The week after the Consumer Electronics Show is traditionally a high point for Apple fans, who look forward to the keynote of CEO Steve Jobs at the MacWorld event as though it were Christmas and their birthdays all rolled into one, and Jobs rarely disappoints. But for investors last week, he did just that ‘ dashing hopes that the company would unveil yet another world beater, even while owning up to problems with Apple TV, and against a backdrop of reports of failure to come to terms with China Mobile for the iPhone.
No company could be expected to unleash a device with the impact of iPod or iPhone every single year, and the disappointment of Wall Street and Apple lovers may in fact be a valuable correction of over-expectations. But the breakdown of talks with China Mobile indicates more deep-seated risks that face Apple and that must be addressed if it really is to become a major in the mobile device sector.
While some commentary on the aborted talks spun these as a crushing blow for China Mobile, whose shares were off as a result, the truth is that the turn of events was more of a problem for Apple, and the new economic facts of life with which it has to live now it is trying to play alongside Nokia. Many reports, like those from Reuters, had effectively fallen into the US press habit of thinking that the iconic Apple-designed phone makes a single inch of difference to an operator that has more customers than any other cellular operator in the world, around 350m. Apple has managed, by being such a small handset supplier in terms of numbers, to attach a ludicrous premium to its devices, which are most definitively cool. But given that Apple only wants to ship around 12m of them this year (we expect it will beat this number unless it is component constrained or charges too much), it can do without China for a while, or even take the device to China through a retailer, regulations permitting.
And indeed, the Chinese market will always be a tough one for Apple. Customers there have been proven to want high end devices and are prepared to pay one month’s average salary for such a device, but Apple is asking something closer to the equivalent of two months’ salary in its deals outside of China. The simple fact is that Apple does not yet have the economies of scale, and won’t have for at least three or four years, to price its products for China, let alone for even more price sensitive places like India, where handset prices are far lower and where the cachet of owning the latest device is not quite so important as a cheap deal.
In order to get any kind of return on investment for the device, Apple has been reported as asking China Mobile for a share of subscription revenues, something that device makers like Nokia, LG Electronics and Samsung can avoid, and since they each have new devices with many of the features of the Apple device (albeit not quite so nicely put together as the iPhone), China Mobile will be happy to take those devices on better terms. Those manufacturers clearly have the scale, and the local manufacturing to price for the Chinese and Indian markets, and it is something that Apple will have to aspire to over time.
Over at MacWorld, Jobs owned up to the weaknesses in the first Apple TV product, and fixed them; confirmed that virtually every major Hollywood studio is now ready to embrace either iTunes, or Apple TV, or both; and saved the biggest gasps for his new super-thin notebook, which is being marketed under the slogan ‘Thinnovation’, .75-inches at its thickest and thereafter tapering to a fine point where one side is a few millimetres across. The advertising for the new MacBook Air features someone pulling it from a large envelop which couldn’t possibly contain a laptop, and Jobs achieved the required gasps at his keynote by doing much the same.
Other announcements squeezed into the keynote included a wireless back-up for a whole network of Macs, a simple hard drive on the network called the Time Capsule with a server-grade hard drive with either 500GB or 1 TB of storage for $299 and $499 respectively. Apparently it’s a single command to turn on wireless back-ups and then just forget them.
The two major multimedia announcements included Apple’s poorest kept secret ‘ new deals with the studios for renting video through iTunes 30 days after the DVD sales window is open. The partners includes Touchstone Pictures, New Line Cinema, Lions Gate, Miramax, 20th Century Fox, Warner Brothers, Disney, Paramount, Universal and Sony. As of now the iTunes Store can offer 1,000 movies, which work on PCs, Macs, iPods and iPhones. They are ready to start playing 30 minutes after start of download, and can be transferred between devices with have 30 days to start watching, and then 24 hours before the rental ends. The deal does make online subordinate to DVD for the foreseeable future, but as the volumes rise, that can be renegotiated.
Jobs also offered latest news on the iPhone, which he said had sold 4m devices so far, ahead of schedule, and claimed second place in the US smartphone sector with a 19.5% market share against the Blackberry’s 39%, beating out Palm, Nokia, Motorola and everyone else. The truth is that there are no smartphones, by the European or Asian definitions, in the US, or at least not many, and the rest of the world market share is what counts, and really only on 3G devices ‘ but it was a small sop to the fans who had hoped for a new iPhone, perhaps the much needed 3G version, at MacWorld. The iPhone remains hugely US-centric so far, in sales and awareness, and though it has made a great start to its career in the handset market, Apple’s statements about market share will only currently be taken seriously by people who don’t have a clear global view.
Other iPhone news included improvements in location services and maps, the ability to customize the home screen and to send multiple SMSs at once. The location system allows users to bookmark locations (and therefore maps) like a web page), using Google maps in the back end. Maps uses a combination of Wi-Fi triangulation from Skyhook Wireless and Google’s cellphone tower triangulation. This mostly works only in the US, so once again Apple will have to find another way of doing this in other countries (Nokia has all this taped with its Navteq purchase). Skyhook Wireless has broadened its coverage to Europe and Asia this year, taking in the top 50 European metropolitan areas and the top 15 Asian cities, but then again, why not just put a GPS chip into the iPhone like 180m other handsets did last year?
But as much as Jobs piled on all these announcements, the Apple stock has been overhyped, and clearly he cannot launch an iPhone class revenue opportunity every year. Shares in Apple dropped $10 by the time the keynote was over, from $179 to $169, taking over 5% off the share value of Apple on the day, but at a market capitalization of $148bn, it could probably live with that.
In our view Apple has to work out what it wants to be, and there are many possibilities. It could dominate consumer electronics, but perhaps the margins in that business, long term, are unattractive; it can look for discrete device opportunities like the iPod or the iPhone, and keep itself purely operating at the high margin end of multiple markets, but in the end a recession will come along and eat most of its profit if it adopts that approach; or it can become a handset company, in which case it needs a few years to bed down its iPhone, pushing on to 3G this year, WiMAX the next and LTE the following year, all the while driving up volumes, and improving its logistics and distribution channels globally.
Then it will find itself on a hard slog to drive down the costs of what it builds, while retaining its design cachet, and it will have to put itself into a position where it can compete head-to-head with Nokia, Motorola, Samsung and Sony Ericsson on a global basis. Our feel is that this will take too long, and given that the US investor public still thinks Apple is quite rightly worth MORE than Nokia, given their respective market capitalizations, if Apple went this route, it would be perceived as an also-ran. Perhaps it should buy Motorola and run it as an arm’s length handset maker (at $32bn market cap, that’s not so crazy as it sounds). But with the current level of investment expectation on Apple, all the design and execution in the world will not keep investors happy, and the company has perhaps just turned into a stock that is ripe to sell, at least for a short while until its value is more sane.