Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

2 July 2007

Icera leads the HSDPA field but denies shift to patents business model

Given the high profile tribulations of Qualcomm, intellectual property models are becoming a sensitive topic for less powerful chip players, and rather than seeking to impress the markets by boasting of their IPR holdings, many are now playing down any intention to build a business on patents. Strong statements from silicon pioneers, denying any intent to pursue the patent-heavy approach, are now becoming commonplace, aiming to reassure customers and backers (and perhaps ward off legal attacks from larger parties). 60GHz CMOS innovator SiBeam was vocal on this topic last week (see separate item), and UK-based fabless semiconductor start-up Icera was also keen to minimize the significance of its appointment of a VP of intellectual property, while even would-be WiMAX chip designer NextWave, whose model echoes Qualcomm’s in many ways, was being careful to say it does not intend to make significant revenue from its patents, but will work within the guidelines of industry forums.

Icera stated that its new vice president and general counsel, Stephen Chandler, had been appointed merely to protect its IPR and pursue any companies infringing it, but not to shift its business model away from its chips and reference designs and towards patent revenues. “Icera is a fabless semiconductor company with a clear business model of supplying semiconductor devices. To support our customers we provide complete platform reference designs. Icera does not provide its technology as IPR, said head of sales and marketing, Nigel Toon, in a statement.

Icera has good reason to focus on its actual product designs, following the release of test results that show its HSDPA chipset outperforming those of Qualcomm and Ericsson Mobile Platforms. The tests were based on 3GPP profiles and were performed by US consultancy Signals Research Group, usually a major supporter of Qualcomm, working with test equipment vendor Spirent.

The companies tested the only four Category 6 HSDPA products available (Category 6 supports 3.6Mbps downlink) – the Icera Livanto ICE8020 Adaptive Wireless device, and competitive products from Qualcomm and from Motorola and Nokia, both of which have so far designed their own platforms for this technology. Signals also included two pre-commercial products, the U350 from Ericsson Mobile Platforms, an increasingly active maker of reference designs for handsets and other devices, and Qualcomm’s next generation MSM7200 chipset.

The testers concluded that there is currently significant variation in performance between different implementations of Category 6, and that Icera’s offering delivered up to double the performance of the others (with the exception of the pre-release MSM7200, which has similar capability). Icera’s product relies on simultaneous equalization and receive diversity techniques to achieve its performance, and these are also used in the upcoming Qualcomm product, but Icera still has a valuable market lead, plus a flagship customer in Japan’s Softbank (formerly Vodafone KK).