Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

3 September 2007

Motorola’s Symbol files suit against aggressive Aruba

For a start-up, there can be a warped satisfaction in being sued by a giant, since it shows the company has succeeded in putting its head above the parapet and making the larger players nervous. This must be the case with Aruba, the largest of the independent enterprise WLan switchmakers, which has been slapped with a lawsuit from Motorola, claiming the smaller firm has infringed four patents.

Motorola has been looking to expand its business in enterprise wireless since acquiring Symbol Technologies, then the second largest maker of Wi-Fi switches after Cisco, but now pushed into third place by Aruba. Symbol has always struggled to move out of its traditional retail and shop floor markets into the ‘carpeted office’ sector, and now faces rising competition from the stronger WLan start-ups, notably Aruba and Trapeze. The race is becoming important, even to the giants, as large companies start to deploy wireless more widely and as a strategic element of their converged IP networks, rather than just in branch offices (see separate item on UniFi). There will be far larger sums of money in wireless switches as these move into more scalable and sophisticated corporate deployments, and Motorola will be keen to optimize its position.

The larger company, then, wants to stop Aruba using the disputed technologies altogether, not to be allowed to pay to license them. The four patents are held by Symbol and another Motorola subsidiary, Wireless Valley Communications. Symbol’s two patents were awarded in February this year, and concern critical areas of new generation corporate WLans, centralized switching and security. US patent 7,173,922 (Multiple Wireless Local Area Networks Occupying Overlapping Physical Spaces), describes an architecture where the functionality of the traditional access point is moved to a centralized ‘cell controller’, replacing the AP with a simplified ‘RF port’ that carries out only basic and time critical MAC functions. Such architectures, of course, underpin the shift of WLans from ‘fat APs’ to switches and controllers, which may often be collocated with a wireline hub.

Symbol’s second piece of intellectual property, US patent 7,172,923 (Security In Multiple WLans), describes how RF ports can operate based on pre-assigned security levels, creating virtual WLans with separate security policies.

The Wireless Valley patents at stake were issued in 2003 and 2005 and were used in the network design company’s Site Planner product suite. One concerns the use of 3D computer aided modelling to automate the prediction of bills of materials and performance predictions inWLans; while the other describes a system for predicting, measuring, and optimizing network performance using agents to feed into a 3D model.

Motorola is demanding royalty compensation and monetary damages, and a permanent injunction against Aruba using the four technologies. “Our goal is to exclude Aruba from using the technologies, not authorize their use in exchange for money,” said Aaron Bernstein, vice president of intellectual property at Symbol. He also hinted that other companies were likely to be targeted.

Aruba officials declined to comment directly on the lawsuit, although CEO Dominic Orr said that Motorola had never contacted the company about the patent claims, implying it had not tried to negotiate a licensing deal. “Patent litigation is a part of doing business in our industry,” Orr said in an earnings conference call. “We are evaluating the lawsuit and will respond at the appropriate time.”

Aruba went public earlier this year and has been performing strongly, snatching Symbol’s number two position in enterprise WLan infrastructure, behind Cisco (the latter has two-thirds of the market). Last week, it reported good fourth quarter figures, with revenues up 74% year-on-year to $41.7m, and full year revenues up 76% to $127.5m. The company’s net loss widened from $1.4m in the last quarter of 2006 to $3.4m a year later, largely because of increased sales and marketing expenses. Excluding stock-based compensation and R&D costs, Aruba posted a profit of $2m for the quarter.