A year ago the term ‘femtocell’ was hardly known outside rarefied circles, yet now the miniaturized indoor base stations have even featured in articles in UK tabloid newspapers. The awareness has been built, but 2008 should be the year when it becomes clear whether the devices are going to live up to their potential in the commercial world. January has seen some positive indicators, not least the announcement of technology trials by yet another European major, with T-Mobile joining Vodafone, TeliaSonera, Orange and Telefonica O2 in testing femtocells. But while these operators are largely looking to the most basic applications of femtocells ‘ to extend the RAN cost effectively, especially for indoor coverage and homezones ‘ the greater potential lies in deploying the products in less conventional ways, where they can support new applications and models, and so generate better economics (see Wireless Watch December 18 2007). So we see picoChip announcing the first femtocell platform for the Chinese wireless standards, which could attack a market where the choices of deployment models are still wide open; RadioFrame pushing further into the enterprise sector; and Cisco taking an investment in UK femtocell start-up ip.access, hinting at the likely role the home networking vendors, as opposed to the base station stalwarts, could take in this sector where full scale RANs intersect with consumer electronics.
T-Mobile is seen as something of a coup for the femtocell cause since in the US it has been the cheerleader for the other main approach to indoor coverage/homezones, dual-mode Wi-Fi/cellular handsets supported by UMA (Unlicensed Mobile Access). UK CTO Emin Gurdenli said the European wing of the Deutsche Telekom unit will kick off trials in the UK, Germany and the Netherlands in the second quarter and that, if successful, there could be some small scale commercial deployment before year end. “If it actually does succeed and deliver on the promise then it will be a breakthrough,” he said in an interview with silicon.com, although he added a note of caution, that T-Mobile would only go commercial if it was confident of the whole concept ‘ ‘not just the technology – including the business models and so on. A proper food chain has to be established before this thing rolls out in large numbers. But I’m personally optimistic.”
One of the issues he sees as vital is to get the femtocell into the hands of companies that are experienced with mass consumer devices and know how to make them affordable, attractive, automated and easily usable ‘ like handsets. Companies like Texas Instruments are already mulling transferring their fledgling femtocell efforts from the base station teams to the handset and consumer device units, reflecting the fact that these product may be base stations, but their economics and design may be better understood by device vendors. Hence the importance of the entry of the consumer wireless suppliers, which in Wi-Fi access points and other home electronics gear have gained experience of bringing carrier class networks right into the living room. Netgear has been the most active to date, being a founder member of the Femto Forum and working with Ubiquisys on a combined femtocell/home gateway (a format also being addressed by NEC and Thomson). This has led to widespread speculation that Cisco would take a serious interest in femtocells through its Linksys division, and the first step may have been taken with its investment in ip.access. Although the IP giant had been widely rumored to be interested in the other UK-based femtocell specialist, Ubiquisys, (which boasts an investment from Google) in fact it has bestowed its favors on ip.access of Cambridge, which also numbers Intel Capital and Motorola Ventures among its backers. The start-up makes GSM and 3G devices, with the Oyster 3G femtocell being its flagship.
Getting the mass market equipment makers involved will help shift the economics of femtocells towards the price points that operators like Vodafone and BSNL are demanding. Another important move will be for femtocells to get in on the ground floor in new markets, where they could support more radical new business models for operators and command higher margins. Greenfield WiMAX and LTE networks will be key areas, and with the Beijing Olympic Games this year finally forcing the Chinese authorities into 3G action, the Chinese carriers will also be choice targets. At least one, and probably more, will end up deploying the homegrown 3G standard, TD-SCDMA, and there is already significant work being done on its 4G successor, TD-SCDMA LTE. In these standards, as in FDD LTE, there will be the chance for femtocells to be a recognized base station format from day one, rather than an add-on.
UK femtocell chip pioneer picoChip has unveiled the first design for a TD-SCDMA femtocell, and its first product wholly developed at its design center in Beijing. The design was announced to coincide with UK prime minister Gordon Brown’s recent visit to China with a delegation of British companies, in which picoChip represented hi-tech.
Yang Hua, the secretary general of the TD-SCDMA Industry Alliance, said in a statement: “Femtocells are an important part of the TD-SCDMA ecosystem, and an essential part of operator strategy, particularly as we evolve to TD-SCDMA LTE.’ picoChip also supports femtocell designs for W-CDMA, LTE, WiMAX and, via a partnership, CDMA2000.
While the TD-SCDMA platform remains largely unproven and untested in the real world, it is being pushed into an accelerated roll-out program to support the technological requirements of the Olympics, and it is still possible that the Chinese will aim to get a network running in the capital before the Games ‘ resulting in an intense burst of activity from this quarter, and a race to get systems working, a race that could be helped by the flexibility to use different base station formats as appropriate to rapid deployment. Regular 3G licenses will also be awarded this year, although the likely technologies to be adopted will depend partly on how Chinese authorities proceed with a planned restructuring of the four main telecoms operators, China Telecom, China Mobile, China Netcom and China Unicom. All of these except Unicom have built trial TD-SCDMA networks. It is likely that TD-SCDMA licenses will be awarded first, before the end of the first quarter, with W-CDMA or CDMA2000 franchises to follow near the end of 2008.
Orange and RadioFrame:
RadioFrame is targeting the consumer femtocell market in 2008, but its heartland is in the enterprise picocell, which it has recently taken to rechristening the ‘giant femtocell’. Orange has adopted the former iDEN specialist’s S-Series picocell to power its recently announced Onsite Coverage service, geared to small and medium enterprises in remote locations in Europe. RadioFrame and Orange have been trialing the service with customers since mid-2007, aiming to improve mobile coverage in difficult terrain such as mountains, and within concrete, steel or underground buildings or shopping centers.
CEO Jeff Brown said: ‘We are mindful that as we develop interesting technology, however, it only matters when the solutions are deployed commercially. For a wireless network operator of Orange’s size and reputation to begin commercial deployment of our technology is a significant milestone for RadioFrame and an indication of the bright prospects of the indoor coverage solution industry as a whole.’
Orange’s Onsite Coverage service is a scalable offering of miniature base stations that can provide full mobile coverage for up to 50 mobile users, boosting coverage within a 50 meter radius. Base stations can also be linked together to support more users or a higher volume of calls. The S-Series is also resold by Nokia Siemens Networks.
TeliaSonera:
TeliaSonera is to run technology trials of femtocells in Sweden and Norway in the first half of this year and extend these to user tests in the third quarter. According to online news service Unstrung, two vendors will be put through their paces, though these have not been identified.
The Scandinavian operator already offers a fixed/mobile convergence option based on UMA (Unlicensed Mobile Access) and dual-mode handsets, which it markets as HomeFree in Denmark, Sweden and Norway. It sees femtocells as a way to evolve this service, adding new functionality and 3G support (HomeFree is GSM/Wi-Fi only).
“For Home Free, UMA is a first step – femtocells are the next step,” the operator told Unstrung, reflecting an increasingly prevalent view, and one that strikes fear into the dual-mode community, that UMA was a useful interim solution but that femtocells will provide a stronger growth path for future applications and devices.