About four years ago, there was considerable buzz around the idea of the personal mobile hub, which basically turned the mobile phone into a basic wireless gateway that would connect via Bluetooth to a range of other media, storage or input devices, creating a super-personal area network. Although Samsung got on board, working with the concept’s main champion IXI, and Intel and Motorola also showed interest, the idea failed to live up to its potential in the mainstream. Now, however, it may have a second lease of life, thanks to operators’ urgent quest for new device formats to support new ways of using their mobile broadband networks; and the need to push mobile web services to the next level by integrating them more naturally with the handset.
Although companies like Nokia continue to refine the ‘super-smartphone’ ‘ a device that can combine a host of functions, from music and video to communications to mass storage, in one mobile unit ‘ there is a parallel trend for users to purchase multiple devices, each optimized for one function, and effectively integrate them into a personal system using web services and web 2.0 applications such as Flikr for photos or Google Maps. The logical extension of this is to make the integration between web-based software applications and devices far more seamless, so that the hardware/interface and web experiences really mirror one another, even across multiple device formats. Clearly much of the advanced development being done by the mobile internet majors on user interfaces is geared to this, with the work on widgets, dynamic interfaces and web 2.0 coming out of Apple, Nokia, Google, Samsung and others.
But one of the companies gaining most attention for a more complete realization of the mobile integration concept is start-up Bug Labs, whose plans recall the personal mobile hub, but are far more software-driven, and designed to work within an open source ethos. It has yet to release full details of its products, but these appear to revolve around an open set of interfaces that will support modular mobile computing and encourage simple development of applications. The company describes its BUG system as ‘an open, modular, consumer electronics web services + hardware platform. Bug seeks to bring to the world of hardware gadgets what the internet, open source, XML and web services have brought to the world of software and media.’
Making the relationship between web services and devices more seamless lies at the heart of this effort and, if BUG can gain developer support and deliver genuine progress, it will be of keen interest to all the parties aiming to ensure that next generation networks do not just deliver conventional services more quickly, but support entirely new ways of working that will have significant appeal to users, and therefore revenue generating capabilities.
Of course, such an approach will also accelerate the demise of the walled garden, implying an unlimited ability to mix and match services and devices ‘ as supported in a limited way by the proposed rules for the US 700MHz auction. This would not only restrict the cellcos’ ability to keep users within their portals ‘ already rapidly declining ‘ but would prevent them tying devices to their networks exclusively. So, keeping the iTunes download service unique to the iPod or iPhone gadgets would no longer be an option ‘ or not one acceptable to consumers ‘ forcing device makers as well as service providers to rethink their business models.
Of course, the main barrier to the open mobile internet is currently lack of user confidence in mixing and matching their own personal systems, rather than purchasing turnkey ones in which the operator serves up the device and portal. Any developments that make the process of user customization easier will hasten the fall of the walled garden, and these are now coming thick and fast from the mobile internet community, which is starting to embrace formerly unlikely members such as Nokia. For instance, the ability to drag and drop web services onto a dashboard that is pervasive from laptop to all other devices (mobile or not) is key, and developments such as Nokia’s widsets or Yahoo’s Go Mobile (plus from integrated dashboard start-ups like Mentations) go some way to deliver that.
The Apple iPhone, for all its advanced interfaces, is, in so many ways, the last fling of the old closed mobile model (with iTunes not even being a web service). The sort of work coming out of Bug Labs and a host of other innovators should ensure that such an approach to mobile broadband declines even more quickly in the years ahead.
IXI and the personal mobile hub:
The key to the new-look personal hub is that it should be a software platform that is applicable to any device, with the user choosing which device should be form the hub of their dynamic personal area network. This was the major flaw of the 2003 buzz of the personal hub, since the idea was to add yet another device to the user’s collection, although Samsung and others incorporated this into the cellphone. The main proponent of the mobile hub, IXI Mobile, aimed to create a host of different devices to support its modular computing idea, but ended up pulling back from its core concept and shutting its software business (see Wireless Watch August 5 2005), concentrating on the one product that had generated real revenues, the Ogo messaging device (offered initially by AT&T Wireless). Although Sanyo North America and Samsung licensed the IXI reference design, the Samsung personal gateway suffered poor sales and Sanyo did not progress beyond a prototype. Sources said that Motorola also created a prototype, but was deterred by IXI’s fee of $10 per device to license its platform.
Even in the first flush of interest from the handset majors, the IXI concept was already being diluted. The Samsung and Motorola projects were both basically Bluetooth-enabled phones, but with software allowing them to connect to other devices. This was a step away from the original IXI idea, with the phonemakers hijacking it to ensure that the handset remained at the heart of the equation, rather than being relegated to just another peripheral hanging off a third party hub. But IXI had envisaged the hub residing in a wide range of devices, according to application and user preference, and in 2003 demonstrated its software working with a Seiko watch, a Gamespark games console, a digital camera and a Messaging Pen.
The failure to gain major support for this broader vision, and the backing off of Motorola, left IXI Mobile seeking to compete in its own right in the device market. It has not lost sight of the aim of integrating internet and devices more seamlessly, though the pressure to support the Ogo platform has limited the scope of its vision. In February it announced Ogo 2.0, claiming: “Ogo 2.0 will do for web 2.0 what the original Ogo did for the first generation internet services: make them mobile, affordable, seamless, easy to use, and suitable for mass consumption’, as CEO Amit Haller put it. Despite the grand words, the device is really competing with many others in the data-centric mobile world, the BlackBerry being the prime example. The main supporter of the Ogo in Europe is Swisscom Mobile, with Mobilkom Austria and Russia’s Vimpelcom being other backers. IXI was itself acquired last year by Israel Technology Acquisition Corporation (ITAC).