Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 August 2007

WLan vendors ignore IEEE disputes in race to 802.11n

The WLan vendors are looking to the emerging 802.11n fast Wi-Fi standard for a major revenue boost in 2008, and seem increasingly willing to ignore the IEEE standards body in pursuit of that. While last week’s plenary meeting of the IEEE 802 committees reported some interesting progress on 802.11 and 802.16 standards, the main news was yet another damaging dispute in the Wi-Fi camp, over measures to reduce interference with legacy 802.11a/b/g networks. Undeterred, the manufacturers are turning out products based on the draft version of the standard, draft 2.0, and D-Link, for one, expects to ship a million units in the fourth quarter of this year, doubling its current run rate.

Other vendors are relying on 802.11n to support wider ambitions that just increased unit shipments, with Nortel, in particular, talking up its new Unwired Enterprise strategy, which depends heavily on high WLan speeds. The Canadian vendor – which with the uncertain state of its carrier networks business is placing increasing focus on its enterprise activities ‘ sees the speeds promised by 802.11n as an enabler for entirely wireless corporations, for a host of new applications, and for wide/local area convergence based on Wi-Fi and WiMAX.

These suppliers will not wait for the IEEE group to sort out its differences before they attack the market, promising customers they will provide software patches to sort out any inconsistencies between current products and the final standard ‘ but in reality, raising widespread fears of platform fragmentation, reduced interoperability and enterprise risk.

And the main issue still dogging 802.11n is an important one for large companies with existing WLans, and even for home users. The 11n working group has failed to achieve consensus on measures to mitigate interference with older WLans, and became deadlocked at the recent meeting on whether or not to allow both 20MHz and 40MHz channel operation in the already congested 2.4GHz band. The maximum performance enhancement promised by 11n comes from using the wider channels, which are not supported by the older Wi-Fi variants. There is only 70MHz available to 11b/g services in the 2.4GHz band, so there is high likelihood of overlapping channels and interference if 40MHz operation is allowed. If it is not, the emphasis would switch to the 5GHz band, which is less crowded but also less unified in terms of global rules, and which supports shorter signal distances.

Other news from the plenary meeting was progress on efforts to integrate 802.11 and 802.16 into the ITU-T’s IMT Advanced framework. Being accepted as part of this list of technologies for next generation wireless networks was crucial to the 802 standards’ bid to appeal to carriers and become part of the communications mainstream, and work on integration began in January, with 802.16 serving as a mobile interface for IMT and 802.11 as a nomadic one.

To support future IMT requirements and provide an upgrade path from 802.16e, the working group is also working on the next iteration of the standard 802.16m, which aims to achieve 1Gbps stationary performance in line with objectives for 4G.