Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

22 October 2007

WiMAX victory in ITU could speed Qualcomm’s move to multiple technologies

Qualcomm is claiming a significant victory in its ongoing legal battle with Nokia, but as its UMB (UltraMobile Broadband) technology increasingly looks like the third wheel on the road to 4G, the chipmaker is showing signs of accommodating a multi-technology world. As WiMAX gained its expected acceptance by the ITU (International Telecommunications Union) as an official IMT2000 wireless standard ‘ removing many potential regulatory barriers to its adoption in cellular bands ‘ Qualcomm remains positioned against the technology, but its CEO has dropped some of his strongest hints yet that Qualcomm will be embracing a range of platforms for the next decade.

WiMAX Forum president Ron Resnick welcomed the ITU Radiocommunications sector’s decision, which adds a new technology to IMT2000 for the first time in a decade, saying it placed WiMAX “on equal footing with the legacy-based technologies ITU-R already endorses’. Although many regulators are moving towards technology neutrality anyway, even in bands previously allocated for 3G, this move will free up operators in nearly all territories to choose WiMAX in key spectrum like2.5GHz in Europe, whose auctions are due to start next year.

Though expected, the decision is another setback for Qualcomm, which had opposed the inclusion of WiMAX in IMT2000, and the ITU decision may push the CDMA giant further towards adopting 802.16e, which despite the company’s public criticism of WiMAX, CEO Paul Jacobs has said it will do if the market is large enough. Jacobs, who is considerably less religious about technology than his father and Qualcomm chairman Irwin Jacobs, or many of his executives, reinforced speculation that the chipmaker will soon set out a more explicitly multi-platform silicon roadmap, perhaps at next February’s 3GSM event in Spain.

At the recent 3G CDMA North America Regional Conference in San Diego, California, Paul Jacobs kicked off his keynote address saying: ‘It’s good to be among friends. I’ve been dealing with a few people who aren’t my friends, so it’s good to be welcome.’ He went through the usual plugs for CDMA’s continuing strength ‘ 377m subscribers currently using the technology, arguments for UMB being the most advanced of the OFDM options ‘ but his main theme was that 4G will be a merging of multiple technologies into one chipset that will deliver seamless services best suited for each network available. ‘I think the next step is really a merging,’ he said. ‘Moving forward we’ll have the chipsets to make it cost effective to include multiple technologies with CDMA. Then I think we’ll get to this mode where we don’t have to have this religious war.’

This is hardly a unique view, but it is significant to hear the Qualcomm chief take such a high profile line on the end of the technology war it helped create. It also shows the key competitive line that Qualcomm will need to pursue and deliver as its IPR business almost inevitably changes and declines. The chipmaker is well recognized as a strong player in integrating multiple technologies into compact, power efficient chipsets, and this will be the most important way to keep itself competitive in a world where it can no longer own any of the major platforms.

This new openness to a more flexible platform is being forced by the need to stay ahead in advanced silicon technologies, retaining revenues and corporate value even in the face of possible IPR decline; and by the actions of operators, which are demonstrating increased interest in 802.16e, and signs of defecting from CDMA2000 and so, by implication, its pre-4G iteration UMB. Unlike WiMAX and LTE, UMB is not expected to make a major play to be a migration path for carriers that are not currently using CDMA2000, which means its future depends on commitment from key operators. If this is not forthcoming, UMB is likely to be stillborn – like EV-DV, which was removed from the Qualcomm roadmap in the face of cellco coolness (and a strategy by TI and Nokia to steal a march in this market). EV-DV had a ready replacement, however, in the shape of EV-DO Rev A with increased VoIP support ‘ and one that saved Qualcomm supporting a dual R&D investment. By contrast, without UMB it will have to compete solely in pre-4G technologies that it does not control. It is no stranger to this now ‘ although it reaps the benefits of its IPR holdings in W-CDMA/HSPA, it has become a major force in this sector mainly through the excellence of its product delivery. Without UMB, and without dominant IPR positions in OFDM, Qualcomm will be forced back to a far more level playing field in LTE (and possibly WiMAX), than it has ever experienced before.

The auspices are not good that sufficient carrier commitment to UMB will be made to overcome the major vendors’ current scepticism (Nortel has UMB on its R&D plan, but has publicly said it is not convinced the system will ever come to market). Verizon Wireless recently made strong indications that it might harmonize its next generation strategy with that of co-owner Vodafone, and focus on LTE with some WiMAX thrown in. Sprint Nextel and KT are using WiMAX, KDDI would like to if it can get spectrum, Bell Canada is undecided. In another key market, India, CDMA operators were last week given the green light to roll out GSM services, marking a likely drift away from Qualcomm’s platform, and Vivo in Brazil is also shifting to GSM, while it seems highly likely that none of the eventual 3G license holders in China will use CDMA2000.

India’s Reliance Communications, plus two regional CDMA operators, HFCL Infotel and Shyam Telelink, have gained approval to offer GSM under their existing licenses, although the other CDMA major, Tata, did not apply. Reliance operates India’s largest CDMA network, with 30.77m subscribers nationwide at the end of August, but it also runs a GSM network in eight of the country’s 23 telecom regions through its Reliance Telecom subsidiary and now plans to invest $7bn in extending that nationally. GSM operators, which applied to expand their networks last year, are still waiting for spectrum, and are opposing the government’s new decision.

Few would doubt Qualcomm’s ability to execute a multi-technology strategy, or that it will be pragmatic enough to do this in pursuit of the lead position in cellular baseband chips ‘ for all the apparent rigidity of its public pronouncements around the superiorty and longevity of CDMA-based systems, the company has made several compromises in reality, including its now enthusiastic adoption of the once despised Wi-Fi. The major complicating factor for Qualcomm is, of course, its IPR business. This faces two issues ‘ one, that although the company has been amassing patents in OFDM in order to make an IPR play in WIMAX, LTE and other next generation networks, it is inconceivable that it could achieve the dominant position it has in CDMA; and two, even if it did gain such an advantage, it would almost certainly have to change its licensing business model to come into line with other major patent holders such as Samsung, Nokia and Intel, reducing its IPR revenues and margins. Already, its model is under significant pressure, with the EU fast tracking a probe into alleged antitrust, and a string of patent-related lawsuits with Nokia, Broadcom and others.

While it seems almost impossible that Qualcomm will be able to retain its current IPR model intact, it is certainly not going to make any concessions until it absolutely has to, despite hints from Paul Jacobs that the company does have contingency plans, including even a spin-off of the licensing business if it comes under sufficiently severe EU attack. But in the short term, Qualcomm is showing remarkable resilience, continuing to outperform expectations in its core chip business for several quarters, thus demonstrating the intrinsic strength of its silicon activities; and winning some victories in its legal fights. The US International Trade Commission, which ruled in favour of Broadcom and awarded an injunction against import of new handsets containing Qualcomm chips based on certain disputed patents, has since watered down the effect of that ruling; and now the same body has advised Nokia to drop its own ITC action against Qualcomm.

Judge Paul Luckern judge recommended ending an ITC investigation of a complaint brought by Nokia against Qualcomm, although the Commission has 30 days from last Friday to make the recommendation final or review it further. In August, Nokia petitioned the ITC to halt US imports of phones containing Qualcomm chips that it claims infringe on Nokia patents related to technology that enhances performance, lowers manufacturing costs and improves battery life.Luckern’s recommendation was made because the two antagonists are already in arbitration over their dispute over renegotiation of licensing terms, following the expiry of their former agreement in April. Many of the two companies’ legal actions against each other are clearly aiming to increase the pressure in this critical dispute, which could set important precedents for the cost of licensing, and therefore handsets, across the whole sector.

Nokia said the company was disappointed by the decision but noted that the recommendation was not based on the merits of the complaints. The ITC is also considering a complaint brought by Qualcomm against Nokia in June, accusing the phonemaker of infringing three patents. Both this and the EU decisions are not expected until mid-2008.