Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 January 2008

India takes decisive action to open up 2G services at last

India is characterized by a combination of great vision and great bureaucracy, so perhaps it is unsurprising that the wireless world is subject to the same extremes. The past three years have seen the development of wireless and broadband plans that would make India the most rapidly growing and ambitious of the 4G nations, as well as starting to help its infrastructure catch up with its vast economic potential. However, the will may be there, but the spirit has proved weak when it has come to regulatory authorities, which have often strangled visions in complex and conflicting rulings. At last, though, the authorities seem prepared to take the decisive actions that are urgently required to cut through the bickering and kickstart the grand plans. Late last year, innovative rulings were made for upcoming auctions of 3G and 2.5GHz spectrum, enabling 3G and ‘4G’ mobile broadband services to be rolled out in parallel, so that India could potentially leapfrog more advanced wireless economies in terms of 4G progress. Most new spectrum allocations have been opened up to new competitors, even from outside India, to create a freer competitive climate. Now the Department of Telecom has ended months and even years of carrier quarrelling over 2G regional spectrum by summarily issuing mobile licenses to any qualified applicant that had completed its paperwork by September 25 last year (those who missed the deadline could have their applications reviewed at a later date).

All this reflects a heightened awareness in India of the potential to use wireless technologies to create a world class infrastructure and enhance its economic power and social integration ‘ and also a heightened recognition that this is now urgent, and must not be allowed to be wrecked by bureaucracy and politics. So, rather than listen to any more of the byzantine arguments of the operators over the 2G licenses, the DoT has taken uncharacteristically quick and unequivocal action.

A total of 46 companies had filed a huge 575 applications for Universal Access Service Licenses (UASLs) before the cut-off date of October 1 (though the DoT has now retrospectively adopted September 25 as the deadline). All licenses were for 2G mobile services in India’s 23 telecoms regions or ‘circles’, and the regulator TRAI (Telecom Regulatory Authority of India) had ruled that there should be no cap on the number of licenses awarded per circle. A total of 15 operators applied for all 23 regions, while four requested 20 or more. The high level of interest reflected the high growth rates in Indian mobile services, with GSM operators signing up 5.6m new subscribers last September alone. The total of GSM and CDMA subscribers crossed the 200m mark in August last year, but with a population of 1.1bn, there is still huge room for expansion.

The lack of caps, low cost of the licenses, and the removal of many restrictions on foreign applicants, have all heightened activity in this market. AT&T was one international player that applied for UASLs in all circles, having gained long distance service licenses across India earlier in 2007. Russia’s Sistema will also gain spectrum in all circles via its acquisition of India’s Shyam Telecom.

The UASL saga has proved another opportunity for the GSM and CDMA operators to pursue their ongoing quarrels and resentments. The CDMA providers, which are represented by the Association of Unified Telecom Service Providers in India (AUSPI) claim their GSM counterparts have unfairly been allocated more spectrum, and has also opposed the ‘no cap’ ruling, claiming it will encourage ‘non-serious operators’ that could ‘spoil the scene by hoarding the scarce spectrum without rolling out the services’. It said in a letter to TRAI late last year that the new auctions should be used to redress an imbalance with GSM, arguing ‘the GSM operators have already been allocated spectrum beyond the contracted limit [6.2MHz], while CDMA operators are still languishing at 5MHz or below 5MHz’. The GSM body, the Cellular Operators Association of India (COAI) responded that the policy of allocating spectrum on the basis of “usage, justification, availability” allows for up to 15MHz per GSM operator, and that operators in other countries have been awarded more. TRAI has been pressurizing GSM providers to use their spectrum more efficiently ‘ in India GSM frequencies serve an average of 3.9m subscribers per MHz, compared to 8.5m in China.

Another row has concerned the award of an additional 10MHz of spectrum to state-owned BSNL and another 8MHz to its sister company MTNL,which has been denounced by privately owned telcos.

Many of these issues have been the topic of heated debate for years and always threaten to delay allocation and build-out of spectrum, and therefore to hold back India’s wireless vision. This is why the swift action of the DoT over UASLs is encouraging. Nine telcos and non-telco entrants will now gain UASLs in some or all circles, enabling them to offer 2G services alongside the existing cellcos (currently either three or four per circle). Among the victors are telcos Idea Cellular, Spice Telecom, Shyam/Sistema and Tata Teleservices. New entrants include property developer Unitech, Swan Communications, S Tel, Loop Telecom and Datacom (part of industrial conglomerate Videocon, which has formed a joint venture with Verizon for long distance services). The new licenses will enable Tata, a CDMA operator, to offer GSM services, a move already adopted in new regions by its main CDMA rival, Reliance. UASLs allow the holder to launch mobile services on either GSM or CDMA networks, as well as VoIP and internet services.

Operators will have to pay INR16.5bn ($419.9m) for nationwide licenses, and less for a smaller number of circles. Once the fee has been paid, they will receive spectrum on a first-come, first-served basis. Reports suggest that, as well as the nine winners, the DoT has also allocated spectrum to mobile players Idea Cellular, Vodafone Essar, Aircel and Reliance, which already operate 2G in the 23 circles, but have been waiting for months for new allocations of bandwidth.

Mobile television:

India’s potentially vast mobile TV market is on the verge of take-off, with the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) recommending an open bidding process for both satellite and terrestrial spectrum dedicated to mobile TV, meaning that auctions are likely to take place this year and that anyone can bid.

TRAI has also taken the step of allowing up to 74% of any bidder to be owned by interests outside of India, in order to attract overseas operators and investors. This is in keeping with India’s recent strategy on 3G, WiMAX and other wireless auctions.

The move to include some S-Band satellite spectrum will almost certainly mean that Alcatel, highly favored in India, will get an opportunity to push its own DVB-SH technology, and gain it an immense national footprint to go with those it is planning in Europe and the US.

TRAI also made the point that these new licenses will be for newcomers and that plenty of other existing telcos and cellcos already have sufficient spectrum to launch their own mobile TV services. The licenses will be technology neutral except that they should use standards put forward under the ITU, so that might mean anything from T-DMB to DVB-H and DVB-SH, but not Qualcomm’s MediaFLO.

TRAI said that, apart from incumbent public broadcaster Doordarshan, private operators may be assigned at least one slot of 8MHz for mobile TV operation using terrestrial systems. For satellite-based systems, also apart from Doordarshan, private operators may be allocated spectrum such that at least 8MHz is available to them for mobile television services. Sharing the terrestrial transmission infrastructure of Doordarshan should be permitted on a mutual agreement basis, TRAI also said.

This move seems to have speeded up Doordarshan, which has had a DVB-H trial in progress in Delhi since 2006 using NEC transmitters and Nokia handsets. Doordarshan has rolled out a full head-end for Delhi, which went live during 2007, and will now begin bringing Mumbai, Chennai, and Kolkata online before these new licenses can be auctioned and made productive.

The Tata Group also began mobile TV trials in New Delhi, Mumbai and Calcutta last year, in partnership with cellco Bharti Airtel, but using its own T-DMB multiplex from Pixtree with just three or four video channels, with handsets from Samsung, LG and Perstel.

Once the new licenses are also added, that means that by the end of 2008 there could be at least four separate mobile TV services in India, in all the major centers of population, plus the big S-Band satellite footprint. However, none of this will take off without exceptionally cheap DVB-H and DVB-SH devices coming to market, and potentially laptop cards will do more business than actual handsets.

India currently has around 166m cellular handset owners, growing at around 24% a year, and is likely to be offering all of these services as either free to air, or with some channels free and some paid. Potentially India could rival the uptake in Japan, which has 18.5m mobile TV users, and keep pace with China, which is expected to eventually become one of the world’s biggest mobile TV markets.

India is viewed as one of the greatest potential growth markets for broadband wireless. Its government has advanced thinking on using broadband, especially in wireless form, to make India more competitive and socially just, and to aim to leapfrog more developed economies in telecoms terms. It also has a high level of technical education and knowledge, a huge population with a growing middle class, and massive uptake of mobile phones, to compensate for its under-developed wireline structures. All this makes an ideal hunting ground for advanced wireless technologies, but ambitions have been held back by political squabbling and regulatory confusion, as well as the bureaucratic structures of the largest operators. Now, real progress is being made in decisions about spectrum for WiMAX and similar technologies, and there is a real prospect of an orderly move towards opening up both 3G and broadband wireless during 2007.

India’s Department of Telecom (DoT) has shortlisted four frequency bands to allocate spectrum for WiMAX services. Three of these harmonize with other major international regulations, opening up the 2.5-2.69GHz, 3.4-3.6GHz and 2.3-2.4GHz bands, while significantly, India is one of the first large players to make the desirable 700MHz spectrum available for broadband wireless services. In the US and Europe, most of this band – much coveted by operators for its excellent propagation qualities, boosting spectral efficiency, range and therefore return on investment – will only come into use once it is vacated by analog television broadcasters. It is seen as ideal spectrum for advanced services such as mobile television and its license holders in India will be aggressively courted by all the mobile datacasting technologies, such as Qualcomm’s MediaFLO and DVB-H, as well as WiMAX.

Like the US regulator, the DoT is keen that at least some of the 700MHz bandwidth should be used to improve rural and low income access, rather than being used entirely for advanced services that mainly benefit high income citizens. It is likely to designate 40MHz for rural broadband wireless.

The regulator is likely to avoid restricting mobile usage in the newly freed up bands, and while WiMAX is the most trialled and fancied technology for this spectrum in the country, it is also likely to leave the spectrum technology neutral. With 3G licenses not yet allocated, some operators are looking to use WiMAX rather than UMTS or CDMA EV-DO for next generation services, especially if they can accumulate a mass of bandwidth in various frequencies and deploy a single platform across it.

There will be some time to wait before actual auctions, however, and this may be a painful period, if the 3G process in India is anything to go by. So far, the DoT has requested the Department of Space (DoS) to release 95MHz in the 2.5GHz band, 150MHz in the 3.5GHz range and an unspecified amount in the other two. However, the DoS claims first rights to some of the frequencies and may not give in to all its sister department’s requests. In 2.69GHz, for instance, the DoS says the band is fully used for various satellite-based mobile and broadcast applications, including disaster warning dissemination, radio and networking, according to Indian press reports.