Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

29 October 2007

Sony and KDDI are the latest to challenge iPhone bandwagon

Sony last week make a clear statement of intent to stick to devices and new online services, such as music services to rival Apple iTunes, and to get out of major chip businesses, as its management comes to terms with its failure to totally dominate the third generation of home gaming consoles.

The music announcement took center stage, and as with all music services, fear of the Apple iPhone appears to color every decision, whether it is taken by major consumer electronics vendors, operators or handset leaders. Sony and Japan’s second largest cellular operator, KDDI, said they would launch a music service together, and the announcement had more than a touch of iPhone panic about it.

For three years handset makers and operators have been predicting that the portable music lead of the iPod would be shortlived and that the handset was the natural place for a music service, but instead of just keeling over and accepting its fate Apple got to the handset first and now all those confident noises are overpowered by ‘hurry up’ sounds, as everyone that cannot benefit directly from the iPhone prepares for life alongside it.

If a music service does not have the support of a major operator, or a handset manufacturer the size of Nokia, in any given region, then it is unlikely to survive the midterm onslaught that the iPhone is stimulating. Either the iPhone will get you, or one of the well supported responses to the iPhone will.

In Japan, the licensed content from both the prior KDDI music effort, called Lismo (Listen Mobile), and the now defunct Sony Connect service will both be on the new offering, which will become part of KDDI’s ‘au’ portal, under the sub-brand ‘au x Sony Music Project’. The service will also work with the Sony Walkman portable players and ‘NetJuke’ high definition conventional stereo system, offering the options of direct access over cellular spectrum, or downloaded and copied from the PC, or from conventional audio equipment.

In Japan something like half of online music is downloaded specifically for a handset, but so far mobile phones, PCs and audio equipment have been separate environments. For instance, KDDI rival Softbank offers free downloads of music intended for a handset, but these are sent to a PC for sideloading because this is cheaper than using cellular bandwidth to download them. But the sideloaded content will not play on the PC or on conventional music equipment and payment for the track is triggered through the operator’s billing system only once these tracks are downloaded to a handset.

KDDI and Sony say they are aiming for an environment where music can be enjoyed freely across the mobile phone, PC, and audio equipment – virtually identical to way that AT&T and Apple have teamed up over the iPhone, but using the Walkman brand. Last month Sony announced new Walkman players which can hold 8Gb of music and video, the same as the iPhone.

The Sony-KDDI deal also comes on the back of a DVD burning service launched by the operator under the same ‘au’ portal brand at the end of September. This uses CPRM digital rights management (DRM) technology to allow KDDI customers to burn movie, animation, and video content to DVD-RWs on their PC via their broadband connection – again a shut-out for Apple, which uses its own proprietary Fairplay DRM. Initially the KDDI option will launch with 1,000 video titles, rising to around 5,000 by the end of the year with content from 60 content providers including major studios such as Warner Brothers. CPRM is a system of content transfer which uses a hidden key to make any piece of memory, such as recordable DVDs and Flash memory, capable of storing copyrighted content safely.

These music and online video burning deals are designed to secure the Japanese market for Sony devices in music and for companies supporting CRPM – Apple has promised to launch the iPhone in Japan in Spring of 2008, but it doesn’t look as though it will be through KDDI. From Sony’s point of view, the moves show it operating a strategy of working through operators, in the same way as Apple in music, and very unlike Nokia, which has created its own Ovi portal to offer music, video and games to handsets, but also to PCs, and perhaps later to set-tops. Nokia may feel that it has the brand to take devices to market in competition with its operator customers, but Sony perhaps, and Sony Ericsson in particular, don’t feel ready for that approach.

However the operator route may not be available to Sony in the US, where AT&T’s music effort is clearly based around the iPhone (and Napster ‘ see inset) and where Verizon Wireless has already partnered with the MTV/RealNetworks Rhapsody music service.

Sony and microprocessors:

Sony’s move to focus on devices and online services shows it clearly moving away from component supply, a business in which it has always been a little uneasy. The company has spent around $2bn during the past three years, to get into microprocessor design, as the legendary Ken Kutaragi, the now retired Sony games console chief, took the company into manufacturing the IBM/Sony/Toshiba-designed Cell chip. The Cell is at the heart of the Sony PlayStation 3 console, as well as workstations and supercomputers supplied by IBM, but has not yet shipped in the numbers needed to drive down its costs.

Sony will sell the Cell manufacturing facilities to Toshiba, with newspapers reporting that it will get less than $1bn, which will result in a crystallized loss for Sony on the chip facility in Nagasaki. The deal will be complete by March next year. Sony CEO Howard Stringer said earlier this year that the company had to cut back on chip spending and would probably not do a 45nm version of the Cell. Given that the PS3 is shipping in lower numbers than Sony initially projected, it has its work cut out to catch up with the Microsoft Xbox shipments, and to keep up with the runaway success of the Nintendo Wii, which it was announced last week will shortly launch in mainland China.

Toshiba recently announced a version of the Cell chip to drive a system for PC users to control a DVD player from a range of 10 feet using hand commands.

3 and Telefonica launch music stores:

Another defensive move in Asia-Pacific against the arrival of iTunes was taken last week by 3 Hong Kong, which has launched the new Omnifone MusicStation service there, as a subscription offering costing just $1.55 a week. 3 MusicStation includes catalogs from all the major record labels including UMG, Sony BMG, EMI and Warner Music. The service will come with a full traditional Chinese interface in addition to an English language interface, and could be readymade for the broader Chinese market. Low iPod penetration there, and the lack of iTunes stores in Asia-Pacific (except in Australia, Japan and New Zealand), means that most consumers sideload music to their phones.

Many operators have made commitments to Musicstore, most significantly Vodafone in key European territories.

Meanwhile, Telefonica says it has launched ‘ the cheapest mobile music service in Europe’, offering an unlimited number of download tracks for a flat rate tariff of €6 a month. The Spanish operator has signed distribution deals with content owners such as Sony/BMG, Universal/Vale, Warner and EMI, as well as many independent labels, and has the usual 1m songs available to download from its music store.

AT&T and iPhone performance:

Apple beat Wall Street’s estimate in its fourth quarter, and announced that it had sold more than 1.1m iPhones, bringing its cumulative total to 1.4m since launch on June 29. In the quarter, the first full one to be affected by the iPhone, Apple saw profits leap almost 67% to $904m, compared to the year-ago period, on revenues up from $4.84bn to $6.22bn. The company ended its fiscal year with $15.4bn in cash and no debt and says its full year results will see revenues topping $24bn.

Other strong performers were the Mac computers, which hit a new record of 2.2m sales in the quarter, up 34% year-on-year; and the iPod, which sold 10.2m units, a 17% rise. Apple expects revenues of about $9.2bn in the first quarter of fiscal 2008, with the impact of the holiday season, and is looking to shift 10m iPhones in calendar 2008.

One interesting aspect of the iPhone figures ‘ about 250,000 unlocked iPhones are out there, around 17% of the total.

This may lead AT&T to question the terms of its agreement with Apple which, though the details are closely guarded, are famously generous to the device maker. One analyst, Gene Munster from Piper Jaffray, estimated in a recent research note that Apple gets $18 a month for each iPhone subscriber from AT&T, under the two companies’ revenue sharing deal, which over the two-year life of the contract would be more than the retail price of an iPhone. Munster had previously estimated the figures at $3 per subscriber and $11 for any iPhone customer that was new to AT&T, but has now revised these numbers in the light of the Q4 results. Discounting the 250,000 unlocked models, there are now1.15m AT&T iPhones in play, generating $118m in iPhone-related revenues. Munster used these statistics, and AT&T’s data charges, to make his revised guess. Clearly, if these figures are anywhere close to accurate, Apple has a powerful incentive not to let the shift towards unlocking ‘ forced upon it in France, for instance ‘ become a major trend.

AT&T has also reaped strong benefits from its Apple deal so far. The carrier said it added a net 2m subscribers in its third quarter, the highest Q3 increase in its history, and surpassing analyst expectations of 1.5m-1.8m net adds. AT&T’s total wireless subscriber base now tops 65.7m. In the quarter, it activated 1.12m iPhones, with over 40% of these being new customers.

Overall, wireless revenues totaled $10.9bn, up 14.4% from the year earlier quarter. ARPU was up 2% to $50.82 and data revenues rose 63.9%. Average monthly subscriber churn was 1.7%, while postpaid churn was down 20 points from a year earlier, at 1.3%.

AT&T has also announced a plan to broaden its partnership with online music store Napster, to offer full download of tunes from Napster’s catalogue of 5m songs over the air. This would be similar to AT&T’s recent agreement with eMusic. Napster Mobile is the main element of a broader AT&T music push that also includes a mobile video service called MobiVJ, provided by MobiTV, which allows users to select up to eight music video channels, organized by genre, for $7 a month.

Despite AT&T’s success, rival Verizon Wireless is reiterating its claim that it walked away from the iPhone. CEO Lowell McAdam said in a recent interview with FierceWireless that the cellco carefully evaluated the iPhone opportunity but found both the business model and the distribution model unsatisfactory., McAdam said that Verizon Wireless did not like ‘restricted’ distribution, with Apple asking that Verizon not service iPhone customers. ‘We have put a huge investment into training our people,’ McAdam said. ‘The model was to say ‘thanks for coming in’ and then point them down the street to Apple.’

He also believes the user interface will be easily emulated or bettered, and that the financial model was too onerous. ‘We made a $40bn investment in our network in the last eight years. I don’t think that kind of revenue split was commensurate with the investment that we have in the network.’

This analysis was originally published by Wireless Watch’s sister service Faultline, which provides weekly in-depth insights into broadband digital media markets and technologies, and the economics of the quad play. Please contact Linda Elisha on [email protected] for more information.