The initial list of bidders in US spectrum auctions is always far more fascinating than the list of eventual winners, which tends to end up focused on the usual suspects, but the 700MHz event may throw up a couple of surprises because of the focus on open access and public safety, as well as the sheer attractiveness of low frequencies for rural services, in particular. Much has been made of the internet community’s interest, but it seems only Google will actually bid, which in itself gives the search giant a new potential chance to disrupt the status quo in the US. The company has stated that it will bid alone, but is widely expected, should it gain licenses, to work with a partner on roll-out and creating its planned open access, wholesale model. This would offer expansionist operators from outside the US a golden opportunity to get a toe in the heavily protected market, and all eyes are on Japan and Korea, countries where there actually is real experience of the open mobile internet model working.
We have already seen Korea’s SKT setting up the Helio joint venture with Earthlink and trying to partner with Sprint Nextel on its Xohm WiMAX plans, an offer that has so far been rebuffed but could be revisited, especially if SKT drops its support for the return of former Nextel chief Tim Donahue as the new CEO. As an alternative, it could look to partner with Google in 700MHz, something that the Japanese majors have also hinted at. In an interview with Business Week, the head of NTT DoCoMo USA, Masaki Yoshikawa, whose main role is to investigate new business opportunities for the Japanese giant, said: “Google is trying to acquire spectrum now. Maybe they will be looking for a partner” for their network. Perhaps we can be involved in the process.” This is despite the fact that DoCoMo sold its 16% stake in AT&T Wireless in 2004 at a $3.3bn loss. KDDI is also testing cellular data services, mainly geared to Japanese expats and visitors, in the north east US.
The Japanese and Korean carriers know they need to expand, though having got their fingers burned during the telecoms recession in the US and Europe, they have recently been more focused on emerging Asian markets. However, the US is a huge opportunity, with its large and wealthy population and relatively low uptake of mobile data services ‘ about 54% of US users subscribe to some form of mobile data, compared to 90% in Japan. DoCoMo has formed a US advisory board, headed by former FCC chairman Michael Powell, and has made a few American partnerships, such as supporting Google’s Android handset software venture and funding AT&T’s build-out in Hawaii.
While renewed activity by the east Asian giants might accelerate change in the US, and kick Verizon and AT&T into further action, the internet companies remain the most high profile movers and shakers, and are willing to base their ambitions on almost any spectrum available. Apart from 700MHz, a key area of focus has been the white space spectrum left between the broadcasters’ allocations in the UHF band, and once again Google has been a key agitator to get this freed up for license-exempt or lightly licensed broadband wireless. The FCC is set to conduct another round of testing on a new group of devices to see if they can avoid interference with digital TV signals, having rejected previous submissions by Microsoft, Google and others.
Several vendors have now submitted updated devices, claiming improved anti-interference performance, for testing by the FCC. These include Google, Philips (whose white spaces ‘sense-and-avoid’gear did pass previous government testing) and start-up Adaptrum. The latter, founded by Robert Broderson, also co-founder of Atheros, uses the whole 6MHz of the DTV signal and contains a time domain matched filter, a technique designed to permit greater sensitivity than pilot tone detectors. Microsoft is also about to deliver a new device, while Motorola has already presented the FCC with a white spaces unit that combines geolocation database and sensing technologies.
A new group, the Wireless Innovation Alliance, has been formed to lobby the FCC to complete testing and move forward with technical guidelines. Six House of Representatives members wrote to FCC chairman Kevin Martin recently to urge a final decision in the next few months. The transition from analog to digital TV is due to be completed in February 2009.
‘It is unfortunate that Microsoft and Google continue to try to muscle their way through Washington in support of a technology that simply does not work,’ said Dennis Wharton, executive VP of the National Association of Broadcasters. ‘By playing Russian Roulette with digital television, Microsoft and Google would completely undermine the historic public-private DTV partnership that broadcasters embraced to ensure America’s ongoing leadership in innovation.’