With the demise of Boeing’s much heralded Connexion in-flight internet venture, the issues of Wi-Fi access in planes was sidelined, but companies continue to search for a more commercially viable approach than Connexion, and last week saw American Airlines and Germany’s Lufthansa both promising services.
Lufthansa was the first adopter of the Connexion offering, which it provided as Flynet from 2004 until Boeing pulled the plug last year (see Wireless Watch August 21 2006). Now it is reported to be working with satellite operator SES Global and product manufacturer Viasat on a new system, which is likely also to provide integration with the Wi-Fi services of its subsidiary T-Mobile (though not in-flight voice). The initiative is likely to cost the partners about $100m.
Meanwhile, American Airlines has signed a deal with AirCell to bring in-flight Wi-Fi to its passengers next year, and is running first trials on intercontinental Boeing 767 aircraft. The aim, however, is to launch the offering primarily for passengers across the whole US, who list in-flight broadband access as one of their top wishes, according to AirCell. Like Lufthansa, American says it is unlikely at this stage to partner with a VoIP provider to support voice, although this could be a lucrative (if unpopular) move given the recent regulatory decision not to allow in-flight cellphone calls in the US. In Europe, various airlines are considering cellular voice services, including low cost operator RyanAir and AirFrance-KLM.
AirCell said last November that it would have an airline running its wireless system by late 2007 and believes it will succeed where Connexion by Boeing failed because it will keep costs lower and target the US domestic market initially. Unlike Connexion, AirCell has no middleman to collect a fee for data transit, and it relies on a far cheaper antenna and ground station package with the spectrum it purchased recently. It is also likely to use picocells within the plane to boost cellular coverage. While the air-to-ground spectrum it acquired delivers just 1.5Mbps, it can offer up to 30Mbps within the plane.
Other US airlines offering in-flight email and messaging are United, Continental and US Airways, with the Verizon Airfone seatback telephone system.
Boeing killed Connexion last year after six years, after failing to sell the business to satellite operators. In a statement at the time, Boeing chief Jim McNerney said: “Regrettably, the market for this service has not materialized as had been expected. We believe this decision best balances the long term interests of all parties with a stake in Connexion by Boeing.”
Even though Connexion worked well in offering airline passengers with Wi-Fi devices broadband access via satellite, it failed to draw enough interest from a broad range of airlines, partly because of high costs. At close, the service was available on selected longhaul flights from Lufthansa, Japan Airlines and Singapore Airlines but usage was “in the low single digits” of passengers per plane. The cost of outfitting each airplane approached $500,000 or more, while the majority of passengers balked at paying the $10 to $27 per flight to have the service.
At the height of the dotcom boom, Boeing and others estimated that revenue from in-flight laptop users could top $25bn a year by 2005 but its original US partners, American Airlines, United Airlines and Delta Air Lines, pulled out as they struggled financially in the aftermath of the September 11 terrorist attacks.
Panasonic is also working on an in-flight system, probably initially with JAL.