Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 January 2008

Paul Allen is a dark horse in US 700MHz auction

With just over two weeks to go before the US 700MHz auction commences, speculation is mounting over the intentions of some of the more interesting would-be bidders. Many of the usual mobile suspects are on the official list of candidates, of course, and despite all the talk of open access and revolutionary business models, are still likely to snap up the lion’s share of the licenses. Of the companies with a serious chance of disrupting the plans of AT&T, in particular, the plans of the cablecos and Google have been well discussed (see Wireless Watch December 11 2007), but others like Qualcomm and Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen are also in the frame.

As well as wireless operators, cablecos are strong on the list, with Cox and Cablevision talking up their intentions, as are various companies looking to adopt a wholesale model, with or without a public safety component (in the portion of the spectrum set aside for that purpose). AT&T, Alltel and the two main flat rate carriers, Leap and MetroPCS, are all likely to be aggressive bidders, with the last two needing to continue to expand their territories in order to sustain growth with their low cost model, especially following last year’s collapse of their often-mooted merger plan.

Qualcomm presumably wants 700MHz spectrum to boost its existing holdings in this band, which it uses for its MediaFLO mobile TV network, in order to increase capacity and deliver more video channels and/or new datacasting services. It could also use new licenses to open up some markets where it has had trouble getting incumbents to vacate the existing frequencies it holds (although that will also be a risk with these new licenses in the first year before the transition from analog TV becomes mandatory). Roger Entner of IAG Research commented: ‘Spectrum is like money, you know, you can never have enough. For a company that breathes and lives wireless like Qualcomm, there’s always use for spectrum.’

Meanwhile, Paul Allen is bidding via his venture capital outfit Vulcan Ventures, which has a unit called Vulcan Spectrum. Allen and Vulcan had already acquired large swathes of 700MHz spectrum in the Pacific Northwest in the first auction in this band in 2003. At that time, Qualcomm and Aloha Partners were the major winners (Aloha’s licenses now belong to AT&T) but there were various smaller acquirers too, including Vulcan, which bought 24 licenses in Washington state and Oregon, including large metro areas like Portland and Seattle.

Allen may be acquiring spectrum purely as a tradeable asset, or on behalf of cable operator Charter Communications, in which Allen has a controlling stake (acquiring it via a private company could save on taxes, compliance costs and disclosure obligations).