Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

1 October 2007

Intel supports compromise on 700MHz open access

FCC chairman Kevin Martin has so far failed in his attempts to revise the open access rules proposed for the 700MHz auction, which have been legally challenged by Verizon Wireless. Democrat politicians have reacted angrily to the attempt and warned Martin not to ‘cripple’ the open access requirements on a portion of the beachfront spectrum.

‘Chairman Markey would be concerned with any ruling that weakened or diluted the effectiveness of the open access rule,’ said an aide to House telecom subcommittee chairman Edward Markey.

Sources said Martin sought to use a different policy making vehicle’a declaratory ruling’to modify the auction’s open access guidelines in a way that responds to concerns raised by Verizon Wireless executives in a meeting with Martin on September 17.

‘If the effort here is to eviscerate what we managed to get into the 700 MHz [decision] with regard to Carterfone ‘ I would look upon that with a lot of concern,’ said Michael Copps, one of the two Democrats on the Republican-controlled FCC. ‘People fought long and hard for these things.’

Interestingly Intel, which has huge interests in promoting open access and the internet model, has taken a position that has parallels with Verizon Wireless’. In a meeting with the FCC last week, Intel officials’including the head of its WiMAX program’said the 700MHz open access requirement should prohibit C-block licensees from locking out third party devices, but permit such operators to market locked-in devices. ‘The latter arrangement might enhance consumer welfare by allowing carriers to subsidize devices and foster consumer acceptance of new services and technology,’ Intel stated.

AT&T has joined Frontline Wireless and Verizon Wireless as the third major company to petition the FCC to change its spectrum rules for the upcoming 700 MHz auction. AT&T, however, wants the regulator to reconsider requirements relating to the build-out of a nationwide broadband network for public safety officials. The current rules require bidders to come to an agreement with public safety networks over a business plan for the shared network before the auction, which is set to take place at the end of January. AT&T said this requirement is “an extreme penalty” since the FCC will not allow bidders to take the spectrum if they do not have such an agreement.