Earthlink surprised nobody by admitting last week that it was considering a complete move out of municipal Wi-Fi. The ISP had pinned many of its hopes for escaping its dial-up heritage on creating a broadband alternative, in conjunction with the US cities’ enthusiasm for citywide wireless, that bypassed the telco lines. However, like most other providers, the company has been hard pressed to find a viable business model in the municipal market, and earlier this year it said it would not pursue new opportunities. Now it may pull out of even those cities where it has existing contracts, like Philadelphia, once the poster child for the municipal movement. This only highlights a general disillusionment with muni wireless, but the persistent interest of large vendors like Cisco shows that, while the early efforts may have been misguided, there is still demand for blanketing cities with low cost wireless ‘ but this will need to be supported with a different choice of revenue models and technologies.
Earthlink said it was considering ‘strategic alternatives’ for its municipal Wi-Fi operations, and even hinted at a price tag for a potential acquirer, saying in a statement that the ‘net book value of the assets attributable to Earthlink’s municipal wireless business is approximately $40m’. In August, when Earthlink first backed away from the muni market, CEO Rolla Huff said: ‘We will not devote any new capital to the old muni Wi-Fi model that has us taking all of the risk by fronting all of the capital, then paying to buy our customers one by one.’ Last week he went a step further, saying: ‘After thorough review and analysis of our municipal wireless business we have decided that making significant further investments in this business could be inconsistent with our objective of maximizing shareholder value.’
Earthlink has active networks in six cities and contracts for about the same number again. According to a recent SEC filing, the ISP claimed to manage 150 square miles of Wi-Fi networks across all its markets, covering 600,000 households. It has never disclosed any usage figures for any of its Wi-Fi operations.
This is a far wider problem than just Earthlink’s, however. Part of the issue with muni Wi-Fi has been Wi-Fi itself. The mistake was to associate the new business approach ‘ open access, low or not cost to consumers, with revenue from advertising and funding from local authorities in return for supporting services like CCTV – too closely with the technology. Wi-Fi in unlicensed spectrum was readily available, but was never going to be a sufficiently robust technology to support the ambitions of the Google-inspired internet lobby. Hence Google’s defocusing on muni Wi-Fi and passion for 700MHz licensed spectrum and new devices, and for pressurizing spectrum owners to adapt to open access models, rather than trying to create a new world from scratch in the unreliable license-exempt bands. The problems for implementing the muni approach on unlicensed Wi-Fi boiled down to inadequate technology; high risk spectrum; limited user demand; and conflicting operator requirements. Wi-Fi, for all its merits, is constrained in what it can deliver by its confinement to unlicensed bands, which are subject to interference and poor performance.
The other key problem has been the conflict of interest between the various objectives that got hopelessly confused in the municipal trend in the US. First came idealistic notions of bridging digital divides and opening internet access to all, which initially was envisaged being funded from the public purse. When this proved unacceptable to many taxpayers, advertising revenues were seen as the answer, but of course, while this encourage the likes of Google to get involved, advertisers are rarely prepared to pay high rates to target low income populations on the wrong side of the digital divide ‘ and meanwhile, their real target consumers were opting to pay more for reliable, licensed spectrum options. The third element, local authorities’ own need for networks to support more efficient administration plus applications like e-government or surveillance, also required far more reliable networks than Wi-Fi could typically guarantee. In addition, demand for free access was vastly overestimated by Google and the idealists ‘ low income residents often lack access to devices, except in libraries or schools, while higher income people generally require higher quality and are prepared to pay for it. In the recently published MuniWireless survey of US municipal wireless networks, it was found that, on average, municipal networks are being used in more than three different formats, with municipal usage by far the most prevalent form, followed by paid public access by residents, visitors and local businesses, and then by free public access. Moreover, while the first two categories are growing, free access is flattening.
So the future for municipal wireless may not contain Earthlink, but will rest with spectrum holders ‘ traditional or new – looking to combine Wi-Fi and licensed technologies to extend their reach and the range of services to offer. These are likely to offer various levels of service, from free and best effort, supported by advertising or sponsorship and often targeted at casual or visting, not necessarily low income, users; to premium offerings suited to enterprises or, indeed, local authority and emergency services use. In this picture, there is no real need for the local authority to be involved except as a customer, often one that can get a good deal by exchanging rights to rooftops or light poles for services. But there is a need for the providers to be skilled telecoms operators, and ones with access to a range of technologies, not just Wi-Fi ‘ a trail that Clearwire has already blazed with its WiMAX-based muni deal in Grand Rapids, Michigan.
In New York, broadcaster CBS is revisiting a model that was very popular before the Google-inspired municipal trend gathered steam ‘ sponsored hotzones. It is blanketing midtown Manhattan with Wi-Fi access and delivering news, sports and entertainment for free to WiFi-enabled devices. The ‘CBS Mobile Zone’ will cover a 20-block area from Times Square to Central Park and from 6th to 8th Avenues and the company is giving away routers to local businesses such as restaurants and coffee shops. The initiative is part of a pilot program with New York’s Metropolitan Transportation Authority and New York City Transit, and CBS has also partnered with mesh equipment vendor Tropos and free hotspot supremo FON. The system also uses CBS Outdoor, the media company’s network of billboards and marketing displays throughout the US, to house access points. This model has the advantage of multiple revenue opportunities ‘ paid-for third party advertising, free advertising of CBS’ own services, and the chance to partner with retailers of music and other content or products, with a revenue share.
Meanwhile, many more traditional attempts, most famously the San Francisco effort driven by Earthlink and (initially) Google, are foundering, as is another flagship Wi-Fi mesh project, though not a municipally funded one, the massive Silicon Valley network.
This ambitious plan to blanket 1,500 square miles of California’s Silicon Valley with wireless is in danger of failing to raise funds for even two test sites of one square mile each, according to reports in the San Jose Mercury News. The two test sites would need $500,000, which so far the region – one of the wealthiest in the US, but also one of the most wireless – has been unwilling to support.
The contract for the project, spawned by a non-profit venture called Joint Venture: SiliconValley Network, was awarded last year to Silicon Valley Metro Connect, a cooperative that has Cisco as its main supplier, IBM as systems integrator, Azulstar as the network owner and operator, and non-profit SeaKay to address digital inclusion issues.
The network, estimated to cost about $200m, was planned to cover 40 communities with some 2.4m residents, using a range of wireless technologies including Wi-Fi mesh, WiMAX, a dedicated 4.9GHz public safety network and wireless sensor networks. Five months ago, the project’s slow development pace was ascribed to its unprecedented scale and complexity, but now it seems to be shortage of funding.
Despite all this, vendors that have set considerable store by muni networks are insisting the systems can still work provided vendors and cities cooperate very closely and identify the real requirements of their particular locations and communities. Nortel said recently: ‘At Nortel we believe the key is to work with the cities, service providers and resellers to determine what the best business model is for the specific customer and which applications/services will drive network utilization. It takes the right business model and the right partners to make it work.’ The company, which has made cities a key target for its mesh/WiMAX systems, recently announced deployments in Kentucky’s 22 state resort parks and libraries in Denver, Colorado, as the latest in a string of contracts that are notable for their flexible mix of technologies, and their focus on a clearly defined application or user group ‘ avoiding two of the key reasons for failure of many muni projects.
Another muni wireless fan, Cisco, is refocusing its strategy for the sector, and has bundled together a range of products to shift the focus of local authorities away from the current low cost, open access model towards thinking of blanket wireless as an enterprise network ‘ with associate quality of service and, of course, capex and opex cost ‘ to support employees. ‘We had looked at the existing models: mainly free services for citizen access, equal access and economic development,’ said Morgan Wright, Cisco’s global industry solution manager for public safety and homeland security. ‘Those didn’t produce the results people wanted.’ Instead, Wright argues, successful municipal deployments are those that treat the technology as an extension of the municipal enterprise network, used by emergency services and other city employees.
It now offers its so-called Mobile Government package, which bundles its 3200 wireless and mobile router, which mounts in a vehicle and supports an 802.11a backhaul link to a metro mesh; an integrated onboard video card (from its 2007 acquisition of Broadware) to let analog video cameras in a vehicle connect directly to the 3200 router; the IP Interoperability and Collaboration System 2.0, to link conventional push-to-talk or land-mobile radios and cellphones with IP devices; and Unified Communications Manager for VoIP.
Newly added are support for the licensed 4.9GHz public safety band in the 3200 routers and the 1520 two-radio outdoor mesh access point; and the 1524 model, which will have up to four modular radio slots, supporting 802.11a/b/g and/or 4.9GHz clients, plus 802.11a backhaul, and competing with similar products from Motorola. Later in 2008, Cisco will have a radio for a dedicated 4.9GHz backhaul link. Also part of the new package are partnerships with 3I Infotech and APS for public safety applications, and with Accela, MobileFrame and Syclo for mobile worker and inspection applications.
The weight of companies like Nortel, Cisco, IBM and Motorola, which are well used to working with large government projects, will ensure that, where a market exists, it will be gradually brought down to earth and tied to real world business or government objectives, with these taking precedence over technology choices or the political aims of either municipalities or technology vendors. This may not deliver all the dreams of the original muni wireless movement, and will likely play into the hands of the traditional operators and suppliers, but at least there will be some real and measurable gains.
Market projections:
The municipal market analysts remain bullish too. In its third annual report on this sector, MuniWireless predicts that the US market will be worth more than $329m in equipment this year, up 35% on 2006, and that while failures are hitting the headlines, there are many cities and counties with networks running successfully. The report claims demand for wireless networks for both municipal and public usage will fuel year-on-year growth rates of at least 33% a year between now and 2010, with revenues exceeding $900m by the end of the decade. However, this year’s statistics are lower than had been predicted in last year’s survey, because several major cities including San Francisco, Chicago and Philadelphia have either delayed, stretched out or re-evaluated their initiatives.
MuniWireless also found that public safety is by far the top government application being deployed or planned, and the fastest growing; networks are growing larger as full roll-outs take over from trials and as counties and larger cities start to deploy; fiber and WiMAX are becoming important for backhaul as networks outgrow DSL or Wi-Fi backhaul.