Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 August 2007

FCC steers middle ground in 700MHz rules but sets valuable precedent

US regulator the FCC has included a measure of support for open access in its rules for next year’s auction of 700MHz spectrum, but this will prove more significant for setting new precedents in US telecoms than for actually revolutionizing the system in 2008. FCC chairman Kevin Martin, who had already hinted at the likely policy in his own recommendations two weeks ago, tried to pursue a middle course that would stand the greatest chance of getting all parties onside. Major operators, notably AT&T, had already said they would support some compulsory open access on 22MHz of the spectrum to be auctioned, presumably on the basis that the FCC would not then adopt more radical proposals from parties like Google. These ideas, backed by the open internet sector including Intel, also wanted this 22MHz to be set aside for a wholesale model geared to supporting new entrants and smaller or innovative providers, and so hastening the breakdown of the traditional cellco business structure and the adoption in the wireless world of the internet model.

As it is, the FCC has ruled that it will bar any auction winner from building a network that specifies selected devices or services, but did not meet the Google demand to mandate that the winner offer wholesale access to any wireless or broadband provider.
Four of the five FCC commissioners voted in favor of the auction plan. The open access provision applies to the C block of spectrum, a total of 22MHz, and meets Google’s demands for access to be guaranteed for any device and any application that do not harm the network. However, as well as ruling out compulsory wholesaling, the regulator also ignored Google’s fourth requirement, for third parties to be able to interconnect at a technically feasible point in the network to enable geolocation and similar services for content providers.

As expected, the FCC also ruled that , in the upper D block of the band, a public safety licensee and a commercial licensee will form a public safety/private partnership to develop a shared, nationwide interoperable network for both types of users.

In contrast to previous auctions when operators could purchase spectrum purely to keep it out of competitors’ hands, in this one the FCC will insist on certain build-out timescales and coverage targets for each slice of spectrum, within four years. Providers that fail to meet these will have their licenses reduced and potentially confiscated.

As a step towards an open internet model – where all applications and devices are supported on all networks, and small providers can offer services without massive upfront investment ‘ the significance of the FCC’s ruling should not be underestimated, even though it disappointed many would-be revolutionaries. It represents a major shift in thinking, even if one imposed by the sea-change in consumer behavior of the past few years, that is remarkable from a conservative body deeply influenced by the interests and lobbying power of the traditional telcos.

However, while it is a step in the open direction, it will not change US wireless internet overnight. The 700MHz network will still have to be built out and in the mean time, the existing network owners will enhance their mobile offerings on networks unencumbered by the new rules. In the medium term, users will have the choice of a network fully open to any device, which will start to break down the traditional operator-handset relationship, as almost anachronistically represented by the AT&T-Apple exclusive. It will be interesting to see how far Sprint Nextel and Clearwire, whose 2.5GHz WiMAX network offers the best hope, in the near future, of a network truly geared to mobile internet, choose to support open access (one suspects this support will be limited, until consumer pressure dictates otherwise, given Sprint’s recognition that attracting optimized and unique devices will be half the battle in winning customers).

Even with the new rules, the operator of the 700MHz network is still likely to be a major player, with the same challenges of getting service mix, pricing and branding right. This is particularly true because the FCC has said that, if a bid of $4.6bn or more is not submitted for the open spectrum, the auction will be restarted without the open access obligations. This situation should not arise, given Google’s pledge to invest just that amount in spectrum in order to promote its own approach ‘ though the promise was given on the basis of the FCC adopting the search giant’s more radical proposals, the company (or another player such as Intel) would be more than likely to step up the money rather than see a telco carry off the spectrum with no openness requirements at all. However, the high reserve price effectively excludes smaller operators or start-ups, unless a wholesaler does secure the licenses ‘ again, possibly a reason for Google to invest directly in order to create its open network and bring its vision of mobile internet to the US even without an FCC mandate.

Unless Google can win the auction in its own right ‘ and justify what could be a price tag far above $4.6bn to its shareholders ‘ the end result will be a long way from the situation Intel and Google envisage, where the wireless network is an anonymous, unbranded internet pipe on which, as in the wired Net, any provider can offer a service for a modest investment and risk. In the Martin plan, operators will still have huge control over the traffic on their networks, especially if ‘ as seems likely ‘ they are not forced to bill customers on behalf of third party content developers. Lack of carrier billing deals has kept various forms of content and applications out of the major US networks, and carriers will also still be able to enforce certification policies for devices, (on the basis that they do not have to support products that could harm the network), and they will have the right to set different rates for different services or hardware, to help shape the ‘open’ network in their own image.

White space rules:

Open wireless internet proponents suffered another setback, at least temporarily, when US government tests found that prototype devices running a variant of Wi-Fi had trouble detecting TV signals in the broadcast guard band spectrum known as ‘white space’, and so interfered with broadcasters and wireless microphones.

‘Given these results, further testing of these devices was not deemed appropriate at this time,’ stated FCC engineers.

The wide guard bands are no longer necessary, with modern technology, to protect broadcasters from interference, but the FCC has to decide whether this spectrum should be made available on a license-exempt basis ‘ as demanded by Wi-Fi/internet players like Intel ‘ or through traditional exclusive licensing or a hybrid. The agency aims to make a ruling this fall.

The hi-tech sector’represented by the White Spaces Coalition’remains confident it can build Wi-Fi products that meet FCC requirements, using ‘detect and avoid’ technologies such as those enshrined in the emerging 802.22 standard, and other techniques developed with the Department of Defense to avoid WLans interfering with military radar.

‘Coalition members are encouraged that FCC engineers did not find fault with our operating parameters and remain confident that unlicensed television spectrum can be used without interference,’ the group stated.

Among the companies involved in the design of the prototype signal sensing Wi-Fi devices are Google, Dell, Hewlett-Packard, Intel, Microsoft and Philips.

The 700MHz band:

The A block (12 MHz, 6X6) will be broken into 176 licenses based on Economic Areas, while the B block (12 MHz, 6X6) will have 734 licenses based on Cellular Market Areas (this fits with the existing Cellular and PCS license areas). These two segments of the spectrum are the most valuable because they are not encumbered with any restrictions, open access requirements or co-ownership.

The C band (22MHz, 11X11), which is the largest of the bands, is where open access rules apply. There will be 12 regional licenses awarded.

The D band (10MHz, 5X5), for which there is one national license available, includes the public safety partnership mandate.

There is also some unpaired spectrum (some already auctioned); the D band (UHF Channel 55, which Qualcomm already won in an earlier auction); and the next UHF TV channel, 722-728MHz, which will also be divided in EAs, yielding 176 potential licenses.

The bidding will be anonymous, and the Wireless Telecommunications Bureau has been ordered to establish reserve prices for the entire spectrum allocation.