Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 July 2007

Crown Castle dumps Modeo, leaving only HiWire to challenge MediaFLO

Qualcomm’s MediaFLO mobile TV platform may have been dealt a body blow in Europe by the EU’s likely mandate of rival DVB-H, but in the US it seems even more certain to sweep the board as Crown Castle pulls out of its Modeo television venture.

Crown Castle, the Texas-based cell tower company, had acquired nationwide 1.6GHz spectrum for DVB-H and planned to build a network on which operators could rent capacity and enter content partnerships ‘ as Qualcomm has done with its MediaFLO build-out in 700MHz. However, the Modeo venture into which it had ploughed the activity failed to win any carrier partners, and so has not progressed beyond trial networks, built in collaboration with DVB-H cheerleader Nokia, and a pilot in New York. Meanwhile, the two largest cellcos, Verizon Wireless and AT&T, had both signed up for MediaFLO; Sprint aims to build its own system on its WiMAX network (and may also use MediaFLO on CDMA); and T-Mobile is testing several systems, including the HiWire, the other DVB-H venture in the US, whose own future must now also be in doubt.

Crown Castle will lease its Modeo’s nationwide spectrum to two venture capital firms, Telcom Ventures and Columbia Capital, for $13m a year. The pair have created a unit that will have the right to acquire the spectrum or renew the lease for another 10 years under the same terms beginning in 2013. The tower company will take a one-time charge of $10m in ‘operating and general administrative costs’ related to the aborted Modeo business, and will write off all its Modeo assets other than spectrum in the third quarter of this year.

Last September, when AT&T (then still called Cingular) joined Verizon in partnering with MediaFLO, Modeo defiantly said it would go it alone and launch its service without a major cellco endorsement. However, it was clear that Crown Castle would soon run out of cash to extend the build-out very far, unless it could sign a major customer, and its chief hopes ‘ now presumably exhausted ‘ revolved around Sprint, or a deal with a non-cellco, perhaps a satellite or cable TV operator wanting to add mobile versions of it programming and targeting non-cellular devices rather than phones.

Its other main option, and one apparently promoted by Cingular and the DVB-H community, was to merge its spectrum and operations with those of HiWire, which is a joint venture between spectrum speculator Aloha Partners and satellite content distribution company SES Americom. Such an alliance, like the recent WiMAX one between Sprint and Clearwire, would have split the costs and risks of build-out, united the competition against MediaFLO, and increased the total spectrum available ‘ most significantly, bringing HiWire’s more attractive 700MHz licenses (the same spectrum band as MediaFLO) into Modeo’s orbit. Although the FCC did Modeo one good turn earlier this year when it allowed it to use higher power transmitters in some regions in its 1.6GHz band, levelling the propagation playing field with the 700MHz players somewhat, there are still disadvantages in terms of cost, device availability and roaming in 1.6GHz (see Wireless Watch March 5 2007). However, the two DVB-H triallists took the probably mistaken decision not to join forces, with HiWire now holding out for a T-Mobile deal or the chance to sell its high value spectrum on at a profit, especially given the current furore raging about the rest of the 700MHz band, to be auctioned at the turn of the year. Its DVB-H trials in Las Vegas, combined with the battles over future licenses will certainly have increased confidence and interest in the whole 700MHz area, and pushed up the value of HiWire’s holdings considerably.

The same is far less true of 1.6GHz, and it is not yet clear what the new controllers of this spectrum plan to do with it. Some observers are speculating that the new venture will leap on the WiMAX bandwagon, though with only 5MHz blocks of spectrum, it would be tough to compete with Sprint/Clearwire’s huge capacity and 20MHz channels. Another possibility may be to support XM Satellite Radio, in which both VC firms have major stakes ‘ since the Modeo spectrum is also a band for Digital Audio Broadcast, it could be used for mobile music and even video based on the DMB version of that standard, a somewhat discredited contender for the mobile TV crown. Or a DVB-H network could still be built out, with XM as the major customer, getting a better deal than it would have obtained directly from Modeo because of the VC cross-ownership.

Meanwhile, HiWire announced a line-up of 24 channels for its trial network in Las Vegas, Nevada, three times the eight-channel list offered commercially by MediaFLO. ‘Our system that we built was set up to broadcast 24 channels at any point in time. We’ve actually signed under contract to trial more channels than that,’ HiWire president and COO Scott Wills told RCRnews. The venture was greatly helped in securing its content by its partnership with SES Americom. It will offer seven channels from Discovery Communications; six from MTV Networks (including CMT, Comedy Central, MTV, Nickelodeon, Spike TV and VH1); two from Turner Broadcasting (CNN Mobile Live and Cartoon Networks/Adult Swim Mobile); plus Anime Network; E!; Fox News Channel; Travel Channel; The Weather Channel; MavTV; and AccuWeather.com. There will also be local broadcasting.

Virgin Mobile TV:

Ten months after launch, Virgin Mobile has confirmed that it is to discontinue and close down its UK mobile TV service in January 2008. Ostensibly Virgin has been pushed into the action because BT Movio, which provides bandwidth for the service, is cancelling its contract with GCap Media, the company that owns the spectrum. However, there are likely to be other reasons too.

Virgin has only ever offered one TV-capable handset, the Lobster 700 from HTC, which has only sold 10,000 units, largely because of its odd shape. Customers will still be able to access DAB radio services on these handsets ‘ Virgin actually admitted last week that the built-in DAB radio had been the ‘key attraction’ of the Lobster for those who did buy it.

BT’s statement said: ‘Following a review of its wholesale solutions, the decision has been made not to continue with the Movio service. BT is discussing the timescale for the closure of the service with Virgin Mobile. While the feedback from users on the service has been complimentary, Movio sales have been slower than originally expected mainly due to a lack of compatible devices from the big brands. This in turn has been caused by the fragmented nature of the mobile TV market and hesitancy on the part of the main network operators as they seek to fill their own largely underutilised 3G networks.” This is clearly another nail in the coffin of the DMB standard, which Movio used, outside its prime territory in Korea (see Wireless Watch July 23 2007).

Also in the UK, regulator Ofcom is debating whether, and when, to auction its 1452-1492MHz spectrum, initially earmarked for mobile TV or potentially satellite radio.
In essence, Ofcom is saying that it is unlikely to be ready to auction this spectrum off by its second deadline of December, because there are so many issues to deal with and it has put out a second request for comments on a new set of proposals. It is concerned that the European Commission will harmonize the use of the 1452-1479.5MHz band, but that it won’t have completed its deliberations until the December meeting of its Radio Spectrum Committee, which would leave no time for a December auction.

The issues Ofcom has put up for discussion include the method of the auction, and how that would relate to two separate types of networks, those with a low number of transmitters operating with very high effective radiated power and those with more transmitters, which each have less power. Multiple respondents in the past have suggested that the two types of networks would not work well together and the result would be interference across the bands.
So Ofcom has proposed a huge 3.4MHz guard band between them, and rules that would place all of one type of network below the band and all the other types above it. It has also said that it will not limit the auction to single 1.55MHz slices that are used when DAB is used in L Band spectrum, which means that Ofcom is preparing the way for DVB-H mandate and 8MHz chunks of spectrum, even in L Band.

BSkyB remains the most likely bidder to use this spectrum for mobile TV, and is currently trialling MediaFLO, but the European Commission may well insist on a DVB-H provision going with any 8MHz blocks or T-DMB in smaller slices, effectively banning MediaFLO for reasons of interoperability of equipment across Europe. Ofcom is clearly not planning to buck the Commission, but its own instincts would be to issue the spectrum without unduly inhibiting the proposal of alternative technologies.