Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

25 June 2007

Clearwire-satellite tie-up could double the operator’s value

The basic economics underlying the deals between Clearwire and both DirecTV and EchoStar are so compelling, that given decent execution and an increase in the rate of build-out by Clearwire, the outcome could be a doubling in the value of all three organizations.

The underlying rules of thumb for valuations of pay TV and other operators are simple. They are essentially bound up in the amount of cash they can generate now and in the future, and the likelihood of this increasing or decreasing due to churn rates, ARPU and network improvement. A small change in churn can create a large change in stock value.

The coming together of three determined corporate cultures used to success, and unafraid of gambling, is set to create a third end-to-end quadruple play in the US, to compete with the cable-Sprint combination and the RBOCs (see Wireless Watch June 16 2007). Of course this depends entirely on the way in which the efforts of the Direct to Home (DTH) satellite providers and those of Clearwire are integrated.

At present, Clearwire is attracting around 50,000 new customers each quarter, although this is accelerating at around 8,000 per quarter. It is doing this with a brand that has quite simply not been heard of among the US public, with a network footprint of only 36 US markets, covering just 9m US citizens. It has deals with AOL and retailer BestBuy to help speed up progress, but even if Clearwire continues its build out at the current pedestrian rate, it has enough spectrum to eventually reach 117m US citizens, in places where it can offer 30MHz of spectrum, which is what it currently believes is the best basis for its service. If it decides that it can manage with less spectrum, it says it can reach a population of 223m in the US, out of a total of 300m. These two figures represent 40% and 74% of the total US population, which is an exceptionally high number for a wireless footprint, beaten perhaps only by Sprint’s 2.5GHz licenses and the combination of the two largest RBOCs, which have less appealing spectrum for broadband, but of course also have fixed lines.

On top of this it must be remembered that Clearwire has spectrum to reach 199m Europeans across Belgium, Germany, Ireland, Poland, Romania and Spain. It has been extremely active in cutting deals for roaming and for cross-marketing in all of the other markets where WiMAX spectrum has been auctioned. In other words, through partnerships, it is likely to offer more than double this roaming footprint across Europe.

The reason for building out in 30MHz of spectrum is that it has, to date, been trying to offer all things to all people and to be in a position to compete with DSL and cable bandwidths. It certainly does not need 30MHz at present – it offers only around 1.5Mbps broadband to customers, plus fixed voice, and will gradually move to portable and eventually mobile voice services, which will take a very small part of that available spectrum. But just because Clearwire’s current implementation only gives customers a reliable 1.5 Mbps, doesn’t meant that it has to stay that way. The 802.16e standard relies on using 4,000 carriers, and properly used this can increase the throughput on existing tower and base station layouts.

A WiMAX base station will usually use one of six channels for each of six radios, each addressing 60 degrees of a 360 degree coverage area. Each one will work in a different channel so the neighboring base stations won’t conflict with the signal. If the aggregate bandwidth available to that 60 degree arc is not enough, more base stations can be inserted between existing base stations, backhaul permitting, which will offer services on different channels. In this way a WiMAX network can grow slowly over time removing the need to put in all of the capex upfront. Since it usually has at least 32 levels of quality of service, achieved by allocating a set number of carriers to each activity, different customers can be offered differing levels of service. So it’s not that 1.5 Mbps is some kind of physical limit to the technology, more that this is an informed decision about what the market requires, allowing the cheapest level of network build at a given point.

As Clearwire moves on to 802.16e compatible equipment, there will be even more flexibility. At the WiMAX World Europe event last month, Clearwire was boasting that it would soon be able to introduce more nomadic and even mobile options to its service. It has been carrying out first phase trials of 802.16e compliant equipment in Hillsboro, a suburb of Portland, Oregon and claimed the results exceeded the expectations, with average user speeds of 2-4Mbps. So, 1.5 Mbps is a movable feast and, with astute network planning, a more dense base station population and migration to 802.16e equipment, Clearwire can offer customers something closer to 4Mbps.

The importance of this in the DirecTV-EchoStar deal is that it can better support one key function that the DTH partners needs, video on demand. This is a core selling point for the cable companies and will be for the RBOCs once their IPTV operations are running problem free – but the satellite operators cannot offer VoD. Both of them are currently offering it piecemeal on broadband lines that they don’t own, but this could become an Achilles Heel if Net Neutrality laws are never passed (and in the US they look like never being passed under the current administration).

That kind of broadband line is plenty fast enough for an SD video signal, and given that VoD tends to need provisioning for at a ratio of 10:1 (one customer in 10 is currently watching a VoD service), rather than the contention ratio of delivering SD broadcast video (every home watching it at once) it should be able to support that application. In fact a WiMAX network could be configured to recognize a video file download, work out that the network isn’t that busy right now and deliver it ahead of real time at the fastest speed a CPE radio can take, around 23Mbps, to DVR storage. Over time WiMAX networks will get smart to this and configure accordingly. This might mean that DVR-based VoD could be worked with HD files.

WiMAX has always been inherently fast enough to support non-HD video on demand. But it isn’t fast enough for broadcast SD TV in its current iteration, and it won’t be ready for HD VoD without further work on in the next generation or so, perhaps ten years (also near HD streaming quality will be achievable on a 4Mbps connection in the next few years, given codec advancement).

So, in a way, the reason that DTH and WiMAX are perfect partners is that each suffers from a weakness. WiMAX can offer VoD, VoIP and HTML browsing and other best effort internet applications, but not broadcast TV, while DTH can offer SD and HD broadcast TV only.

The combination puts a single, two-stage platform in a position where it can deliver everything that cable and the RBOCs can do and that includes the provision of a mobile TV option, either through the use of multicasting on WiMAX or more likely through another Craig McCaw company, ICO Global Communications, which has just signed with Alcatel-Lucent to deliver mobile TV from its satellite by 2008 using DVB-SH.

By using standard customer relationship management techniques the DTH companies can target the areas that Clearwire has already built out, and drive up density so that the networks are full, or close to capacity in a short period of time. They would probably get most benefit from pushing this into homes which they currently have not previous been able to attract, getting a double payback on their marketing activity.

That will make an enormous change to the speed at which Clearwire markets which have been built out, are profitable. And this will be especially effective if it is marketed as a ‘triple play’ for $99 (or less) in the same way that Comcast and Verizon are both marketing such services from their web sites.

And if a market is profitable more rapidly, then Clearwire can accelerate its rate of build-out, virtually doubling it overnight and coming closer to total net additions of about 360,000 in a year – getting closer to the type of numbers that the DTH companies are more used to, which is 200,000 to 225,000 a quarter each.

And if the DTH companies are bringing business at that rate, then Clearwire would be only too happy to let them dictate the most advantageous markets in which to build out its network. So in the same way Verizon can dictate to MediaFLO into which markets to go next, EchoStar and DirecTV could agree between them the markets where cable (and potentially the RBOCs) are weakest (or strongest). And at that rate it only takes a couple of years until every sign up is a triple play sign up across the entire US. Instead of taking five years to break even, Clearwire could either break even sooner, or it could build out its full spectrum ownership a hell of a lot faster. In our view Craig McCaw is not interested in building immediate profit, he wants to drive up exit value in five years’ time.

The ensuing combination of an existing, working hybrid between WiMAX and DTH would likely create an eruption of lookalikes over the next few years across Europe.
News Corp may have dragged its heels with regard to signing up Clearwire inside the US, but once it is handed a working formula on a plate, it may be likely to sign up local WiMAX franchises across the world, to work with its abundant supply of DTH services. In the UK its BSkyB DTH service has already gone down the broadband route, but there it was forced to buy the leading DSL unbundled loop supplier and invest heavily in further DSL plant which was far more expensive than buying or partnering with an incumbent WiMAX play.

There is one other issue to consider here – in order to cover both of its bases, AT&T could perhaps agree to buy EchoStar, and offer both U-Verse and Homezone in perpetuity. If that was a likelihood, then why would EchoStar have joined in the party and agreed to resell the Clearwire broadband service? But now that it has shown that it will go up against the RBOCs if it has to, it gives AT&T an extra reason to consider making overtures to EchoStar.

This analysis was first published by our sister service Faultline, which focuses on the economics of the quad play and provides weekly insights into the broadband digital media markets.