As one MVNO dies, another is born. Last week, Disney said it would close down Disney Mobile, having done the same a year ago to its Mobile ESPN virtual operator; while invitation-only, ad-driven start-up Blyk went live in the UK.
Following hard on the heels of the failure of Amp’d Mobile, Disney’s decisions casts another shadow over the US MVNO sector, which last year appeared to be booming, but which has struggled to make sufficient impact on the major cellcos and the flat rate carriers. Disney will now take the same approach with Disney Mobile as it did when it shut down ESPN Mobile, turning to licensing its content, the main differentiator for both services, to other cellcos. It has already signed a deal with Verizon Wireless for ESPN’s sports-related services.
The Disney branded offering was aimed at children and their parents and featured family oriented services like child tracking as well as the famous content. However, it failed to make headway with the big retailers or other important outlets and so did not achieve sufficient scale.
Disney would not comment on how much it had invested in its MVNOs or the cost of closing them, although last September CFO Tom Staggs indicated the cost of shuttering ESPN Mobile would be $30m.
Meanwhile, in Europe, where MVNOs are longer established but less hyped, Blyk is testing a new business model. It aims to offer free voice and texting supported by advertising. It already has the backing of a number of investors and is founded and run by Pekka Ala-Pietila, former president of Nokia.
Like most MVNOs, Blyk is appealing to 15-24 year olds, and its plan is to pair advertisers that target this demographic with consumers who agree to view ads, an approach already tested on certain services by Virgin Mobile USA. Specifically, Blyk subscribers will have to watch six SMS-based ads each day and in return, get to send up to 217 text messages and talk for 43 minutes per month. After this they have to pay, and also have to fork out 99 pence (about $2) per minute to surf the web. Also, any user over 24 has to pay for the service.
At launch, 45 advertisers were signed up. They pay on the basis of per message per user ‘ 20 pence per picture message, five pence per text and two pence per ad tagged to the bottom of a private text message.
One interesting aspect is that it is based on SIM cards only, and so is geared to users who already have a handset, clearly cutting Blyk’s own costs and eliminating subsidies and complex retail chains. At first, at least, it will offer SIM cards on an invitation basis to ensure the demographic is tightly controlled.
According to Blyk, there are about 4.5m users who are the right age and fall into the right usage patterns in the UK and 85% of those use prepaid services. It hopes to lure them with a combination of lower overall costs and better service.