Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 October 2007

WiMAX can be tool for inward expansion into western Europe

Western Europe was once expected to be a wasteland for WiMAX, because of the advanced state of both DSL and 3G coverage, but many bold movers have seen greater success than expected, and now international players as well as some incumbents are eyeing the technology. The place of WiMAX in Europe’s pre-4G and convergence pictures will be primarily decided by the results of the forthcoming auctions of 2.5GHz-2.7GHz spectrum, most of which will take place in 2008-9.

The European Union has favored making this band technology neutral, rather than mandating certain technologies, and in fact this divisive issue will be almost neutralized by the adoption of 802.16e as an approved IMT-2000 platform along with the various 3G variants. Most regulators will make IMT-2000, rather than a specific technology like HSPA or LTE, the requirement for the new spectrum. Therefore, WiMAX’ level of success will depend on how many license winners decide to use 802.16e instead of, or alongside, these stronger European networks. Some 3G operators, even Vodafone, have hinted at using WiMAX, but are likely to do this for limited hotzone deployments, such as enterprise services, or outside their core territories. WiMAX’ real hopes of becoming mainstream lie with non-3G operators, or players from outside Europe, winning licenses.

As the recent WiMAX World conference in Chicago highlighted, in a panel debate on WiMAX in Europe, there is already significant activity around the standard, mainly in 3.5GHz ‘ in which there is plentiful spectrum in the region, much of it reasonably priced. Companies like WiMAX Telecom, Irish Broadband and UK Broadband are all pursuing innovative business models and aiming to move from a traditional fixed/nomadic model to full mobility using 802.16e, when the technology, devices and regulators allow.

Also participating was Telecom Italia, which has been one of the most advanced of the European incumbents in trialling WiMAX and forming plans to combine it with Wi-Fi, 3G and DSL to support a quad play and other growth models. Italy started slowly in WiMAX, since even its 3.5GHz licenses have not yet been auctioned ‘ ministers have finally, and painfully, agreed on auction rules but have not yet set a date, but expect to raise about €80m per license. However, Italy is expected to be one of the most competitive markets in 2.5GHz, as international players converge on the country to take a share of its advanced quad play progress (see separate item). Vodafone recently bought the Italian assets of Sweden’s Tele2, while Orascom, the rapidly expanding Egypt-based international operator, is widely expected to seek a 2.5GHz license for WiMAX (it already owns cellco Wind).

WiMAX is seen by many potentially disruptive and expansionist groups as a tool to spread their wings. These include NextWave Wireless from the US, which has already acquired spectrum in various parts of Europe and a controlling stake in WiMAX Telecom; and several Russian players looking westwards. Another example is Naguib Sawiris, the Egyptian tycoon who owns the Weather Investments holding group, which controls Wind and Greece’s TIM Hellas, and owns half of Orascom Telecom, one of the most ambitious of the new breed of international carriers. Orascom has GSM and some 3G activities in the Middle East, Mediterranean and North Africa, but also has a separate venture called Orascom WiMAX in partnership with Intel, and sees this as a vehicle to expand quickly in some areas where cellular incumbents are hard to dislodge, or 3G is delayed. TIM Hellas owns Q-Telecom, which has a national 3.5GHz license in its home country and will start rolling out a national network next year. And recently, Orascom subsidiary Pakistan Mobile Communications (Mobilink) announced that it will launch a WiMAX network in 3.5GHz, with equipment from Alcatel-Lucent, in all major cities in the country by the end of 2008. Another subsidiary, Mobinil in Egypt, has been testing WiMAX with Motorola and will bid for 3.5GHz spectrum later this year.

A recent report in business newspaper Milano Finanza noted that Wind may be a surprise bidder in the forthcoming 3.5GHz as well as 2.5GHz spectrum auctions in Italy. Wind has made several attempts to acquire broadband and triple play assets in Italy, though it lost Tele2’s Italian unit to Vodafone. This may make WiMAX the lowest cost option for the cellco to expand into fixed and converged broadband.

Sawiris said at the formation of Orascom WiMAX last year: ‘WiMAX ‘is the future’. Every time a company loses time to include WiMAX technology, they are either losing an opportunity or living with future failures that they are currently unaware of.’ By contrast, he has publicly referred to 3G as a ‘flop’ and told French financial paper Les Echos that Wind has ‘not spent one eurocent on 3G investments in Italy’. Other possible targets for Orascom include a bid for French GSM operator Bouygues, or a partnership with broadband provider Iliad to acquire France’s fourth GSM license in 2008.

According to the UK’s Financial Times, Weather Investments has been in talks with private equity firms with a view to raising capital by selling a 30% stake for about €2.5bn. However, the FT reported that the firms – Blackstone Group, Texas Pacific Group and Permira ‘ are not willing to pay more than €2bn.

While activity continues in the 3.5GHz band ‘ which UK Broadband claims makes up for its inferior propagation qualities, compared to 2.5GHz or below, with the low cost of spectrum ‘ the stage is set for the 2.5GHz-2.69GHz auctions. Norway, Sweden, Austria and the UK will go first and will set important precedents on pricing and rulemaking ‘ in particular, how much of the bandwidth will be set aside for TDD, in which WiMAX is a natural contender (although FDD profiles are under development too).

Norway is likely to go first, by year end, and is also auctioning 2010MHz-2025MHz spectrum, as is Austria. Then the UK is scheduled for the first quarter of 2008, and the other two for the second quarter.

European body CEPT has recommended 50MHz for TDD and 2x70MHz for FDD, but regulators can make their own decisions. In Norway, for instance, the regulator plans to offer larger amounts of TDD spectrum (100MHz against 2x40MHz) to satisfy high demand from the WiMAX community. Sweden and Norway will both allow operators to change from TDD to FDD even after acquiring the licenses.

In the UK, the auction will have two phases. In the first, operators will bid for generic lots, which will determine how much spectrum is allocated for FDD and TDD. In the second, operators will bid for specific blocks of spectrum. Regulator Ofcom expects to exceed the 50MHz guideline for TDD allocation. UK licenses are expected to be among the most expensive because of the presence in the country of BT.

Pipex Wireless:

The UK’s major holder of 3.5GHz spectrum, Pipex Wireless, has renamed itself Freedom4 and will launch services geared to small and medium enterprises by the end of this year. The company is a joint venture between former parent Pipex and Intel.

CEO Mike Read refused to give details of pricing or precise timing but referred to the SME space as the company’s ‘sweet spot’ because Freedom4 can offer asymmetric services, plus greater flexibility, than business DSL, without the company being forced to take on the expense of leased lines.

A consumer launch will follow, though Read does not seem to have a clear business model in mind, except that Freedom4 will not go down the ‘free broadband’ route, as it lacks other services to bundle. ‘The industry would drive me down to give it away for free,’ he said, while with SMEs, there is clear ROI. Read says 60-80 customers per base station achieves break-even. Consumer services are likely to depend on whether UK regulator Ofcom allows mobility in this band.

Freedom4 will sell mainly through local resellers that are already targeting SMEs. COO Brendan O’Rourke said: ‘We can give the resellers a good margin compared with what they get on DSL.’ The company can also use its parent’s Pipex Business’ channels.

Inset: Telenor:

Telenor will roll out the first commercial stage of its WiMAX network in Norway this year, having carried out two years of tests in its 3.5GHz spectrum. Some of the main testing has been in the North Sea where the operator plans to bring broadband to offshore oil rigs.

While Telenor has an ADSL broadband network that covers over 90% of the population, there are still 700,000-800,000 homes that lack broadband access, as well as several thousand businesses. The first to be covered by WiMAX will be along the Tr’ndelag coast in central Norway, based around the city of Trondheim.

The company said in a statement that it has submitted a plan to the county of S’r-Tr’ndelag, which includes the municipalities of Fr’ya, Hitra, Kl’bu and Snillfjord. ‘In addition to the private market, there are also fish farming plants and other industries which are looking forward to receiving broadband coverage in this area,’ the telco said.

It is using Airspan base stations for its network. Initially it will limit data services to 2Mbps but higher rates, plus voice, will be added from later in 2008.