In normal times, the third quarter figures Qualcomm reported last week would have prompted a leap in its share price, instead of the meagre 1.9% rise on the day, but investors remain cautious amid growing uncertainty that the chip giant can preserve intact its intellectual property business, and therefore its margins and market control. The results were strong, but with a federal appeal court rejecting Qualcomm’s arguments in its Broadcom dispute last week, and further troubles with Nokia and Europe looming, there is a serious risk that they will not easily be repeated.
This meant Qualcomm executives were missing their customary unshakable self-assurance and briefed analysts with no attempt to downplay the impact of the series of legal defeats by Broadcom in the US, and the risk of further stand-off with Nokia in Europe. This was despite results that, according to one semiconductor market watcher, iSuppli, showed Qualcomm snatching Texas Instruments’ crown for the first time and becoming the world’s largest supplier, by revenue, of integrated circuits for mobile devices. The figures, especially when compared with TI’s unexciting performance, were outstanding, with a 24% year-on-year rise in Q3 profit to $798m or 47 cents (55 cents a share excluding the investment arm), easily beating Wall Street forecasts. But even in that stellar figure the dark side was clear, since the profit leap has been driven so strongly by increases in license fees, as well as rising demand for 3G products. CFO Bill Keitel said the strong performance was mainly down to increased demand for 3G phones with web capabilities, which had enabled Qualcomm to beat its own chip sales targets and also collect a high level of royalties across the entire 3G sector.
Revenue rose to $2.33bn, above analyst estimates of $2.26bn, and up from $1.95bn a year earlier. The company raised full year revenue and earnings outlooks on the basis of rising average phone prices and a shift of its sales in the current quarter towards high end platforms. This is despite the fact that the absence of anticipated royalties from Nokia, following the breakdown of negotiations over renewing a licensing pact that expired in April, will start to hit in the current fourth quarter. Qualcomm expects an arbitration panel to be selected soon to review the dispute, but resolution is not likely to come quickly.
Excluding its investment arm, the chipmaker forecast full year earnings per share of $1.95 to $1.97, up from its previous forecast of $1.84 to $1.88, and above average Wall Street estimates of $1.91. It raised its revenue outlook for the year to $8.72bn-$8.82bn from its earlier range of $8.4bn-$8.7bn, also above analyst expectations of $8.71bn. It shipped a record 65m 3G (W-CDMA and EV-DO) chipsets during the quarter and raised its forecast for the year from 373m-393m units to 378m-398m. The company also raised its estimate for average selling price of handsets from $208 to $216 for the current fiscal year, which ends in September, before the full impact of potential negative legal and licensing decisions is felt ‘ making fiscal 2008 possibly a far more difficult one.
So, despite the bullish outlook for the rest of fiscal 2007, when looking beyond that CEO Paul Jacobs had none of his usual certainty, and was more keen to reassure investors that Qualcomm was not taking its legal threats lightly, than able to offer any concrete solutions. He could not give any realistic indication of when ‘ or how ‘ the period of legal uncertainty would end.
‘We are disappointed with the rulings on behalf of Broadcom both in Santa Ana and in front of the ITC. We continue to believe that the rulings are wrong and are pursuing all avenues to reverse and to mitigate the effects of these rulings, including working with our partners who may obtain a license from Broadcom,’ Jacobs said in his results conference call. ‘Unfortunately, given the threat of injunctions against certain of our products, the next few months represent a crucial litigation timeframe and we can’t predict the outcomes at this time.’
The effects of this uncertainty are somewhat masked by the company’s powerful current financial performance, which is keeping its value steady, but that will not last if the shareholders do not get some stronger sense very soon of how Qualcomm will respond to a worst case scenario with Broadcom, Nokia and even possible European Commission antitrust actions. Jacobs has spoken in general terms about contingency plans, including the possible spin-off of the IPR business, but it is hard to gauge how many options the company really has for dealing with its legal crisis while maintaining as much value as possible in a chipmaker whose business model may have to be radically changed.
Qualcomm’s saving grace, of course, is that it has good products as well as IPR, and that it has been successfully shifting its revenue streams towards the high margin end of its markets even as many of its rivals go in the opposite direction. Its repeated ability to develop and execute advanced platforms ahead of many other players will avert a fatal crisis, but without the current legal issues, this ability would be boosting the company’s value still further.
Its next legal milestone will come by August 6, the deadline for the president’s team to decide on whether to veto the ITC injunction, which would ban the import of new handset models based on Qualcomm chips that the ITC, and a federal court in Santa Ana, have ruled infringe four Broadcom patents, mainly related to power management. Other appeals remain afterwards, but the veto is highly unlikely. It would set a new precedent in the US and the case for it ‘ that a ban would severely damage the US cellular industry, depriving some of the largest cellcos of new handsets ‘ has been fatally weakened by Verizon Wireless’ decision to make a licensing deal with Broadcom directly (see Wireless Watch July 23 2007).
This is not necessarily a bad deal for Qualcomm financially, assuming it loses its case to have the pro-Broadcom judgements overturned. Although Verizon Wireless did the cause of low-royalty handsets no favors by agreeing to a high $6 per phone for the four patents, the limits on the deal ‘ notably its $200m ceiling over the lifetime of the patents ‘ suggest it is probably more favorable than any Qualcomm could have done in its own right. It is very likely that the CDMA giant will end up paying much of the Verizon fee anyway, distancing Broadcom from dark hints that it was indulging in the dreaded ‘double-dipping’ on royalties by licensing to the carrier directly; and possibly setting a precedent for future Qualcomm compromises on IPR, making deals indirectly through large customers while refusing to back down on the principles, at least, of its licensing model. ‘A comprehensive settlement between us and Broadcom is unlikely, given Broadcom’s insistence on terms which could have a material impact on our licensing business’ said Qualcomm’s president, Steve Altman.
Qualcomm executives acknowledged they were in talks with Verizon Wireless over the latter’s patent costs, as under the terms of Qualcomm’s agreements with its partners, it could be liable for the fees. However, it disputed that these costs could be as much as $6 per handset, and indeed, once the $200m cap and life of the patents its taken into account, Verizon is more likely to end up paying about $1.5 per phone. So far, the other major CDMA operator, Sprint Nextel, still claims to be testing a workaround to the Broadcom patents, but in its race to keep up with Verizon in rolling out enhanced EV-DO networks, it will be feeling strong pressure to make its own deal with Broadcom.
UMB reference design:
Qualcomm has introduced a new infrastructure reference design for Ultra Mobile Broadband (UMB), its next generation technology based on OFDMA, and formerly called EV-DO Rev C.
Based on the company’s OFDMA Cell Site Modem CSM8900 and technologies from partner component and software providers, the base station reference design is intended to help enable OEMs reduce their development costs and time to market, although the standards will not be finalized within the 3GPP2 until later this year.
The UMB reference design uses the CSM8900 to provide physical layer functions and supports a flat, all-IP network architecture. It also includes technology from Freescale, whose MPC8548 PowerQUICC III processor is used for the control plane and Layer 2 functions; Cavium Networks, with its Octeon Processor for Layer 3 and Layer 3+ networking applications; and a real time operating system from Green Hills Software.
Broadcom joins S60 community:
As Broadcom steps up its assault on Qualcomm, it is also making friends in its quest to be a 3G player. In particular, it has been drawing closer to Nokia, no doubt hoping to exploit the Finnish company’s desire to reduce its dependence on Texas Instruments. Its latest gesture is to join the Series 60 Product Creation Community, in order to create smartphone platforms for S60 software, which is developed by Nokia and also licensed to some other phonemakers.
“Broadcom joining the S60 community is a very positive development that will further enhance the silicon resources available to smartphone makers committed to S60 software,” said Matti Vanska, VP of mobile software sales and marketing at Nokia. “The combination of advanced S60 software capabilities and pre-integration with Broadcom’s silicon solutions will help drive new smartphone designs and shorten time to market for introducing these products.”
Broadcom will be pushing its recently introduced BCM2153 7.2Mbps HSDPA multimedia baseband processor, as well as its skills in integrating this with Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and GPS.