Ericsson is placing its intellectual property portfolio increasingly at the center of its strategy and is becoming more and more aggressive about enforcing its rights and gaining good deals. However, it has settled one of its potentially most important but damaging disputes, with Samsung, as both vendors vye to take a key position in the development agenda for 4G.
The two-year dispute over a wide range of patents in GSM, GPRS, EDGE, TDMA and W-CDMA has ended with a cross-licensing deal covering respective IPR in all these technologies. The fight started when the companies failed to renew a licensing deal in 2005, and Ericsson went on to sue the Korean company for infringement in the following year, claiming violation of 11 patents. As in the Broadcom-Qualcomm saga, many of these relate to the all-important area of power management.
Ericsson, itself a handset maker through its Sony joint venture, and a supporter of Nokia’s calls for royalty caps to reduce cellphone costs, is in a more complex position than arch-IPR litigator Qualcomm, since it needs to balance its desire for increased IPR revenues with its drive to keep cellphone prices competitive. However, it can also use its patents to trade with other handset makers in royalties deals, and so the higher the value of its holdings, the lower the overall licensing burden for Sony Ericsson.
Even without the bartering factor, the balance for the Swedish giant is shifting towards boosting its patent strengths anyway. In the past two years it has greatly expanded its activities in technology licensing, including the marketing of reference platforms to Sony Ericsson rivals, and while its joint venture focuses on the high end of the market – and so is less sensitive to royalty costs than the phonemakers chasing emerging economies – there is also a real option for Ericsson to quit handsets altogether.
Therefore, IPR is more central to the strategy going forward, and Ericsson aims to establish certain ground rules right now. In this, enforcing GSM patents and renewing existing agreements without significant dilution of the terms, is vital, since Ericsson has a huge patents holding in the technology.