Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 August 2007

T-Mobile will not back off WLan, looks to wireline VoIP too

Since the US carriers started to roll out 3G, T-Mobile USA has been forced to be creative with its technologies and services to compensate for its lack of 3G spectrum. This led it to create its hotspot network, and almost unwittingly spark the idea of Wi-Fi as a carrier class network into life. Combining 2G and Wi-Fi to deliver wireless and pseudo-mobile data services has proven a good strategy for the operator, especially when combined with its high service levels and imaginative handset choices. Recently it extended the concept to launch one of the world’s trailblazing fixed/mobile convergence services, Hotspot@Home, which aims to accelerate fixed line replacement and fend off 3G-based data offerings, using dual-mode handsets and UMA.

Now, however, the cellco faces something of a crossroads in its strategy. Late last year it acquired significant chunks of AWS spectrum in which it will deploy HSPA, and so it needs to find a way to integrate this network and its existing Wi-Fi services. On one hand, it could defocus on WLan in order to avoid supporting two networks and cannibalizing potential 3G revenues, and because there may be advantages to freeing itself from dual-mode handsets and instead looking to 3G femtocells as the main basis of convergence and homezone offerings. On the other, it has ploughed considerable investment into Wi-Fi and has a strong brand differentiator there, whereas in HSPA it will remain, for the foreseeable future, a laggard behind AT&T. One theory is that it will take a similar approach to Sprint Nextel, developing parallel systems with clearly differentiated services on each ‘ one for open mobile internet offerings, based in T-Mobile’s case on Wi-Fi and possibly supplemented with WiMAX; and one for voice, messaging and traditional mobile data applications and devices. Many operators round the world are contemplating this apparently neat mobile internet/classic cellular division. They are looking at preserving at least some of their margins and brand in 3G by leveraging its efficiencies for voice and messaging, and by developing premium services that will exploit fully the qualities of the mobile network and small screen, something it will be years before standard mobile internet platforms can do to full effectiveness. Meanwhile they can ensure they are not left out of the emerging open internet sector by creating a network for that too, planned from the start around the low cost base and wide range of device support that will be essential to make any money from this model. At the all-IP 4G stage, of course, the two models can be converged into one infrastructure ‘ so goes the theory, as expounded by several carriers, including Korea Telecom, T-Mobile itself and even Vodafone.

One of the many potential flies in the ointment of this neat game plan is the role of VoIP. While Qualcomm has addressed this somewhat for the CDMA community with its VoIP-based enhancements in EV-DO Revs A and B, outside of that world, there remains a fundamental dilemma for cellular operators. They need to compete with VoIP providers and support consumer demand for open voice, but ‘ far more than in data services ‘ this will kill the healthy margins of cellular voice, and rob them of their greatest advantage, the voice efficiency of the circuit switched networks, especially W-CDMA. Low cost homezone tariffs are one way to keep customers on the cellular network, though at the cost of margin, by making 3G calls as cost effective as VoIP ones ‘ and the emergence of femtocells will improve the homezone as a commercial proposition by restricting its size. But few cellcos will be able to avoid embracing VoIP altogether, and this is clearly shown by T-Mobile USA’s latest plans for its Hotspot@Home system, which appear to include a fully fledged landline VoIP service.

This is indicated by the carrier’s submission to the FCC of a Linksys wireless router that would support two landline phones and two cellular handsets per unit. With such a device, T-Mobile would strengthen its competitive position against the two leading telcos, AT&T and Verizon ‘ while fixed-mobile substitution is a clear trend in the US, it is not moving quickly enough to make up entirely for T-Mobile’s lack of any fixed line infrastructure in the country. By allowing customers to incorporate their fixed lines into the Hotspot@Home service, T-Mobile will be able to enhance the packages it can offer and gain better customer control, while removing one incentive for users to move from its cellular service to one, such as AT&T’s, with fixed line bundles.

This shows T-Mobile USA once again thinking of Wi-Fi in strategic terms rather than purely defensively, a habit that has stood it in good stead since the advent of public hotspots, in which market the German-owned carrier has been one of the only significant commercial successes (largely by using bundles to reduce churn on its main network). T-Mobile knows that standalone VoIP, whether wired or wireless, is merely a cheap alternative to home and mobile phone services, whereas when VoIP is included in increasingly broad-based bundles, the consumer appeal is far greater and the likelihood of holding on to the customer is stronger.

Linux RAZR:

In keeping with its habitually creative approach to handset choices, T-Mobile USA looks set to be the first cellco to carry the Linux version of Motorola’s new RAZR2 phone. Verizon Wireless, Sprint Nextel and Alltel will all offer the EV-DO iteration, the RAZR2 V9m, while AT&T, T-Mobile USA and US Cellular will sell the W-CDMA model, the V9.

T-Mobile is now expected also to launch the Linux model, the V8, the first to use Motorola’s MotoMAGX Linux platform. This software is likely to be a breakthrough product for the beleaguered phonemaker as early tests show that it manages ‘not to look like a Linux phone’ to end users, as one analyst put it ‘ in interface and speed terms, Linux handsets have often been clumsy compared to Symbian or Windows devices. The V8 is touted as a very fast phone compared to older RAZRs, with a 500MHz processor.