Sprint Nextel fired three senior executives and talked up its cost cutting program, just as Verizon and AT&T were trying to convince the market of their open access credentials ‘ the area where, until Sprint pulled in its horns amid poor results, it was managing to score the most points against its larger rivals.
Sprint Nextel was the cheerleader for open mobile broadband business models in the US, which were to be driven by its Xohm WiMAX-based roll-out in 2.5GHz, and a year ago it was using the Xohm plan very effectively to present itself as the most advanced carrier in the country, well ahead of its larger competitors in open 4G-style models. Now, although Xohm’s soft launch went ahead as planned, the future of the initiative remains in doubt, and it is questionable whether, despite the strength of the vision, a weakened Sprint will have the resources and investor support to carry through its plans in a sufficiently strong way to offer a genuine challenge to Verizon and AT&T. The sale of the 2.5GHz spectrum to a better resourced player, or its placement in a joint venture, may prove the way forward, but in the meantime, all the attention from Sprint’s new CEO Dan Hesse is focused on establishing his credentials for operational efficiency, the quality his predecessor Gary Forsee, despite a hefty dose of vision, seriously lacked.
So hard on the heels of plans to cut jobs and other overheads (see Wireless Watch January 22 2008), with the aim of cutting $700m-$800m in annual expenses, CEO Hesse has culled top management too. Three senior executives, including CFO and (unimpressive) interim CEO Paul Saleh, left the company on Friday in the wake of last week’s poor quarterly results. As well as Saleh, chief marketing officer Tim Kelly and president of sales and distribution Mark Angelino departed. Senior VP and controller
William Arendt has stepped in as interim CFO. “Permanent leaders will be named in conjunction with a review of overall strategy and an effort to streamline operations,” said Hesse, who is also still looking for a COO to replace Len Lauer, who fell on his sword last year and joined Qualcomm.
Analysts are sceptical about the cost cutting program, which focuses mainly on headcount and retail stores. According to market watchers JPRG: ‘the company’s recently announced cost reductions seem of an inappropriate scale and seem unlikely to reach the company’s stated goal of $700m-$800m in annual expense reduction.’ The analysts believe Sprint Nextel will become a takeover target as well as attracting the attentions of activist investors/corporate raiders. ‘In a nutshell, we believe management is lousy, the assets are attractive, and the stock is cheap enough to attract bids,’ said JPRG in a research note. It believes that, while Sprint’s spectrum holdings in three key bands are worth an estimated $18bn (see table), it needs $8bn to build out Xohm alone, and even if it did succeed in achieving its cost cutting targets, it would not have enough to fund the future and exploit the underused spectrum assets effectively. This will not be helped by a hesitant board ‘ ‘the announced restructuring reinforces our opinion that Sprint’s board is so risk adverse it is best at taking half measures and in so doing is likely to fritter away opportunities, capital, and market position’, said the note. ‘With unimproved spectrum worth approximately $$9bn and a per subscriber value well below that of competitors it seems reasonable to expect an activist shareholder or strategic bidder to surface. It just seems like Sprint’s board is leaving money on the table.’ Possible bidders, in JPRG’s view, include a revival of the pre-Christmas proposal led by SK Telecom and private equity, with former Nextel chief Tim Donohue at the helm; fellow CDMA players Verizon Wireless (subject to antitrust clearance and support from co-owner Vodafone) or Alltel; and even Deutsche Telekom, which already owns T-Mobile USA. Other options could be an internet major such as Google or Intel, which could use Xohm as a vehicle for a disruptive open wholesale business model (especially if this approach fails to gain 700MHz spectrum), another international carrier or even private equity interests.
Meanwhile, Verizon and AT&T, once wrongfooted by Sprint in terms of setting out a 4G stall, are now largely unconcerned by their crippled challenger, but are still keen to improve their profile in the emerging open access market, to defend themselves against the threat from the real open internet players such as Google, now keen to control wireless spectrum and promote new business approaches.
AT&T quietly made available a SIM-only service through its online store. The SIM costs $5 after an online discount and allows new subscribers to sign up for AT&T’s service without having to buy a phone. Although it has always been possible to bring one’s own device to an AT&T store, the online offering shows it gaining a higher profile and the carrier accepting openness as a more mainstream part of its services.
The timing was also good to draw fire from Verizon Wireless’ announcement of a
developer conference for its open access plans, to be held on March 19-20 in New York. The carrier, which announced limited support for open access last November – fighting back against Google’ aggressive lobbying for compulsory open access on parts of the 700MHz spectrum ‘ said the conference is intended for developers in the device community to come together and learn about the technical standards needed for devices to run on Verizon Wireless’ network. “This initial conference is for developers of devices – because before consumers can have open access, you have to have open development,” Verizon VP Anthony Lewis said. “In hosting this conference, our aim is to jumpstart the development community by sharing information needed to develop devices for our network that achieve our network performance goals while making it easy for them to deliver devices.”
However, the cellco raised its usual caveats about open access ‘ that most consumers don’t actually want it, a view self-servingly echoed by AT&T and other mobile operators as they seek to maintain customer control and walled gardens for as long as possible. In its statement, Verizon Wireless said it “is listening to a segment of customers who want another choice without full service,” but remains largely focused on its full service offerings, including retail stores, 24/7 customer service and carrier branded applications.
In reaction to Verizon Wireless’ original promise, two months ago, to open its network to any devices that were certified for compatibility and security, AT&T’s CEO Randall Stephenson argued that the open mobile internet is a red herring in the US, and that consumers prefer subsidies to unlocked devices, and applications that work easily on a small device to those created in Java for multiple platforms. Like Verizon, and as the SIM move shows, AT&T is prepared to make a few concessions to what it believes (or hopes) is a small base of open access consumers, but will aim to shape the mobile internet model in its own image before it is too late and it loses it to Google or Nokia.
Stephenson claimed at the time that his company’s network was as open as Verizon’s is planned to be, since any device could be attached to it using an AT&T SIM card, a point now reinforced by the upgraded profile of the SIM option. He said in an that, of course, wireless would, over time, become open access like wireline but said: “You can take a Nokia phone and connect it to our network, just put in your own SIM card. We don’t see customers do that. They want the phone subsidized.”