Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 August 2007

Nokia accelerates shift to merchant W-CDMA but tier two players could suffer

Nokia’s recent decision to reorganize its baseband chip supply partners accelerates an existing trend, towards the death of captive relationships in this market, and the shift to a merchant model. In theory this could open up the largest handset accounts to second tier chipmakers and create new opportunities for them, but in practise, the silicon players that benefit most from the new structures are likely to be the giants.

In W-CDMA, the key growth market in 2007, Texas Instruments was the global leader last year because of its virtually captive alliance with Nokia, and because it also supplied Ericsson Mobile Platforms, which in turn provided 3G to Sony Ericsson and others. Qualcomm came second (though in the most recent quarter this year it overtook TI), with Samsung and LG its key W-CDMA customers. Freescale and NEC were next ‘ the former exclusively with former owner Motorola in W-CDMA; the latter supplying a handful of Japanese vendors, mainly focused on NTT DoCoMo and its FOMA 3G system. Other would-be W-CDMA players are STMicro (vastly boosted by being named Nokia’s second source for this technology, alongside TI) plus Broadcom, Infineon and NXP, but these three have not yet shipped significant volumes.

In this landscape, Qualcomm and Ericsson Mobile Platforms (EMP) were the chief merchant suppliers, but TI is rapidly transforming itself to target the whole vendor and platform base more aggressively, partly in response to the loosening of its ties with Nokia. Meanwhile, Nokia also plans, largely with STMicro, to enter the 3G platforms race and compete with EMP and Qualcomm in the open playing field (see Wireless Watch August 13 2007).

Freescale is in one of the most difficult positions since Motorola retains some of its key W-CDMA IPR, but has also diversified its supply chain to incorporate Qualcomm and TI as well as its former chip unit.

Competition will clearly heat up in the merchant platforms sector as the handset makers shift to differentiating their products in software rather than hardware, and so reallocate some of their R&D and intellectual property resources away from chips. But as the cellphone market becomes increasingly concentrated in the hands of the top five, the remainder will lack the volume to support many tier two silicon players if these fail to win a place at the top table. For instance Nokia, though providing an important boost for STMicro, Broadcom and Infineon, has effectively cast NXP into the wilderness by excluding it, and even the new partners are unlikely, in the near future, to secure a major proportion of the Nokia business (unless TI really stumbles on execution or pricing). This leaves EMP/Texas, Nokia/STMicro/Texas and Qualcomm as the big hitters in W-CDMA handsets, with NEC clinging to its FOMA niche and Freescale to what it can preserve of the Motorola business.