The upcoming 700MHz auctions in the US are the focus of high hopes among supporters of disruptive operator models and technologies such as WiMAX, but they are also being used by more conventional companies to help restore investor and customer confidence. Alcatel-Lucent and now Nokia Siemens Networks have both been battered recently by poor results and merger pains, and both are now talking up their plans to make equipment for the emerging 700MHz market.
The Finnish-German joint venture said it is about to ramp up its capabilities in emerging spectrum bands such as 700MHz, and to meet the potential to run 3G systems in Europe’s GSM frequencies. Its key weapon in the race to take the lead in these new sectors is the Flexi base station platform, originally developed at Nokia and now the flagship of the four-month old venture because of its ability to be adapted relatively easily for different technologies and bands. The Flexi has already been a factor in the company’s surprise win of one of Sprint Nextel’s three contracts to supply WiMAX infrastructure for 2.5GHz, and now it is being promoted as a system that can be optimized for 700MHz in short order, allaying some potential spectrum holders’ fears that equipment could lag behind their need to deploy services from 2008. Flexi will also support a range of technologies in 700MHz, said NSN, and so could be of interest to incumbent or new providers (though not Verizon Wireless or Alltel, as there will be no CDMA option). It currently runs with GSM, EDGE, W-CDMA, HSDPA or WiMAX, and NSN is working on further HSPA iterations and on LTE.
The company argues that Flexi will marry well with the motivations of many 700MHz bidders, since one of the key benefits of the spectrum will be to support rural operators with sparsely populated territories, with its potential to deliver broadband wireless in very large cells. These large cells reduce the number of base stations required and so cut capex and opex costs, and NSN claims that Flexi improves the profit potential further as it is designed for cost-constrained scenarios with its modular, compact design. NSN also supports Internet-HSPA, a flat network architecture that offers similar cost/performance advantages to the flat IP networks such as WiMAX.
In fact, though its plans have been less detailed, Alcatel-Lucent pipped its rival to the post in announcing its intentions for 700MHz, and will also aim to support multiple technology choices in this band ‘ W-CDMA, WiMAX and also, of course, CDMA (see Wireless Watch March 5 2007). The French giant is using the time honored method of creating systems for the more immediate public safety requirement, which will then be adapted for commercial use in future. The company has already won a contract worth up to $110m to build a CDMA2000 EV-DO Rev A network in the 700MHz band covering Washington DC, including the White House and Congress. Alcatel said the network would be ‘interoperable”, and ‘provide mission critical information to public safety professionals in the region’s 19 municipal, district, state and federal jurisdictions’. It will support push to talk, an important function for public safety, and implementation partners will include Qualcomm, LGS and AnyData.
Alcatel-Lucent is clearly setting out its stall – or rather, that of the CDMA technology that came from Lucent – for the commercial providers, no doubt with an eye on the CDMA leader Verizon Wireless (the other CDMA major, Sprint Nextel, flush with 2.5GHz spectrum and somewhat over-burdened with WiMAX build-out, has said it will sit out the 700MHz auction). CDMA2000 is traditionally strong in spectrum with narrow channels, as 700MHz will be, and success in these new frequencies would be a boost for a technology that is facing rising doubts over its long term survival. The other huge public safety contract of recent years, a $500m deal in New York City, was won by Northrop Grumman using the UMTS-based TD-CDMA technology from IPWireless (now NextWave).
Ericsson has so far been less vocal about the 700MHz opportunity, while Motorola and Nortel are likely to focus primarily on WiMAX, plus CDMA if Verizon Wireless wins large swathes of spectrum. Qualcomm says that adapting current CDMA technologies, and UMB, for 700MHz is a ‘high priority’ and chips will ship early next year. It will add 700MHz to quad band EV-DO Rev A and Rev B chipsets in 2008, and UMB by June 2009, it claims.
The WiMAX community in general is gearing up for what could be one of its greatest opportunities to date ‘ fresh spectrum in which non-traditional operators and business models are being pushed more strongly than in any previous auction, and where there is none of the 3GPP incumbency that WiMAX faces in other important new bands such as Europe’s 2.5GHz.
WiMAX’ greatest cheerleader, Intel, has been in the forefront of lobbying for 700MHz rules to support open access and new, internet-focused service providers, its activities predating Google’s more publicized demands by years. It is even possible that Intel will invest in spectrum itself in order to create a wholesale network that would support its chosen technology and operator models ‘ as Qualcomm did in the last 700MHz US auction, when it bought the spectrum in which it now runs MediaFLO. However, it now looks more likely that Google may play this role, or that either party, or other mobile internet players, could provide backing for a disruptive bidder. Intel is certainly playing a role in investing in start-ups that are focused on getting WiMAX chips and equipment to market rapidly for 700MHz ‘ even though, of course, there is no official WiMAX Forum profile for the band, and unlikely to be until 2009. This will not stop vendors from creating pre-certified 700MHz products, and they will need to act quickly to have their systems ready once the auction has taken place at the turn of the year, and so rob the HSPA majors of their much-boasted headstart. There will also have to be accelerated work on FDD implementations of the technology, which are unlikely to be fully standardized by the Forum until late 2008, but which will be important for many operator models. In the lower 700MHz band, the FCC has divided the 48MHz of spectrum into several blocks of paired and unpaired licenses in increments of 6MHz blocks to accommodate broadcast use, TDD technology in the unpaired bands, as well as FDD in the paired bands (see diagram).
As well as Motorola and Nortel, Fujitsu is likely to be an early mover both in chips and infrastructure. ” George Wu, director of the wireless group at Fujitsu Microelectronics, said in an interview: “We have received wish list comments from some of our customers about the 700MHz band and are reviewing their requests while keeping a close watch of the open access policy development.’