Despite shiny results at Nokia (see separate item), its infrastructure joint venture with Siemens performed less well, while Alcatel-Lucent saw its shares slide by 8% on a decline in sales and greater than expected loss, wiping over €1bn off its market value. Both companies blamed what NSN called ‘aggressive and unsustainable pricing’ by competitors, implicitly pointing the finger at Ericsson, whose current dominance is only reinforced by the teething troubles of the two huge ventures that were set up partly to challenge its market lead.
Alcatel-Lucent reported a second quarter loss of €586m. Had the two partners been operating as a single company in the same quarter last year, it would have reported a profit of €302m. While CEO Pat Russo tried to emphasize the few positives – notably that sales were above the company’s guidance, and 46 new contracts were signed in the quarter ‘ she could not detract from the blow of a slump in gross margins, which Russo admitted were ‘lower than we would have liked’ because of ‘unfavorable product and geographic mix’.
Gross margins fell from 33.4% this quarter from 38.1% a year ago, and analysts fretted over the company’s failure to offer any guidance on future margins.
While wireless carrier sales fell by 8% year-on-year, wireline revenues saw a 7% rise and the company did report its best ever quarter in the DSL sector, with 9.6m lines delivered – for the first time, more than half of that came from the IP-based DSLAM platform. The wireless slippage was mainly blamed on low volumes in GSM, the price sensitive market that Ericsson rules, attracting huge contracts in territories like India by bundling services and other equipment alongside the networks themselves.
The main nervousness about Alcatel-Lucent surrounds the slower than expected uptick in sales post-merger, and the failure to offer guidance on margins. So protestations that the efficiencies promised by the unification were on track ‘ at about €600m ‘ had limited impact, especially as the cost of the cutback programme has been amplified by a series of strikes in France and high redundancy costs there. Now, even more severe cuts are expected to be needed to tide Alcatel-Lucent over what its investors are hoping will not be a more prolonged downturn.
The same is true at NSN, which promised to announce more stringent cost reductions and to rethink its market strategies, just one quarter after its official start of operations as a joint venture.
‘It is an extremely competitive market, especially in wireless infrastructure,’ said Nokia’s CFO Rick Simonson during the earnings conference call. ‘We have seen very aggressive and unsustainable pricing, and we haven’t participated in some of the deals due to the financials. Competitors have targeted our business during our integration period’ (an accusation also hurled by Russo). Nokia CEO Olli-Pekka Kallasvuo, who is also chairman of NSN, said the results represented a ‘disappointing first quarter that fell short [in terms of] margins and revenues’. As at Alcatel-Lucent, gross margins were particularly disappointing, and among the lowest in the sector at 23.6%, (Ericsson’s are closer to 40%).
Kallasvuo promised ‘strong actions’ and will demand that NSN’s CEO Simon Beresford-Wylie, find another €500m in annual cost savings on top of the €1.5bn already announced, although details and timescales were not divulged. He also said that the venture ‘must focus on more services, software focused product developments’ and rebalancing on emerging markets such as India and China’.
Meanwhile, Nortel also fell short of analyst expectations, though its main focus in discussing its recovery plans was on potential acquisition activities, rather than further cuts. This could mean a major merger to try to achieve sufficient scale to compete effectively with Ericsson in wireless infrastructure, but is more likely to mean specialized vendors that will bolster the Canadian company’s strategy to place itself increasingly outside the mighty Swede’s firing line, by strengthening its focus on enterprise markets and IP technologies like WiMAX.
Nortel reported a second quarter loss of US$37m, compared with net income of $342m in the same period last year, while revenue fell 8% to $2.56bn, partly because of the sale of its UMTS business to Alcatel last year. Like its European rivals, Nortel pointed to increasing price pressure in its major carrier business – driven especially by Ericsson and the Chinese suppliers, and by operator consolidation – as a major factor in its declining results, and a reason to expand into new sectors. Like NSN, Nortel CEO Mike Zafirovski said in an interview that his company had been forced to walk away from a number of carrier network deals in the past 18 months to avoid unacceptable erosion of its profit margins.
Zafirovski insisted that Nortel’s restructuring, in the wake of its emergence from its painful financial scandals of mid-decade, was on track. He stuck with previous guidance of full year revenues the same as, or slightly below, last year’s $11.4bn, although to deliver flat performance, Nortel will have to accelerate sales to $6.36bn in the second half, compared to $5bn in the first half, which many observers believe will be unachievable. The CEO insisted there would be a ‘big ramp-up’ in sales of enterprise and VoIP equipment in the second half of this year, strength in CDMA and GSM, and a bounceback in the depressed metro Ethernet business, which in Q2 saw its revenues drop 16% year-on-year. However, analysts were not all convinced, and a research note from JPMorgan Securities analyst Ehud Gelblum called Nortel’s fiscal 2007 guidance ‘a tall order’.
Facing the scepticism about Nortel’s ability to ramp up its sales so sharply in the second half, Zafirovski hinted at acquisitions, now that its financial house is back in order. Earlier this year, Nortel was tipped to take over Avaya, but no deal has yet transpired.