to the handset, with a new pricing model that also borrows heavily from the PC internet, offering flat monthly fees. Such an approach will be the way that cellcos hit back against alternative wireless operators that are using Wi-Fi and WiMAX to provide mobile broadband with multimedia at flat rates, replicating the PC experience on smaller devices. But differentiated user interfaces and services, updated in rapid succession and heavily customized to the user, will be the key to keeping customers online and spending, even when there are many mobile internet offerings to choose from, and 3 -which already offers Java-based downloads – sees Brew as a useful weapon in that ongoing battle.

Frank Meehan, director and general manage at the global 3G handset and application group of 3’s parent Hutchison Whampoa, commented: ‘Using Brew, we can embed applications on the handset to deliver a single integrated user experience, which in turn will encourage take-up of our services.’ 3 has commercial 3G services in Italy, the UK, Australia, Austria, Sweden, Denmark, Hong Kong, Israel and Ireland and totals about 13.5m customers and one of the highest data ARPUs in Europe at around $25 a month.

In a more natural market for Qualcomm, South Korea, the complexities of its relationship with key CDMA operators is seen once again in another important victory for Brew – the agreement by operator KTF to deploy a content service combining Brew with WIPI, the homegrown Korean alternative. WIPI was created by the Korean cellcos at the turn of the decade and mandated by the government as a way to reduce royalties dependence on Qualcomm. Since volume implementation in 2005, usage of Brew is said to have halved, hitting Qualcomm hard in the first ever market for the territory. Now, KTF is offering an LG handset running WIPI 2.0.B. which runs the Korean platform on Brew, and will power its ‘Magic n’ Show Downloadpack’ data service. Significantly, this offering will be delivered over W-CDMA, marking another inroad by Brew outside the CDMA homeland – and epitomizing its parent’s hope that, even in markets like Korea where it is faced with the loss of a CDMA monopoly, it can claw back some ground through W-CDMA chip sales to old allies like LG, and through multi-platform Brew.

The KTF deal can be seen as proof that – as in China – the best efforts of the Asian nations to create their own standards are not yet resulting in fully mature technologies, driving the operators to skirt round government mandates and continue to adopt the more advanced offerings of the traditional vendors (though, no doubt, on more favorable terms, now they have their homegrown standards to use as bargaining chips). But it also reflects Qualcomm’s willingness to promote its own technologies by forging close relationships with carriers, often bypassing the equipment makers in between, and even taking stakes in them – it is one of the largest shareholders in KTF, Korea’s second largest cellco after SKT, and the operator made it clear that it had launched the new hybrid service “at the request of Qualcomm”. The real test for the future of Brew in Korea will be whether SKT will take up a similar approach. Arvin Chander, vice president of global carrier relations for Qualcomm Internet Services, is keen that Brew should be seen by operators as a tool not just for improving services to their own subscribers, but for devising offerings that can be sold on to other non-competing carriers – an increasing focus of activity among the large Asian operators as they seek new revenue streams beyond their own saturated territories. DoCoMo and KT are already looking to sell applications and expertise to operators in smaller south east Asian economies, and Qualcomm can see WIPI on Brew providing a similar opportunity for KTF.

Of course, a potential fly in the Brew ointment is the fact that Nokia has extended its patent countersuits against Qualcomm to the software technology, and to MediaFLO, upping the stakes in its royalties battle with the CDMA giant by claiming rights in its key high growth new technologies. So, back on the IPR front, news that Qualcomm had licensed its MediaFLO technology to Siano Mobile Silicon with no royalty payments might continue to fuel the legal fires, given that Nokia happens to believe that it holds the core patents to IP datacasting and so might feel that Qualcomm is giving its IP rights away.

The fact that Qualcomm feels compelled not to charge for a new technology might hint at a new flexibility in its licensing habits, or serve to demonstrate how DVB-H continues to have the global whip hand in the mobile TV market. Other successes for the standard were touted last week, as MiTV and Nokia said they had a live DVB-H mobile TV service ready for Malaysia; TVI Portugal and Vodafone Portugal announced they had completed successful trials using DVB-H with help from France’s Thomson; France’s Expway said that it will provide the Elecronic Services Guide to be used by Hiwire in its Las Vegas DVB-H trial, which continues to remind us that MediaFLO will not have a free run in the US; while Envivio said that its had provided encoders for a Philippine roll-out of DVB-H, happening far earlier than anyone had expected.

Siano has a multi-format mobile TV tuner that works with DVB-H, T-DMB, DAB IP and other systems. By agreeing that it will add MediaFLO in some future version, it is taking on a big extra workload, in order to get a piece of an unquantified market, while at the same time agreeing to compete head-on with Qualcomm itself. By contrast, DVB-H market leader DiBcom has all but ruled out a shift to MediaFLO.

US start-up Newport Media is the only other mobile TV specialist that has signed a MediaFLO license, and this was recently admitted by Qualcomm also to be royalty free (MediaFLO licensing terms are confusing because of the Qualcomm policy of bundling royalties for new technologies with existing ones for CDMA). PCCW of Hong Kong is the latest operator to trial MediaFLO. Its CTO Paul Berriman said: ‘The Hong Kong market is ready for this type of service, which is complementary to our 3G-based interactive multimedia services, and we want to offer the best quality solution to our end-users. MediaFLO’s demonstrated success in recent trials and promises a compelling user experience that has the potential for widespread adoption in Hong Kong.’

This, then, is the new face of Qualcomm – aiming for the same influence over how mobile content and data is delivered to handsets as it did over the handsets themselves. Enhanced Brew content delivery and branding mechanisms, MediaFLO and UIone are just the key building blocks in what CEO Paul Jacobs envisions as a far broader multimedia content platform that will go beyond the handset. Delivering the keynote address at the Brew 2007 conference in San Diego, he stressed that Qualcomm is no longer about pushing one particular network. ‘We believe the device of the future is compatible with multiple networks. There’s going to be a lot of people that want to choose the device they use based on what they want to do with it,’ he said. Therefore the company with the real power is the one with the enabling technology for richer services, hence the MediaFLO/Brew/UIone triumvirate. And Jacobs sees MediaFLO taking a role beyond just television, using its datacasting capabilities to deliver a wide range of information services in a modern and interactive way to multiple devices, not just handsets. ‘There’s no one killer app. It’s really about having a portfolio of services and content,’ he said. ‘MediaFLO really is about much more than TV. If we only deliver TV to the phone I think we really fail at what we want to do with MediaFLO.’

WIPI

WIPI recently gained a boost as a potential international platform when it was accepted, in May, as part of the roadmap of the operator-driven Open Mobile Terminal Platform (OMTP), which seeks to set standards for handset specifications.

WIPI (Wireless Internet Platform for Interoperability) was created by the Korean Wireless Internet Standardization Forum (KWISF) in direct response to the major cellcos’ demands for an alternative to Brew, which would reduce their royalty payments to Qualcomm. It was one of the first signs of Korea’s bid to seize the initiative in next generation wireless standards and shift the balance of power and intellectual property eastwards. Initially, when WIPI was adopted by the operators, it was seen simply as a way to reduce dependence on Qualcomm, but it has since become part of a broader agenda to put east Asia in the 4G driving seat, one in which Korea is now closely allied with China.

While other efforts, notably mobile WiMAX, have already started to gain international acceptance, WIPI has remained specifically Korean, despite the increasing profile of mobile content systems, as the operators strive to find a workable mobile internet experience and business case. But now the Korean approach is starting to creep beyond its home borders, and adoption into the canon of OMTP technologies is a major step forward. The body is operator driven and the members aim to create a set of specifications for future devices, which will enable them to dictate terms to the vendors – some carriers claim their wishes were fatally ignored during the run-up to 3G – and to insist on a unified base design, leading to reduced time to market and lower prices. OMTP executives said they had been impressed by the Korean operators’ success in creating a harmonized platform, which had simplified their sourcing of multimedia devices and reduced their costs and development overheads.

Any technology that is accepted as part of the OMTP roadmap will gain the great advantage of access to the volume market and likely adoption by all the major device manufacturers. Under the terms of the new memorandum of understanding between the two bodies, they have agreed to work together to drive international standards, and KWISF will intent to incorporate OMTP recommendations in its future specifications. This will be important for WIPI to extend its reach. A Korean Ministry of Communications official said: “Exports of WIPI will be facilitated now that the two organizations agreed on standardization.” Outside Korea, WIPI is being adopted by Helio, the US MVNO run by a joint venture between SKT and Earthlink. It is also under technical discussion for adoption in China, Taiwan, Thailand, Kazakhstan and Israel.

WIPI provides a standardized environment for mounting and implementing applications downloaded to mobile terminals and its common interface layer makes it easier for developers to create multimedia content. It is based on Java but can also support Brew. However, its scope is being broadened as it evolves – as is Brew’s, of course – to become a comprehensive set of application interfaces to create a fully fledged mobile internet platform. At this stage, the political battle for next generation standards influence will really begin in earnest.