Western Europe and Japan had always seemed particularly tough markets for mobile WiMAX to crack because of the entrenched strength of 3G, but Vodafone’s recent commitment to a multi-technology strategy, and support for technology neutrality in 2.5GHz auctions in the UK, has turned most of those assumptions on their head. Now WiMAX has scored another endorsement of its claim to be a parallel technology for UMTS and the emerging LTE, with the greatest champion of the traditional cellular networks, NTT DoCoMo of Japan, teaming up to bid for a WiMAX license.
It had appeared that DoCoMo, despite some ongoing 802.16e trials with its telco parent NTT, would be unable to participate in WiMAX in its home country, as the MIC (Ministry of Information and Communications) ruled that existing 3G mobile operators could not bid for the upcoming 2.4/2.5GHz broadband wireless licenses, in which WiMAX is set to be the primary technology. However, it seems that the rules may be more flexible than first assumed, and DoCoMo will form a joint venture with broadband provider ACCA Networks, a frontrunner to win a license.
To comply with government rules, DoCoMo will take a stake of just one-third in the venture. The new allies will recapitalize ACCA’s new unit ‘ set up specifically to bid for the 2.5GHz license and called ACCA Wireless ‘ to the tune of ’72bn. Under the agreement, DoCoMo will provide around $164m to the venture, while ACCA will invest around $259m.
Although this may dilute the MIC’s aim of encouraging new competitors in to the Japanese mobile broadband market, it will also place significant expertise and resources behind ACCA’s efforts to develop a converged offering based on its DSL networks and WiMAX, and eventually a quad play. With DoCoMo’s support, the smaller company is more likely to create a viable business, in a market where it could have faced outright hostility from NTT and its cellular arm, with DoCoMo forced back to rely entirely on LTE plans for its own mobile broadband initiatives.
‘ACCA Networks agreed to the partnership based on DoCoMo’s extensive experience and knowhow in mobile technologies,’ said a statement from the two companies.
In November 2006, ACCA began trials of WiMAX in the suburban area of Yokosuka Research Park, and is now expanding that test to include the urban area of Yokohama City. It is using Alcatel-Lucent’s 9100 Evolium WiMAX end-to-end radio system and has tested applications such as video streaming, high speed internet and VoIP, plus extended QoS and service integration through IMS.
The other confirmed bidder for a 2.5GHz license is Willcom, currently the operator of Japan’s PHS network. It has been working with Adaptix on a migration path from PHS to low cost WiMAX micro base stations. According to researchers at Ovum, PHS operators supply most of Japan’s 2m data card users with speeds up to 128Kbps, but the market is dying, with DoCoMo planning to shut down its network soon. This means the PHS upgrade sector will be attractive to new broadband wireless entrants (see Wireless Watch July 24 2006).
PHS was pioneered in Japan and is based on the pre-2G TDMA technology. It has gone through something of a revival in recent years, being adopted to bring mobility to regions where even GSM phones are too expensive. There are now 100m PHS subscribers worldwide, mainly in Japan and China, and providers like Willcom are looking for an upgrade path that will enable them to offer triple play services at low cost, as the average income of their user bases increases in some areas, and as ultra-low cost GSM handsets eat into their market. Willcom, which started tests with OFDMA in November 2005, has now been awarded a one-year trial license. “We absolutely believe that OFDMA is an ideal technology for next generation PHS services,” said Adaptix.
The auction rules:
The MIC said the 2.5GHz band would be reserved for mobile access using broadband channels, and therefore technologies such as WiMAX, 802.20, CDMA EV-DO Rev C (UMB) or Willcom’s successor to PHS (the other key option, LTE, was not mentioned by name).
The proposed plan says that 80MHz between 2.535GHz and 2.63GHz (excluding the guard band) will be divided into two bands, one for nationwide mobile access and one for fixed access per local community. The mobile band will be allocated to two carriers with a channel of 30MHz each. 3G operators cannot bid for either fixed or mobile bands.