The World Radiocommunication Conference (WRC-07) is underway, representing the most significant talking shop in the industry for global spectrum policy. Last held in 2003, the WRC usually results in far-reaching recommendations for usage and regulation of wireless spectrum ‘ although these may take many years to be adopted in anything close to a uniform way. Key 2003 decisions like harmonizing the rules governing the 5GHz band are only just making a tangible impact on telecoms on a global scale. However, with the demands for wireless resources at an unprecedented level ‘ for purposes from mobile broadband to universal access to new industrial applications ‘ this WRC will be more significant than its predecessors, and after years of preparation, all the major national and international agencies have honed their lobbying skills to the highest degree. Similarly, many have been delaying crucial decisions on subjects such as 3G/4G licensing and broadband wireless bands until they see the way the land lies after the WRC.
Two early issues that have emerged relate to one of the most important generic issues affecting wireless ‘ how to balance licensed, unlicensed and lightly licensed allocations, and how to open up larger swathes of spectrum without denying incumbent rights or causing commercial and interference chaos. The GSM Association is leading the call for 100MHz of analog television spectrum to be assigned to mobile broadband, while the wireless industry is trying to minimize the imposition of anti-interference restrictions in unlicensed bands, despite the counter-arguments of other spectrum users in the defense, transport, utilities and other sectors.
The GSMA called on the WRC to allocate about 100MHz of bandwidth in the UHF range ‘ the 470MHz to 806/862MHz band ‘ for mobile services, especially because these low frequencies are well suited to rural coverage, with support for large cells and therefore low cost of build-out in sparsely populated areas. Low frequencies are also strong for business models requiring strong indoor penetration. Of course, the 700MHz portion of the analog TV spectrum is already hotly debated in countries where it will soon be reassigned, such as the US and India, but the GSMA is looking to a broader availability of UHF bandwidth for its members, particularly in developing or highly rural economies.
‘By reserving a chunk of the analog TV spectrum for mobile broadband, the world’s governments could take a major step towards closing the digital divide between those who enjoy high speed access to multimedia services today and the many people who can’t yet be economically served by broadband networks,’ said Tom Phillips, chief government and regulatory affairs officer at the association, which represents GSM/UMTS operators and interests. ‘It is important that the world’s governments set aside this spectrum in a harmonized way, enabling handset makers to achieve economies of scale, thereby reducing the cost of access devices for consumers.’
Members that would benefit especially strongly from access to plentiful spectrum at low frequencies ‘ because of their geographical focus ‘ leapt to support the demands, led by Orascom, the Egypt-based operator that is expanding rapidly in the Middle East, Mediterranean and Africa; India’s giant cellco Bharti; and Norway’s Telenor, which is expanding its interests in various geographical directions, notably in Russia and the former Soviet states.
The GSMA believes the WRC needs to identify sufficient UHF spectrum for mobile broadband services to ensure that at least 2x40MHz of paired spectrum can be made available. In the EMEA region, it has earmarked the 750MHz-862MHz band for mobile broadband services, while in the Americas it wants the 698MHz-806MHz band should be reserved for these purposes. ‘The Asia-Pacific region has the scope to align itself with either the EMEA region or the Americas region, enabling the mobile ecosystem to achieve as large economies of scale as possible,’ the GSMA said in a statement.
Another important issue for broadband wireless is access to new unlicensed spectrum with the fewest possible restrictions, and this will be debated at WRC-07, with related, more localized discussions already underway in various parts of the world. The main issue is that utilities, railroads, defense agencies and some licensed wireless operators insist strong safeguards are necessary to prevent interference in existing and future unlicensed frequencies.
In the US, the FCC recently rejected Cellnet Technology’s request that a spectrum etiquette’a mandatory combination of steps and protocols that a device must follow before accessing spectrum’be imposed in the 915MHz band, although Cellnet was arguing that a new approach is required because wireless services are proliferating in this area of spectrum (which is unlicensed in the US, though not in much of the rest of the world).
Despite its decision, the FCC conceded that Cellnet had some cause for concern, notably that under current regulations, ‘digitally modulated 915MHz devices may ‘ transmit continuously at the maximum power permitted by the rules’, with no limit on transmit bandwidth, so creating ‘a potential for a digitally modulated device or a group of digitally modulated devices to essentially occupy the entire 915MHz band, leaving little or no opportunity for other devices to gain access to the spectrum.’
In other bands, spectrum etiquette schemes have proved quite workable ‘ for instance, ‘detect and avoid’ rules for 5GHz Wi-Fi in many parts of the world; or operation of unlicensed PCS devices in the US’ 1920-1930MHz band.
The spectrum where this debate is currently most hotly contested in the US is in the white space, or unoccupied areas, of TV spectrum. The FCC recently rejected a prototype created by a group of vendors led by Microsoft, which claimed to be able to operate in these spaces without interfering with broadcasters ‘ but it later permitted Microsoft to resubmit an amended device. The most enthusiastic proponents of minimal restrictions are, of course, the companies that stand to gain from unlimited open access to internet services over wireless networks, such as Microsoft, Google, Intel and Cisco ‘ and even some less obvious suspects like the new-look web-focused Nokia. The opponents are the incumbents, who fear interference, and the operators that stand to lose from increased competition from unlicensed players. This is not just about the commercial wireless services, which tend to dominate the headlines, but other even more rapidly growing areas of wireless business, such as machine to machine (M2M) communications for industrial and automated consumer applications (this is how Cellnet, which provides real time automated meter reading for utilities, became a cheerleader for the spectrum etiquette lobby in 915MHz, which is a key band for M2M). It was joined by other vendors in this market, such as GE MDS, Freewave, Hunt Technologies and Dataradio, as well as utilities and railroads that use 915MHz for their internal operations and benefit from not having to acquire licensed spectrum for this.
‘An appropriate spectrum etiquette can provide an environment in which numerous users may operate in the same geographic area simultaneously, using only the minimum power and bandwidth they need for the particular application,’ Cellnet and Hunt told the FCC. ‘Such an approach protects current users in the band and ensures that the band will continue to be available to future innovation.’
The Wireless Communications Association International (WCAI) – representing the broadband wireless sector and particularly the Wi-Fi and WiMAX interests that hope to gain from unrestricted access – said it ‘continues to support voluntary frequency coordination and other best practises among unlicensed users, approaches that do not undermine the flexibility and technological innovation that has been critical to the success of unlicensed services over the past decade.’
It was backed by the Wi-Fi Alliance, which said in a statement: ‘We believe a good part of this spectacular success of Wi-Fi devices can be attributed to the fact that the development of these devices was encouraged by having unlicensed spectrum with minimum regulatory restrictions.’ The TIA, representing vendors, the IEEE standards body and the Consumer Electronics Association all added their voice to the lobbying of the FCC, and will take the same arguments to Geneva this week, as will individual vendors such as Cisco, which said last week that extending a spectrum etiquette to the current Wi-Fi bands – 2.4GHz and 5.8GHz ‘ and potential future growth areas for unlicensed wireless, such as 900MHz, would ‘economically degrade them’.
The WRC agenda:
The WRC-07 has opened in Geneva under the auspices of the International Telecommunications Union (ITU), and has about 30 major agenda items related to almost all terrestrial and space radio services and applications, including aeronautical telemetry and telecommand, satellite services, mobile communications, maritime distress and safety signals, digital broadcasting, weather satellites, and the prediction and detection of natural disasters.
WRC-07 will also consider options to improve the international spectrum regulatory framework.
Key issues of debate will include:
‘ New capabilities of systems, components and services in 3G and broadband wireless systems.
‘ Procedures for the introduction of high definition TV services.
‘ Revision of the regulatory procedures applicable to satellite services, including the plan for fixed satellite services.
‘ Global harmonization of user requirements and spectrum usage in electronic newsgathering.
‘ Access to spectrum for the provision of aeronautical telemetry and telecommand systems, compatible with the increasing complexity of aircraft design.
‘ The Maritime Mobile Service Identification system and its number formats.