Qualcomm said this week that it will seek a workaround for technology a federal jury found infringed Broadcom’s patents, after Broadcom said it would ‘immediately pursue an injunction’ against the products concerned, in particular EV-DO and W-CDMA chips.
Broadcom said it will “seek to enjoin Qualcomm from making, using, selling and developing third generation WCDMA and EV-DO cellular chips that infringe any of the patents.”
In July, Qualcomm worked out a deal directly with Verizon Wireless, for the cellco to pay Broadcom up to $200m for the use of Qualcomm’s patent infringing chips in its handsets; Qualcomm has indicated it will seek to replicate a similar deal with all its customers going forward.
The development follows a decision by US District Court Judge James Selna, who last week reversed an earlier decision to double a $19.6m judgment meted out against Qualcomm in its litigation with Broadcom. Broadcom has accepted this ruling, as the alternative was to retry the case. The reduction was imposed following a Supreme Court ruling that raised the bar for declaring “willful” infringement of a patent, meaning that Selna has, in effect, ruled that Qualcomm as guilty of infringement, but not wilful infringement.
Qualcomm has had more fortune recently in its legal battles with Nokia, winning two victories in courts in Germany and the Netherlands over patent exhaustion, and one in the US, where the International Trade Commission threw out a Nokia claim asking for an injunction against import of Qualcomm 3G chips that infringed its patents. The ITC said the suit was to be dismissed as it was pending arbitration, even though it had ruled in favor of Broadcom in a similar action earlier this year. “From our point of view, Nokia is not entitled to sue Qualcomm for patent infringement,” a spokesperson for the ITC said.