As expected, the FCC has rejected proposals from new operator M2Z Networks to provide a free national broadband network in the currently idle 2.1GHz frequencies. M2Z, headed by former FCC chair John Muleta, has argued that the FCC should afford it special treatment, offering it guaranteed access to national spectrum in return for the provision of a free access service, featuring open access and obscenity filtering, and with a share of revenues returned to the government in lieu of market license pricing.
Naturally, the wireless industry had vehemently opposed any preferential treatment for alternative providers in this valuable spectrum, and the FCC has taken the cautious ground, concluding that it would be better to initiate a consultation and rulemaking process on the 2155-2175MHz frequencies, to adopt flexible rules and take all opinions into consideration. Other, unnamed, parties had also submitted proposals for the band.
‘Each of these proposals has merit, and consideration of either would be inappropriately foreclosed by granting forbearance in this instance,’ wrote FCC chairman Kevin Martin in a statement. ‘We plan to issue this Notice of Proposed Rulemaking shortly to address these issues and adopt flexible rules that will encourage the innovative use of this unique piece of spectrum.’
The FCC was not convinced by M2Z’s argument that it was proposing a whole new service eligible for special treatment under the law, noting that base level data speeds would have been relatively slow and that other applicants claimed innovative approaches too. However, it was not a united front. One of the two Democrats in the five-member Commission, Jonathan Adelstein, questioned the FCC’s legal analysis, which could prove valuable in any legal challenge from M2Z.
‘I am concerned that we have not considered more seriously M2Z’s proposal as offering a new technology or service under Section 7 of the Communications Act,’ he said in his statement. ‘The Commission should be encouraging the development of new technologies and services for the benefit of consumers. Our job at the FCC is to do whatever we can to promote spectrum-based opportunities and I am not convinced that we have done so adequately here.’