Bluetooth may be a standard that has always over-promised and under-delivered, but it certainly knows how to strengthen its case by embracing potential rivals, rather than engaging in the sort of destructive feuds we have seen in broadband wireless and WLan. In April last year the technology’s ruling body, the Bluetooth Special Interest Group (SIG), said it would adopt the WiMedia Alliance’s UltraWideBand system as the basis of a future iteration, to take advantage of that potential rival’s low power, high speed qualities. Now it has agreed to take the Nokia-inspired Wibree platform into its fold, again deflecting the risk of fragmentation in the wireless personal area networking (WPan) sector, one that is very dependent on the mass volumes that harmonization brings.
Wibree was developed by Nokia six years ago and launched into the market a year ago. Although there were fears it would be presented as a vendor controlled alternative to Bluetooth, it works better as a complement, since it addresses devices with extremely low power capacity such as watches and heart rate monitors, and can allow them to compete with other devices such as Bluetooth handsets. Bluetooth is really too power hungry for such minute gadgets (it uses 10 times more power than Wibree), but a combination with higher powered cellphones could drive applications such as health monitoring for the elderly. IMS Research was one analyst company that was cheered by the news of collaboration, predicting that shipments of Wibree integrated circuits would now reach tens of millions very quickly, and that Bluetooth-Wibree dual-mode ICs would exceed 120m units in 2011.’
The clear symbiosis of Wibree and Bluetooth begs the question, why was the initiative not taken under the auspices of the SIG from the start? Answer, greater control for Nokia as the technology is presented readymade, rather than subject to the politicking of standards committees. And what of the Bluetooth plan to move towards a version of its specification based on the WiMedia physical layer, to increase data rates, an objective designed to get round many of the current standard’s limitations? Answer, WiBree could also be integrated with UWB to boost its own data rates (currently no faster than Bluetooth’s), strengthening Nokia’s influence in the high potential UWB sector. Nokia contributed to the UWB platform backed by Intel and Texas Instruments, which is expected to be the basis of next generation WirelessUSB, Bluetooth and IP specification, but integrating this with its own MAC could strengthen the burgeoning Intel-Nokia axis, focused on dominating the new breed of mobile and wireless devices (see Wireless Watch October 2 2006).
WiBree shares many of the characteristics of Bluetooth, with a range of 30 feet, 1Mbps data rates and operating in the 2.4GHz license-exempt band. Like the older system, it is based on variable length packets that deliver low data rates. Early backers included Broadcom, Bluetooth chip leader CSR, Epson and Nordic Semiconductor.
Nokia says that since Wibree shares much of the same underlying technology with Bluetooth it will be easy and cost-effective for manufacturers to design dual-mode chips. The SIG said in a statement: “Wibree consists of a small extension to a standard Bluetooth radio. As such, Wibree has the potential to enhance Bluetooth use cases in the phone by bringing sensor [network] type devices into the fold.” This hints at a long held ambition of the Bluetooth community – to extend its reach into the emerging market for automation and other networks based on tiny sensors. To date, the most hopeful standard to dominate this space has been Zigbee, which may also look to a UWB-based next generation. Helping Bluetooth address such potentially lucrative new sectors will be one of the key incentives that Nokia can bring to encourage the SIG and the existing community of vendors to support its technology. It may also be an area of possible cooperation with Intel, which has talked about ultra-low power sensors and putting wireless connections “into a Band-Aid”.
The SIG’s collaborations with Wibree and WiMedia, and also with the groups behind Wi-Fi and the contactless chip technology NFC, are making a unified PAN with multiple applications a real possibility, an outcome that could have a dramatic effect on accelerating the move to ubiquitous wireless. As well as pushing down costs, greater integration between different PAN technologies will boost the quality of applications in a sector that has to span a vast number of different uses from factory automation sensor networks to fast in-home digital media systems and, in future, such developments as ‘body area networks’ creating ad hoc links between humans.
The Bluetooth roadmap
The most recent Bluetooth SIG roadmap defines plans up to the third quarter of this year, with the focus on UWB. The next core, called Seattle, will be the first to feature compatibility with UWB and the specification is expected soon, with devices by the end of this year. This release will see Bluetooth date rates rising from the current 3Mbps to UWB speeds of up to 480Mbps (or up to 1Gbps with future evolutions).
The SIG and the WiMedia Alliance have now agreed to develop a high data rate Bluetooth solution that uses the unlicensed radio spectrum above 6GHz.
The roadmap shows that the SIG envisages a convergence layer, like the one already devised by the WiMedia Alliance, that would be the basis of interfacing between the UWB MACs and Bluetooth’s logical link control and application protocol layers, supporting features such as service discovery as well as making Bluetooth suitable for a wider range of devices. Other PHY/MAC layers could also be plugged under the Bluetooth protocols in future too.
Other important facets of the Bluetooth roadmap are improved security features, advanced topologies and better quality of service. Some new features in Seattle will include multicast support so that data can be sent to multiple end points simultaneously, eSCO air mode negotiation for renegotiation and seamless switching of the air mode, and AES security.