Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 August 2007

Nokia makes few mistakes with impressive Q2, though needs to watch Google

Nokia turned in a stellar second quarter, and claimed 38% market share in handsets, close to its perennial goal of 40%. The Finnish giant has succeeded in the difficult balancing act ‘ between high end media phones and low end models for emerging volume markets ‘ as none of its rivals have done, and this, coupled with its excellence in logistics and execution, have proved a stronger formula than isolated hit record handsets. However, those much-hyped phones, notably the iPhone and LG Prada, do also reflect consumer trends that Nokia must be certain it can tap into, even if its star models, such as the N95 media handset, do not achieve quite the profile of the Apple upstart. It is not so long since the Finn lost its grip on its core market by failing to respond to the demand for clamshells, and as Motorola know post-RAZR, the cellphone market is a fickle and fast moving one. Nokia has proved itself very strong in recognizing and driving high level trends in mobile behavior, notably the mobile internet, but this needs consistently to be translated into real world products if it is to achieve that fabled 40%. And even this quarter was not without its shadows ‘ despite huge growth in key emerging markets like India, Nokia cannot really claim to be a global superstar unless it can improve its performance in North America; plus there was the drag on overall results of a poor first quarter from the Nokia Siemens Networks venture (see separate item). In addition, Nokia itself recognized that this was a quarter where it did not have to try very hard, given the meltdown at Motorola, usually its biggest challenger.

Despite the notes of caution though, Nokia was undoubtedly in impressive form in its Q2, with double-digit gains in handset volumes in every region except North America and a sharp increase in revenue and profits, beating even relatively bullish market expectations. Nokia’s stock soared by 8% on news that its handset share was up by two points in just one quarter (and four points since Q2 2006), though shipments to the US fell 21% year-on-year despite the promises made by CEO Olli-Pekka Kallasvuo that US growth was top of his agenda. Nokia sold just 4.1m units in the US, compared to the 11m managed even by a wounded Motorola (although its retail sales were up 1.5%, reflecting possible hopeful signs of consumer uptake, even if Nokia pulled back shipments to avoid excess inventory). Outside North America, regional growth was strong compared to the year previous, with a 21% rise in shipments in Latin America, 36% in China and the rest of Asia, and nearly 37% in the Middle East and Africa.

Overall, Nokia saw revenues up 28% year-on-year to $17.2bn, with operating profits up 57% to $3.2bn and net profits surging a massive 148% to $3.9bn. At almost 101m units, handset shipments were up 29% over the previous year’s Q2, and represented treble the volume of second placed Samsung. Even average selling price was up (just slightly, from $122 to $123, still an optimistic sign given the huge market pressure on cellphone prices and the damage to margins that some vendors have suffered while chasing emerging economies). An accelerating shift to 3G in mature markets, and Nokia’s strong position in W-CDMA, were credited with this, as well as solid performance in mid-tier models worldwide and a cautious approach to the ultra-low cost sector. These factors saw the Multimedia unit, which makes the high end products such as the N Series, enjoying revenue growth of 43% and margins up four points to 20%, with the N95 cameraphone a particularly strong perfomer. By contrast, the Mobile Phone unit, which makes the entry and middle level handsets, saw flat revenues, though operating profits were up on a shift of sales balance to successful midrange models like the 6300, which boosted the ASP. This structure of business units will soon be altered to reflect Kallasvuo’s recent reorganization of the Nokia structure (see Wireless Watch June 25 2007), which will place all handsets in a single Devices operation.

Given Nokia’s scale, the handset du jour, the iPhone, is barely a blip on its radar, but the Finnish giant will need to keep its eye keenly on some of the trends the Apple device epitomizes, such as touchscreens and dynamic user interfaces. Apple also looks set to add voice commands to its product, having filed a patent application for ‘Audio User Interface For Computing Devices’, which builds on two older Apple patents, ‘Audio User Interface For Computing Devices’ (2004) and ‘Voice Menu System’ (2003). Apple has already patented speech recognition technologies, but this application lists applicable devices as “a media player such as an MP3 player, a mobile phone or a personal digital assistant’.

The aspect of the iPhone that has most caught the public imagination is its touchscreen, to the benefit of the supplier of this module, Balda (with its partner TPK Holdings). Balda’s shareholders are even calling for the German company to spin off its touchscreen business to bring more visibility to its value.

A rush of new touchscreen-based cellphones will appear in the fourth quarter and should be especially popular in Asia, where character sets are too complex for keypads or keyboards. Touchscreens such as the iPhone’s and Prada’s, using ‘capacitive technology’ ‘ as opposed to ‘resistive technology’ prevalent in most handsets ‘ also saves on power. However, touchscreens currently account for only 2% of the total market. IMS Research believes this will reach 29% in 2011.

Meanwhile, Google is a far bigger potential fly in the Nokia ointment than Apple, since it could prove a significant barrier to the Finn’s objective of becoming a mobile internet services company. Now the rumors are flying again that Google will back up its own ambitions in the mobile space by creating devices, although reports that it has been in discussions with Verizon Wireless and T-Mobile USA about carrying the phones seem to fly in the face of Google’s strategy of acquiring its own spectrum and networks to promote its services and push an open access model.

According to the Wall Street Journal, Google is keen to release a handset with its user interfaces and hardware mechanisms optimized to the search giant’s applications, and has got to the stage of developing prototypes after an R&D investment of hundreds of millions of dollars. Google is already working on making mobile-friendly iterations of its applications and a new browser and other software (see separate item on Microsoft), but may believe it also needs to create devices (branded or not) that will make the best of its software. With companies like Nokia seeking to set the standards themselves for mobile internet interfaces and applications, Google could encounter problems with persuading these handset majors to support its techniques in their premium models. Its reported developments also reflect an increasingly important battlefield in the war for mobile internet dominance ‘ ensuring a seamless integration of the device and UI with the web services pattern of new applications, so that hardware and software truly mirror one another to deliver a satisfying user experience (see separate item).