Ericsson blotted its recently pristine copybook with a third quarter profit warning that sent its shares crashing, wiping out $15.7bn of market capitalization. It blamed an unexpected shortfall in sales of high margin products for the weak third quarter ‘ despite its gains in market share, as it exploits the weaknesses of its major rivals Alcatel-Lucent and Nokia Siemens Networks, these are coming at the expense of aggressive price cutting that is hitting margins, before Ericsson’s moves into more profitable activities, such as managed services, convergence and multimedia, really affect the bottom line.
Ericsson issued a warning, saying it had only just closed the books and would report full results on October 25. The Swedish market leader in telecoms infrastructure said it expects third quarter net income of SKr4bn (about $625m) a 36% drop from the year earlier period; on a sales increase of 6% to SKr43.5bn, below its own and market expectations. The company’s closely watched gross margin will narrow to 35.6% from 38.2% a year earlier.
Ericsson CEO Carl-Henric Svanberg said the company would ‘self-critically’ look at why it didn’t forsee the problems earlier, but denied a full scale strategic review was needed at this stage.
The company’s shares slumped 24% to SKr20.10 ($3.13) in Stockholm on the news, but rivals’ stocks fell too, reflecting the fact that problems at Ericsson are indicative of pressures across the industry, rather than being specific to the Swedish vendor, which is currently the most effective player in the game. Nokia shares fell 3.2% to €24.80 ($35.22) in Helsinki and Alcatel-Lucent’s dropped 4.5% to €6.59 in Paris. Ericsson’s American depository shares fell 23% to $31.33 on the Nasdaq.
In an analyst conference call, Svanberg said: ‘Both in North America and in Western Europe, particularly the UK and Italy, we have situations where operators have late entered into consolidation talks and network sharing talks, and such discussions typically hold back short term orders, as these operators don’t necessarily know exactly how their network configuration and so on could look ‘ It is not, from our point of view, a signal on a change in the market outlook.’
Ericsson suffered a fall in orders for its high margin products such as 3G/HSPA. Chairman Michael Treschow said in an interview that the company would review how it misread the market, but was supportive of Svanberg’s management team, which he said had delivered ‘phenomenal results’ for the past four years. Svanberg said about 20% of Ericsson’s network business comes from shorter term contracts such as network upgrades and expansions, which can be ordered at short notice. A shortfall in such orders helped trigger the warning, he said.
‘This is a day to be humble, concerned and disappointed,’ he added during a press conference. ‘This is a dynamic business environment. We should have talked more about it and understood more about it. We have underestimated the impact of changes.’
He said that fourth quarter sales are expected to be between SKr53bn ($8.2bn) and SKr60 bn ($9.3bn), with an operating margin in the ‘mid-teens,’ compared with 22.7% in the fourth quarter of 2006. The operating margin in the second quarter this year was 19.4%, and is expected to be 12.9% in the third quarter.
In a market where price competition is increasing dramatically, volume and market share will be vital to survival, as witnessed by the wave of consolidation among the infrastructure vendors. Ericsson is certainly succeeding in increasing its market weight. In April, it had 35% share, followed by NSN on 30% and Alcatel-Lucent on about 20%. Now Ericsson is estimated to have 45-47% share, with NSN on 27% and Alcatel-Lucent on 13%. ‘We have pushed on market share because it is so strategic. Now it’s time to leverage our position, so next year there’s going to be less focus on gaining market share,’ said Svanberg in the press conference.
Analysts generally agreed with the well respected CEO that this warning is down to a temporary blip, mainly a short term slowdown in network upgrades and expansions, despite the more general trends of price pressure and a shift to lower margin markets like India. ‘Operators are healthy, networks are loaded, traffic is increasing,’ said Svanberg. ‘They build greater footprint for future network expansions and upgrades.’ Nomura International, in a research note, broadly agreed: ‘The fundamentals of the mobile industry remain intact as new subscribers keep on joining the network and we are seeing the first signs of a lift-off in data usage. Sooner or later operators will have to resume spending on both capacity upgrades and software.’