While RIM, against all odds, continues to retain its market share and move into new sectors, its old rival Palm has suffered two years of decline, as its traditional PDA business dies off (see Wireless Watch August 20 2007) and it fails to gain solid traction in the smartphone space against Nokia and others. Its best hope will lie in taking on the mighty Finn in one of its hottest new areas, Linux internet devices, which are firmly targeted at Palm’s traditional enterprise territory. But even this strategy has suffered a setback with the rumoured delay in delivering the company’s first Linux product, the Foleo, and even more seriously, its much anticipated new open OS.
Palm gained a new lease of life last June (see Wireless Watch June 11 2007) when it raised new equity financing from Elevation Partners, largely on the back of attracting Jon Rubenstein, former head of Apple’s iPod division and an eminent device engineer, to be chairman. But while his reputation brings clout, it cannot change Palm’s inherent problems ‘ falling market share, shrinking differentiation from other smartphone vendors, lukewarm response to its latest products, and a complex operating system strategy that has led to it developing and supporting three OSs (PalmOS, Windows and Linux). Now this has been made even worse by the delay in delivering the Foleo, and further confusion on the OS front, since it seems Foleo and an ensuing smartphone will run a Linux distribution from Wind River Systems, not the homegrown platform Palm has been promising, and on which it has staked many of its claims for future recovery.
Deutsche Bank analyst Jonathan Goldberg put out a research note last week saying that Palm’s Foleo, which was unveiled in May, has been delayed. This will certainly dampen investor enthusiasm further, since Palm has managed to hype up Foleo quite successfully, despite the shadow of the higher profile iPhone. Palm founder Jeffrey Hawkins, who designed its seminal products Pilot and Treo, called the Foleo “the most exciting product I have ever worked on’ at its launch, setting the tone for a confidence-building campaign that will not be helped by further delays.
Like similar devices from Nokia and Motorola, the $500 Foleo is a Linux-based, 10-inch screen companion device to the Treo, allowing users to create emails and edit documents with a full-sized keyboard, and to sync automatically with the smartphone. This is apparently the root of the delay, since software bugs have been found that prevent synchronization with most Treo models, according to Goldberg.
Shipments are now expected in early October, but more serious may be the delay to Palm’s own Linux-based OS, which was expected to debut this fall and to power a new high end smartphone. It will now come ‘some time next year’, according to CEO Ed Colligan, and in the mean time, a Linux smartphone is likely to be launched as a stopgap, using the same Wind River OS as in Foleo.
This is serious news, as Palm has been placing so many hopes on its new OS, arguing vociferously that this will give it real differentiation against the larger handset makers, especially in the enterprise and high end smartphone markets ‘ the Palm line is that, apart from RIM and Apple, no other smartphone rival really understands software and so is capable of creating a real applications ecosystem around their platforms. Nokia might have something to say about that, but such comments show the strategy that Palm is relying on for survival ‘ playing on its unique software and device design skills, as it always has, but adapting these for the open Linux world. Yet with products like the Nokia Internet Tablet, as well as Ultra-Mobile PCs, gaining ground, Palm needs to turn its talk into reality as soon as possible to gain a decent foothold.
In its quest to base its future on its Linux-based OS, Palm has recently distanced itself somewhat from Microsoft and Windows Mobile, and is preparing to wind down PalmOS. Instead, it is going back to its roots, creating an OS and interface that will be differentiators, and closely identified with its devices. The risk is that the time is past for this approach – even Nokia, which once saw the Symbian OS that it dominates as the key weapon in its war with Microsoft, is now using Linux too, and has shifted the battleground higher up the software stack to the UI and browser.
As Microsoft knows, the benefit and the cost of competing on a closed OS is that there is a huge effort to attract developers and handset makers to support another system – at a time when cellcos like Vodafone are narrowing the number of operating environments they are prepared to support. In reality, it is likely that Palm will emulate its former stablemate, Palmsource (formerly the software arm of the company, which was spun off and then acquired by Japan’s Access and is now focused on adapting features of the Palm UI for a mobile Linux platform). In other words, it will concentrate for its uniqueness on navigation, widgets and other critical features of the modern mobile UI. In common with many other innovators in this area, Palm is expected to work closely with Opera on the browser front – the Opera product, which supports Ajax and many other advanced functions also being pioneered by Apple/Nokia and Yahoo is becoming a major thorn in the side of Internet Explorer as it never was in the PC world.
Corrigan has said the new OS will not be licensed to other handset makers, indicating that the Treo maker does not intend to quit the hardware market and follow other early PDA movers into the licensing game. Palm says it has been working on its new OS for several years, and will use its licensing rights to Palmsource/Access’ PalmOS (known as Garnet), to evolve its implementation of Garnet into the new system. Among other benefits, this will reduce its licensing fees in future to Access, and protect it from that company’s likely reduction of investment in PalmOS as it concentrates on Linux and the upper layers.
It certainly had to make a critical decision about PalmOS – continuing to license from Access was not going to prove fruitful. Access plans to introduce its Linux Platform later this year and it will include an emulation layer for running Palm OS-based applications. However, emulators rarely work as well as native systems, and this approach is unlikely to prolong the life of PalmOS in any meaningful way, though it will be useful as a transition aid for large Palm shops. Clearly Access’ main direction will be to take the advantages of the Palm user interface for its Linux stack, leaving Palm to fend for itself. By not committing to the Access Linux product, and preferring to create its own, Palm is making a clean break with its former subsidiary, and making a last ditch attempt to develop a world class OS again, an ambition that has faded under the Palmsource auspices since spin-off.
Sprint and the Centro:
Among the new mobile devices Sprint was showing off at its recent Tech Summit was the Centro, reported to be the smallest PalmOS model in the Treo family to date. It will feature the Treo smartphone’s signature touchscreen and Qwerty keyboard, and Sprint will target it, in its EV-DO version, at younger, first-time smartphone users. It is said to be getting a three-month US exclusive from Palm, and will offer the device for $99 with contract. Sprint will also soon offer EV-DO versions of the HTC Touch Windows smartphone and the Blackberry Pearl.