Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 October 2007

CSIRO may have come to agreement with IEEE on 802.11n patent licensing

Progress on final ratification of the 802.11n fast Wi-Fi standard has been slowed by uncertainty over whether Australian research group CSIRO, which claims core patents in the platform, would work within the IEEE licensing guidelines. However, last Wednesday it appeared the issue could be settled, when the institute belatedly responded to IEEE calls for clarification, raising hopes that legal threats against 802.11n vendors would not materialize.

The IEEE 802 committee asked CSIRO earlier this year for a letter concerning how it would deal with any essential technology in 802.11n that it believed it owned, and this has now been received, though its content has not yet been made public. However, IEEE 802 chairman Paul Nikolich said in the statement that he was ‘confident’ the 802.11n project would now be completed. T

Earlier this year, CSIRO won an injunction against the US arm of Buffalo Technology for infringement of patents that claim to be part of the 802.11a and 802.11g standards. The group also has suits pending against several other WLan vendors concerning these older platforms.

Most Wi-Fi vendors are already producing equipment conforming to draft 2 of the 802.11n standard, and the Wi-Fi Alliance even has a certification program for this interim specification. Two weeks ago, the 802.11n taskgroup started the process of writing and voting on a third draft that it hopes will turn into the final standard, but this is likely to take until July 2008 to gain ratification.

CSIRO filed its first US patent for invention of a wireless Lan in 1993 and was awarded this in January 1996. The following year, it set up the company Radiata, with Australia’s Macquarie University, for the purposes of commercializing the patent, and this company was acquired in 2001 by Cisco for $295m. From 2003, CSIRO has been in licensing discussions with several manufacturers, but none have agreed to pay what it claims are ‘reasonable and non-discriminatory terms’, leading it to sue Buffalo in 2005 as a test case. This prompted two groups of vendors, including Dell, Intel, Microsoft, HP and Netgear , to file suit gainst CSIRO seeking to overturn its patent. So far, these have been unsuccessful, and in the Buffalo case CSIRO’s patent was upheld.