With its wireless carrier stronghold still hostile, the enterprise is the strongest element in Nortel’s turnaround strategy, particularly since its strategic alliance with Microsoft for Unified Communications (see Wireless Watch July 24 2006). This has led the Canadian company to take a more proactive approach to corporate-class Wi-Fi, unveiling its ‘Unwired Enterprise’ strategy last week. this also looks likely to be one of the first such corporate-focused roadmaps to incorporate WiMAX.
Although Nortel has been an innovator in outdoor Wi-Fi, pushing combinations of 802.11 mesh and WiMAX as cornerstones of its carrier offering, in the enterprise WLan sector it has relied mainly on OEMd products, particularly from Trapeze Networks. Despite its clear goal in recent years of using its IP expertise to penetrate Cisco’s kingdom, as enterprises move to all-IP networks, Nortel has been unexciting in WLans, until now, when it is allocating a considerable amount of R&D investment to a revamped line of unified wired/wireless switches aimed squarely at Cisco.
It is also looking to add WiMAX to the mix at an early stage. A couple of years ago, there was a high level of interest in WiMAX among enterprise WLan vendors, with innovators like Airespace (now Cisco) putting the technology on to their roadmap and operators like AT&T touting it as a strong T1 alternative and multimedia network for clients. However, the shift of focus to licensed spectrum WiMAX and the rapid enhancements to Wi-Fi’s own performance through the 802.11n initiative has pushed 802.16 to the enterprise sidelines, and its main role alongside Wi-Fi is now seen in the outdoor metrozone, and therefore on the roadmaps of companies like Tropos. Even Cisco, though likely to support WiMAX at an early stage in metrozones, is more interested in 3G in its corporate convergence products.
However, the tide is turning again. Samsung recently announced Wi-Fi/WiMAX routers for medium-sized businesses as an assault on Cisco’s core territory and Nortel, though its initial ‘Unwired Enterprise’ announcements are Wi-Fi oriented, seems set to add WiMAX next year, to support backhaul, and applications requiring advanced QoS and multimedia, such as secure videoconferencing.
Like other vendors coming from the wired Lan sector, Nortel will integrate Wi-Fi functionality directly into Ethernet switches, rather than keeping the wireless elements standalone. This has been a risky strategy in the past – although much touted by wireline companies like Enterasys and Extreme, only Cisco has had real success. However, in the emerging ‘fourth generation’ of enterprise WLans, three main trends are clear, which reflect the ‘growing up’ of the wireless Lan, and should benefit large suppliers like Nortel. These three trends are:
‘ higher levels of integration with the wireline network
‘ lower cost and a higher level of commoditization, especially as new standards emerge
‘ new architectures to support greater scalability
Although larger companies have led the investment in wireless, in general their deployments have been confined to isolated applications or to branch offices. The main success of the specialist wireless switchmakers has been in these remote offices and among SMEs. But in the fourth generation, new approaches are already emerging to challenge or enhance the switches. These are epitomized by the offerings of Extricom, Meru and Xirrus, all of which are addressing scalability. And whereas the most fashionable view to date has been that Ethernet and Wi-Fi are so different in design and capabilities that they should be treated separately – with Wi-Fi overlaid on an established Ethernet infrastructure but logically distinct – the opposite approach is now gaining ground, as represented by Nortel. In this, Ethernet and Wi-Fi are seen as complementary Lan access approaches that demand tight service, security and policy integration, with wireless functionality added to existing Ethernet infrastructures, as with Cisco’s integration of Wi-Fi controllers into its Catalyst 6500 and 3750 switches. (Cisco claims integration of wireless Lan with wireline switching and routing brings a reduction in total cost of ownership of almost 50% over five years.)
Even Cisco, though, has been fairly slow to move beyond superficial integration, and Nortel will be hoping to steal a march with its new products. These will combine Wi-Fi and mesh, plus switches and routers with embedded wireless capability, and a unified network management platform. The company will support the emerging high speed 802.11n standard in 2008 and will also position its range for wholly wireless office environments as well as converged sites.
The company says it will invest a “significant increase” into R&D to design and build its multiradio access points, and a new line of WLan switches, as well as the integrated Ethernet switches.
This will be a blow to OEM partner Trapeze Networks, at least once the Nortel range ships in a year’s time. Once the largest WLan switch specialist, Airespace, was acquired by Cisco, Trapeze has vyed with Aruba for that position, although still dwarfed by Cisco and Motorola/Symbol. Currently, Nortel offers the 2300 series of WLan access points and controllers from Trapeze, its own outdoor WLan mesh nodes, and both fixed and mobile WiMAX radios.
Nortel is also widely expected to gain some differentiation from Cisco by marrying its 802.11n activities with its existing mesh and WiMAX products for carriers, particularly metrozone operators. It could be looking at a system that supports continuous connection between users with mobile voice and data devices and their corporate networks, a capability that only Nortel, Cisco and Motorola would currently be positioned to provide. Nortel has been an early activist around the IEEE 802.21 standard, which allows for fast and seamless hand-off between WLan, WiMAX and wireline networks. The focus on a system that goes beyond conventional enterprise WLan communications to an indoor/outdoor, multimedia system with enhanced QoS would make sense for this carrier class vendor and could finally turn into reality the vision of Wi-Fi supporting pseudo-mobile VoIP and video as effectively as a true mobile network. “Right now we’re pretty far away for true voice or video over WLans. But that’s what we’re trying to achieve with our next gen solutions,” said Jake Power, director of product marketing, in an interview.