Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 October 2007

Siemens may want out of NSN, while Ericsson turns screws on AlcaLu

The two mega-alliances in telecoms infrastructure, Alcatel-Lucent and Nokia Siemens (NSN), continue to come under huge pressure, handing ever more advantage to market leader Ericsson. Such are the teething troubles of these two partnerships that Siemens is hinting at wanting an early exit from NSN after only six months, while speculation is rife that Alcatel-Lucent CEO Pat Russo will not keep her post beyond this year.

Siemens’ new CEO, Peter Loescher, cast doubt on both his companies major joint ventures ‘ NSN and the Fujitsu Siemens operation in computing ‘ as he started to set out his restructuring plans, trying to start with a clean slate after the settlement of the long running and major fraud investigation that has plagued the German company. Loescher said in a statement: ‘We are absolutely not satisfied with NSN’, though did not go as far as to say Siemens would like to exit that venture or Fujitsu Siemens, though there has been rising speculation that this is his goal. Major German trades union IG Metall said last week that Siemens might be looking to get rid of its 50% stake in NSN, following management briefings. However, under the terms of the six-year deal, either party can only sell its stake with mutual consent before 2013.

NSN has seemed jinxed almost from the start, when its planned January 1 kick-off was delayed by the Siemens probes. Although it has scored some significant deals since then, it has struggled to deliver the growth and efficiency gains that the markets had hoped for from the alliance. In July, it became clear that NSN had dragged down an otherwise copybook second quarter for its Finnish parent, with a loss in its first quarter as a joint venture.

The organization reduced its growth expectations almost as soon as its commenced operations at the start of April, but was still forecast to make a positive EBITDA. But instead, it reported an operating loss of €1.3bn on sales of €3.44bn. ‘Both net sales and margins were weak and these adverse developments require decisive action,’ Nokia said in a statement at the time. Cost cutting efforts were accelerated to try to achieve the planned savings by the end of 2008 rather than by 2010.

Meanwhile, Alcatel-Lucent suffered its latest blow on Friday when its shares fell 2% on a report, in the UK’s Financial Times, that it was losing significant business to Ericsson, in particular that AT&T was shifting its favors towards the Swedish giant. In 2004, AT&T awarded a $2bn 3G infrastructure contract, with the deal split between Ericsson on about $900m, Lucent on $700m and Siemens $400m, but according to the report, Alcatel-Lucent delayed delivering the technology and Ericsson ‘stepped in’ to increase its share to over half of the total. Alcatel-Lucent denied speculation that AT&T was considering dropping it altogether, but clearly such reports are shaking confidence in a merger that is already coming under shareholder fire after a string of disappointing results and profit warnings.

The key problem for Alcatel-Lucent is Ericsson’s ability, and willingness, to compete aggressively on price in GSM and W-CDMA, something the Swedish company balances with its shift to higher margin managed services and media activities, and with its economies of scale. Alcatel was throwing well publicized accusations at its largest competitor pre-merger, saying that Ericsson’s undercutting made it almost impossible to compete in GSM, but the result of the war has been that most of the savings Alcatel-Lucent targeted from their merger have actually gone on lowering prices to keep competitive with Ericsson ‘ and to a lesser extent, the Chinese vendors. In order to retain or win customers during the uncertain period after the merger, Alcatel-Lucent has been forced to discount heavily, for instance charging only $400m for a massive GSM expansion roll-out at Reliance Telecom in India. Some analysts believe this would, in normal pricing, be worth double that, and so margins are suffering. In the second quarter, gross margins were down 5% year-on-year and revenues slumped by 8% (and 15% the quarter before).

The merged outfit has also encountered customer resistance to rationalizing the product line too quickly to eliminate overlap, so savings on this front have been slow to materialize, even as the company has accelerated its projected timescales for making efficiencies. At major clients like Orange and AT&T, the company is supporting product lines that are due to be discontinued as well as new ones, and, as Russo admitted recently, have also to ‘give incentives to customers not to leave’. Both product lines will broadly be supported until 2009.

‘We don’t know when the margins of the combined company will be better than the ones before the merger,’ said Paul Sagawa, a Sanford Bernstein analyst, to the Wall Street Journal.

Ericsson has lost no chance to exploit the uncertainties surrounding its two major rivals, and its ‘Project Stealth’ was a non-too stealthy program to boost its wireless infrastructure share beyond the magical 40% line. ‘We knew their management would be distracted and preoccupied,’ said Bert Nordberg, Ericsson’s executive VP of sales and marketing, describing the project.

All this is raising serious questions over the future of CEO Pat Russo, following three consecutive quarterly profit and revenue warnings, the latest last month. Alcatel-Lucent’s share price is down 30% since the beginning of the year; and since the merger was announced, has lost about $12bn in market capitalization ‘ about the total pre-merger value of Lucent, for which Alcatel shareholders have frequently said they paid too high a price.

The French media, some analysts and investors are calling for Russo’s resignation, prompting the Alcatel-Lucent board to issue a statement of support for ‘Pat Russo and the leadership team’ last Tuesday. At the same time, however, the board asked Russo to detail her turnaround plans at a meeting on October 30.

The Siemens probes:

Last week, Siemens accepted a €201m ($284.1m) fine from the Munich District Court and reached a settlement with German tax authorities on questionable payments, ending investigations into illegal conduct and tax violations at its former communications unit. This ended German investigations into illegal conduct and tax violations at the unit, with Siemens waiving its right to appeal.

However, the group is still under investigation by the European law enforcement agency, the US Department of Justice and the US Securities and Exchange Commission for suspected bribery involving ‘ according to a Siemens internal probe as reported in the Wall Street Journal ‘ some €1.6bn.

Loescher has announced a restructuring along the lines of Siemens’s three remaining major businesses – infrastructure/industry, energy and medical technology. The heads of these units will sit on the group’s central management board, reducing the power of previously dominant regional bosses and seeking to increase streamlining and accountability. Loescher will present a detailed plan on November 28 and in the meantime is expected to identify further units for sale, following the divestment of the automotive division to Continental AG. The trains business and the Osram lighting unit are possible candidates for sell-off. Loescher says a key growthobjective is to increase focus in Asia.