Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 February 2008

Ericsson’s TDD demo and picoChip’s reference design show LTE getting real

The development of LTE platforms has accelerated dramatically in the face of the challenge from Mobile WiMAX, though the irony is that, as key vendors and operators line up for a commercial and political stand-off, the technologies themselves are getting ever more similar. In the past couple of weeks we have seen LTE propelled by Ericsson into the TDD profiles traditionally associated with WiMAX, while the WiMAX Forum’s recent summit made progress in the reverse direction, towards FDD implementations of 802.16e. And UK-based picoChip, working with German start-up MimoOn, has produced the first full reference design for LTE base stations.

The picoChip designs, which range from femtocells to macro base stations, take advantage of the commonalities between 802.16e and LTE, much touted by equipment vendors working both technologies (such as Motorola, which has found an overlap of over 80% in its development of infrastructure for the two platforms). The LTE products use the same physical platform as picoChip’s WiMAX family, enabling the start-up to steal a march on larger semiconductor makers ‘ with a reference platform that, in turn, VP of marketing Rupert Baines sees as reducing time to market for smaller equipment vendors, as they seek to use new technologies to break into the tight-knit club of GSM and UMTS base station makers.

The PC86xx LTE reference design was codeveloped with MimoOn, a German start-up focusing on IP for MIMO, in a non-exclusive agreement. Like its WiMAX stablemates, it uses picoChip’s own PHY and the Wintegra MAC, and. The PHY runs on the picoChip PC203 devices and includes OFDMA downlink and SC-FDM uplink, with support for up to 4×4 MIMO and for AAS, and supports TDD and FDD modes. MimoOn provides an end-to-end full software implementation of LTE on multicore DSP platforms like the picoArray.

Reference designs have been a well established way to cut the cost and time of getting an advanced product to market by saving smaller vendors from having to develop from scratch, and they gained a new prominence in the base station world with the arrival of WiMAX, with its need to close the timing gap with HSPA and support disruptive suppliers. It was not clear that the same level of competition would evolve in LTE, because of the power of the traditional cellular equipment makers, but even greater efficiencies are achieved through platforms that are adaptable in software between more than one technology, a goal that is also preoccupying the handset baseband sector (see separate item) as operators increasingly mull multi-technology strategies. While the likes of Intel and Ericsson may be pitting WiMAX and LTE directly against one another, and pinning their respective futures on one network becoming dominant, in reality most suppliers will be keen to exploit the similarities of the technologies to be able to supply whichever system customers want. Among the tier one base station makers, only Ericsson is strictly LTE-only (and even the mighty Swede OEMs Airspan kit for customers in DSL-style applications); Motorola and Nortel have majored on WiMAX, having failed in UMTS, but aim to reuse their work for LTE, and Samsung may do the same; Alcatel-Lucent, Nokia Siemens and the Chinese majors are all working on both platforms.

Another factor that will make LTE disruptive rather than conservative in certain markets will be the emergence of new base station formats, such as femtocells and broader use of picocells, which will support new operator models, and may also enable non-traditional equipment makers to elbow into the territory of Ericsson et al. ‘Ericsson’s world will never be the same again,’ bemoaned one senior executive last week, referring to the Swedish giant’s belief that ‘ however painful for its traditional profit model ‘ femtocells will become a commercial force from 2009, and mainstream from 2010, similar timescales to those expected for LTE and Mobile WiMAX.

With these factors in mind, it is important that reference designs are flexible in terms of base station formats, and the PC86xx scales from single-chip femtocell designs to multi-sector macro stations, from 1.25MHz to 20MHz and with both TDD and FDD modes supported. Being software defined, it can be upgraded in line with refinements to the LTE standard, which is 80% finalized, and the common platform also supports Wave 2/MIMO Mobile WiMAX now, and will support upgrades to the forthcoming FDD profile and to the next iteration of the standard, 802.16m.

Meanwhile, though the WiMAX Forum has been officially coy about the FDD profile for 802.16e (see Wireless Watch January 22 2008), it seems that work on this long-planned enhancement has accelerated in the face of Ericsson’s aggressive moves to push LTE into the TDD spectrum, which will increasingly be the focus of regulators’ new allocations, as the developed economies intensify their focus on mobile broadband data applications, to which TDD operation is well suited. Internal documents from the WiMAX Forum’s recent meeting in Hawaii have circulated widely, indicating that the Forum’s technical working group has now received full recommendations for an FDD profile for three frequency bands. One of these, predictably, is 2.5GHz, one of the two core bands for 802.16e (along with 3.5GHz), but the others show WiMAX moving directly into the cellular standards’ territory, and also taking a highly US-centric focus, with recommendations for two bands that are mainly available in the US ‘ AWS, auctioned last year, and 700MHz, the subject of the current FCC auction. Individual vendors like SOMA and Alcatel-Lucent have been adapting WiMAX for both these bands already, but now they appear to be moving to the WiMAX mainstream, stepping up the challenge to HSPA and LTE.

Of course, it may be a long process from recommendations and internal debate to seeing FDD profiles approved by the Forum and Mohammad Shakouri, the body’s vice president of marketing, stressed that there is no approved board policy yet on spectrum profiles for FDD.

Ericsson, in its role as the standard bearer for LTE as the main option for next generation mobile deployments, is far less shy in its pronouncements. It is doing a good job of implying that LTE is far more concrete and market-ready than it really is, with a barrage of demonstrations and announcements, presumably designed to detract from the market lead of Mobile WiMAX (which Intel recently argued is two years, while Ericsson’s own white papers narrow the gap to seven months). Key in the bid to convince operators that WiMAX is irrelevant or niche is the creation of TDD implementations of LTE, so that as well as being the natural choice for the vast swathes of FDD spectrum available today, it can also bid for the rising tide of new TDD or flexible spectrum licenses. Today more than 90% of all mobile spectrum is FDD (paired) but this ratio is already starting to change. For instance, many European regulators are increasing the proportion of TDD spectrum allowed for in the upcoming 2.5GHz allocations.

Much of the impetus has come from China, which created the TDD version of W-CDMA as its homegrown 3G standard, but stands to gain far greater international impact with its TDD implementation of LTE (TD-SCDMA LTE). Ericsson has been working closely with Chinese organizations on this important technology (see Wireless Watch January 15 2008) and using it to accelerate the development of a credible TDD platform in LTE that will be applicable outside China. While China has been widely criticized for its insularity in 3G platforms, the enhanced significance of TDD in the LTE generation may finally justify its strategy, and as picoChip’s Baines puts it, show China succeeding in the ‘long game that TD-SCDMA started’.

Now Ericsson has also shown the first demonstration of LTE running in both TDD and FDD mode on the same base station platform, claiming major economies for operators that can use the same system in both unpaired and paired spectrum. Although many carriers, especially in western Europe, had TDD spectrum allocated along with their FDD 3G licenses, few built it out because of limited amounts, and because it required a separate network (with the TD-CDMA technology from IPWireless, now owned by NextWave, the only real product option. However, IPWireless’ early R&D on a TDD path to LTE may put its new parent in an interesting position in terms of future products or licensing opportunities). Now Ericsson claims to have overcome that problem and its demonstration showed LTE in TDD mode working at 90Mbps in the downlink with 2×2 MIMO. Ericsson has previously demonstrated LTE in FDD mode with speeds of up to 160Mbps, as have Nokia Siemens and other key vendors in this market.

Ulf Ewaldsson, VP of product area radio at Ericsson, said: “We have now demonstrated that LTE can be used in both paired (FDD) and unpaired spectrum (TDD) on the same base station platform. This means that operators with only unpaired spectrum also can plan for LTE and benefit from the optimal global LTE solutions.”

Common platforms that can support multiple air interfaces and duplex modes will intensify the competition between the vendors, with a positive impact for operators in terms of timely availability of equipment to support new business models, plus rapid price erosion and development of new base station options such as femtocells. For the major equipment suppliers, the situation is not necessarily positive. They are being forced to accelerate R&D programs and roll-out while facing a far steeper price reduction curve than they have seen in the past, with the risk of failing to recoup their investments in development before the market becomes commoditized. History says this is likely to favor two sets of vendors. First, those with economies of scale, provided they can adapt quickly enough rather than clinging wistfully to old profit models, and this could spark further consolidation, with Motorola Networks now an obvious candidate (see separate item). Second, upstart vendors that can support new platforms and formats, and steal a march on larger rivals, without the financial burden of legacy systems and customers. The emergence of reference designs and software defined platforms will improve the ability of these challengers to enter the market with credible, early solutions, and will in turn make them attractive acquisition targets. Of course, some ‘upstarts’ in the carrier world may not be small companies. With its acquisition of Navini and investment in femtocell maker ip.access, Cisco has been sending out signals of interest in this sector and with data-oriented, all-IP systems moving firmly to center stage, many eyes will be on the IP supremo and, if it decides to move, on its potentially disruptive effect on the mobile networks space.