The race to set the mobile internet agenda centers on two approaches ‘ one driven by wireless specialists like Nokia, which argue that specific mobile expertise is necessary to deliver a usable web experience on the handset; and the other by the internet players, which want to play down the distinction between the mobile and PC platforms and port their models almost unchanged to the small device. Inevitably, parties from both camps need each other’s help. Nokia – the most prominent in the first group, and also seeking to boost its direct-to-consumer business and bypass carriers in new markets ‘ cannot achieve a full internet services portfolio overnight by itself, and is likely to look to partners like Yahoo to fill out its Ovi portal ‘ and more immediately, is reported to be working closely with social networking success story Facebook. Yahoo itself has had a strong measure of success in cultivating cellco partnerships, especially in Asia, and now even the carrier challenger Google is recognizing the power of the mobile operators, notably with a new agreement with DoCoMo. And Sun, always the dark horse in mobile internet, but determined to use its expertise in Java to obtain a position of influence, may now be turning its recent acquisition of open source database MySQL to this task.
Social networking is one of the biggest phenomena in the evolution of ‘web 2.0’ techniques, and is a natural application for personal devices such as handsets, so inevitably it has become a key focus of the mobile internet battles. Google recently sought to take the steering wheel by creating an open technical specification called OpenSocial, to which leader MySpace, as well as Bebo, have signed up. The spec lets software developers write web-based applications that run within a number of social network services and also tap user information.
By contrast, the other social networking major, Facebook, offers its own specifications for software developers, and such add-ons to its site have contributed to Facebook’s popularity and usage. This is a technique Nokia is also using for its own mobile social networking service Mosh, its first foray into this application area and one of its most aggressive web moves to date. Now it looks as though Mosh will be supplemented by a closer alliance with Facebook, with some pundits even predicting an outright acquisition for the Finnish giant, which so far has added to Ovi mainly through small scale purchases, but which upped the stakes when it agreed to pay an impressive $8.1bn for mapping specialist Navteq, in its bid to go heavy on location-based services. Other recent internet acquisitions have included Avvenu for file sharing between mobiles and PCs; Twango for media sharing; and Enpocket for mobile advertising and marketing.
Getting closer to Facebook suggests that Nokia is shifting away from one of the tenets of its early moves in this market ‘ that it could create a specific mobile internet experience, under its own brands, that would be superior to any services just transferred from the PC, and so would help sideline the PC web brands in the mobile world. So Mosh aims to provide the first social networking offering that really bridges the gap between PC and mobile ‘ but the addition of Facebook, though it may be a less exciting product on the cellphone, allows Nokia to capitalize on a strong brand and probably prevent competitors like Sony Ericsson from doing the same (although RIM does support and promote Facebook on some Blackberry devices). This may well be a stronger strategy in the short term than trying to build a topnotch Nokia branded mobile web experience from scratch. While Mosh and the other Ovi elements may claim a headstart over MySpace, FaceBook and others in delivering their popular user experience on a mobile platform, something most PC brands are still doing very inadequately, it still needs to prove this advantage among real users, convince the Forum Nokia development community and leverage the hoped-for market lead rapidly, before the bigger names get their own mobile systems right. In the meantime, there is no harm in boosting uptake of the Nokia internet handsets, notably the N Series, by association with popular services, and score points against Apple and others.
Despite acquisition rumors, it is more likely that Nokia will take just a stake in Facebook as part of a development and marketing alliance, a move that would put it next to Microsoft, which paid $240m for a 1.6% stake in Facebook last fall, valuing the start-up at $15bn. Nokia and its new social networking friend are now working on porting the social network to Nokia handsets in such a way that these phones will be made synonymous with Facebook, giving it a placement as prominent as the YouTube button on the main screen of the iPhone. Facebook would also gain a major position in Nokia retail displays, a significant boost to its profile and distribution channels in the mobile world, as it fights for mindshare against MySpace. Working with Nokia will be particularly important as Facebook has been looking to expand in Europe, and recently raised funds from Sawmer Brothers geared to just that.
Such alliances will be important to the big internet properties, even though most have mobile sites now and are getting better at making these a friendly experience on small screens. But the web specialists are increasingly realizing that the handset base is a very different place to the PC market, and that the cellphone and operator brands still take precedence over their own, requiring the sort of partnerships that have not been necessary in the wired internet.
Yahoo has so far relied mainly on carrier brands, with partnerships with many cellcos driving its rather low profile mobile internet activities, centered on its Go Mobile platform (see Wireless Watch January 9 2008). Google has been trying to make its own brand dominant, bringing it into conflict at times with cellcos and with Nokia, but it is certainly not blind to the value of mobile alliances, especially as it has effectively excluded itself from any special treatment on handset from the Finnish giant, maker of 40% of the world’s handsets now. One of Google’s most important friends is now Japan’s NTT DoCoMo, one of the most advanced operators in terms of mobile internet services and interfaces. DoCoMo will offer Google services including search, Gmail, YouTube and Picasa to the 46m subscribers to its i-Mode mobile data service in Japan (other operators such as Telefonica also license i-Mode and could potentially adopt the same deal).
The search offering will come to market this spring and will include keyword-based advertisements among search results via Google’s AdWords platform. Under the agreement, Google will appear as the default start page on the full i-mode browser, and a new search box will be placed on the top page of the i-mode portal. The companies also announced plans to embed Google Maps for Mobile on i-mode handsets. This is a major win for Google, which although it has antagonized US cellcos with its support for alternative networks, has more opportunities in Asia, where consumers are famously hungry for mobile web applications. I-Mode customers are considered the most intensive users of mobile data in the world and DoCoMo was one of the operators that put its weight behind Google’s Open Mobile Alliance, the group supporting its Android open source mobile platform as a de facto standard. This signalled a likely alliance between the search giant and one of the most influential operators in the mobile web. It will also be important as a counterweight in Asia to Yahoo, which has close agreements with 16 Asian cellcos covering 40% of the region’s users (see Wireless Watch December 4 2007). Google has also partnered with Japan’s second carrier, KDDI, and powers mobile search for China Mobile.
Google and Facebook are two big internet names that use the MySQL open source database as their engine, along with Nokia and various cellcos such as China Mobile, Virgin Mobile and T-Mobile. This makes Sun’s recent $1bn purchase of the software house significant for the server maker in its constant, but largely unsuccessful, quest to gain a significant position in the mobile market. It potentially boosts the position of Sun servers among major wireless players, but more significantly in the long term, it gives the company a database platform that could be put at the center of mobile enterprise and mobile internet deployments, greatly increasing Sun’s influence, especially if combined with some of its Java-based technologies like Java FX Mobile.
Sun is making its own bid to take the driving seat in the evolution of the mobile internet interface and applications platform, though focusing on underlying technology and standards rather than front end brands and apps like Google and Nokia. With last year’s launch of FX Mobile and acquisition of the SavaJe Java-based mobile OS developer, Sun demonstrated its determination to put its technology at the heart of the mobile software world. It is working on handset software platforms ‘ working with Samsung on one based on FX Mobile and SavaJe, for instance ‘ and with MySQL could attack from the angle of the database driving the mobile web services.
Sun’s chances of creating its own handset architectures to compete with Android, Nokia S60 and others seem slim, especially given its poor track record of commercially exploiting its Java technology for profit and influence. But with MySQL it has a far better opportunity to become the supplier of choice of vital underlying technologies for emerging mobile internet players, as well as enterprises, and so to push its Java and other products in through the back door.
Mobile Mozilla:
Mozilla has shown off prototypes of the mobile version of its Firefox browser, which it aims to enter aggressively into the race to dominate this vital element of the mobile web experience. Firefox is already supported by Intel for the UMPC (UltraMobile PC) platform, and now it is close to a full cellphone implementation, aiming to snatch a headstart on Microsoft and Google and chase Opera and Safari.
There are already Mozilla-based browsers on selected handsets, notably the Nokia Internet Tablet, and the browser is a key element of Ubuntu Mobile, part of the Intel Internet Project. Most recently, microprocessor leader ARM and its allies put Firefox at the heart of their own bid to dominate the mobile Linux agenda (see Wireless Watch October 15 2007).
Mozilla said recently ‘Up until very recently device limitations required writing new mobile browsers from the ground up. Being able to leverage all the investments in the Mozilla platform across both desktops and devices is the right approach.’
There are two prototypes available, one for touchscreen phones and one for conventional handsets. Both are fairly minimal to make economical use of valuable screen real estate and to keep the code base slim and resource usage low ‘ all of which will be vital to compete with slimmed-down browsers like Opera Mobile. Information is available on the Mozilla wiki. Some features planned for development include a tab switching system that displays page thumbnails, and a URL completion system that works like the Firefox 3 AwesomeBar.
Mozilla Mobile should also use the Firefox Places system and the experimental Weave framework.
YouTube expands in mobile:
Google online video subsidiary YouTube is bringing its entire catalog of video clips to 3G users, and its expanded mobile offering also enables YouTube members to access their favorite clips and channels, rate and comment on videos and upload content directly from their phones.
YouTube got into mobile in late 2006 with an exclusive deal with Verizon Wireless, and launched a mobile web site last year. It also offers a free downloadable Java application that is available on a handful of devices in the US and UK, and which supports some interactive features like sharing. The mobile site does not yet carry advertising as the company aims to build up traffic first before seeking to monetize it.