Microsoft’s $44.6bn bid to acquire Yahoo, and the hostile reaction from Google, has dominated the week’s technology news, and if the deal goes through, it will have a profound impact on the fledgling mobile internet. Assuming Microsoft succeeds in its audacious bid to neutralize perhaps its greatest challenger, Google, the deal will show the company finally accepting that Windows is no longer its future, and that it must dominate web services and applications across platforms, in order to generate growth and remain relevant. This will put it even more directly in conflict with Google in the broad internet market, and in the mobile world it will gain its first credible chance to be a major force, something that will raise profound issues for Nokia, itself becoming more platform-neutral and pinning its growth hopes on internet services.
The impact of such a fundamental shift in Microsoft thinking ‘ one that is long overdue, held back by the attachment of CEO Steve Ballmer to the traditional operating system model ‘ will be profound, and put a combined MSN and Yahoo at the center of the company’s future. Strategically this makes good sense, gaining Microsoft a company that has strong web technology, customer base and brand, despite its recent appalling commercial execution. Whether the software giant, not known for its skill in integrating acquisitions, makes an operational success of the marriage is another matter, but the decision to bid for Yahoo certainly indicates that Microsoft understands where the future of software lies and is determined not to let the internet players have it all their own way.
Hence an offer price of $31 a share, a 62% premium on the closing price of Yahoo common stock the day before the bid was announced (Yahoo shareholders could choose to receive either cash or stock). Rumors abound of rival bids, some of which could have Google’s support, although antitrust concerns would probably prevent the search leader from bidding directly. AT&T, News Corp and Time Warner AOL have all been mentioned as possible co-bidders, though no offers have yet materialized. Some Yahoo investors will be keen to get a bidding war going, as despite the company’s recent troubles, they argue the 62% premium is insufficient, given that Yahoo shares traded at $33.63 ($2.63 above the offer price) as recently as October 26, and that Yahoo holds cash and shares in publicly traded companies, including Yahoo Japan and Alibaba Group Holding, with a total market value of more than $12 per Yahoo share.
“We have great respect for Yahoo, and together we can offer an increasingly exciting set of solutions for consumers, publishers and advertisers while becoming better positioned to compete in the online services market,” said Ballmer in his offer statement, which explicitly referred to the threat from Google. ‘Today this market is increasingly dominated by one player. Together, Microsoft and Yahoo can offer a competitive choice while better fulfilling the needs of customers and partners’ ‘ comments clearly directed at possible antitrust probes, although the presence of Google and, to a lesser extent, Time Warner’s AOL in the portal market suggest that such investigations would clear the deal (provided Microsoft obeyed the usual restrictions on tying its portals and web applications into Windows). Microsoft hopes the transaction would clear in the second half of this year, though regulatory processes could drag it out until the end of the year or even early 2009.
While internet search and advertising are the key current battlegrounds with Google, both companies will have a keen eye on the future potential of the mobile web. This is a market where the positions of the major players are very different to those in the PC internet. There is an additional significant competitor in the shape of Nokia, which is determined to take Google’s position in the mobile internet and is investing heavily in cross-platform software and web services for its Ovi portal (and could itself have benefited from buying Yahoo, if it were not for the Finnish company’s aversion to the distraction of managing huge acquisitions). AOL is virtually non-existent, and Microsoft/MSN is far weaker than in the wired Net. Meanwhile, Google has done a successful job of talking up its wireless ambitions and positioning itself as the natural leader in the mobile web, without actually delivering too many results yet, though its spectrum activities and its nascent Android handset software platform may be disruptive from late 2008. But in reality, Yahoo has been the most impressive of the portals in the mobile world, even though it has failed to convince the market of this, and its activities have not been enough to affect its corporate performance significantly as yet (the company has been struggling, and last week said it would slash 1,000 jobs in the fall-out from a painful fourth quarter that saw profits fall by 24%, together with weak guidance for fiscal 2008).
Yahoo has steered clear of Google’s strategy to promote an alternative carrier model, based on open access and universal web connections, and guaranteed to provoke the hostility of the traditional cellcos, particularly in the US. Instead it has built strong relationships with many operators, particularly in Asia, and claims the market lead in mobile internet traffic (see Wireless Watch December 4 2007). Yahoo was the top ranking internet brand for mobile web surfers in 2007, according to Nielsen Mobile, drawing more than 16m unique visitors per month, ahead of Google on 11m and MSN on just over 9m.
In addition, Yahoo has been very advanced in key mobile internet technologies, and has greatly enhanced its Go Mobile platform, and at the recent CES show, made this fully open, stealing the high ground from the unproven Android. Its open Mobile Developer Platform is designed to show off what are clearly Yahoo’s strengths compared to Google ‘ its superior technology, in terms of mobility, developer functionality and maturity ‘ as opposed to its weaknesses, notably its poor marketing and market weight. Yahoo is far more advanced than Google in harnessing the popular technique of widgets for mobile applications development and now will offer third parties tools to write widgets once, for instant publication across the device ecosystem. Initial partners announcing widgets at CES include eBay, MySpace and MTV.
All this will strengthen the mobile internet offering of Microsoft, which is feeble and give it the chance to have a real impact on the smartphone sector at last ‘ not through Windows Mobile, which has not gained serious traction outside the enterprise device market, and which is likely to lose ground to Linux; but through web services, search, advertising engines and innovative user interfaces. Yahoo would give Microsoft a developer community, brand, services and user base in the mobile consumer sector where it has signally failed to have its usual impact, and which would complement its strength in mobile enterprise applications.
This would be tough for Google, which as we have seen is already struggling to turn its high sounding mobile ambitions into real products and market share. The search giant’s initial reaction was to argue that a Microsoft-Yahoo tie-up would be bad for competition, and to offer Yahoo any help with fighting off the predator. If the acquisition proceeds, we can expect to see Google ploughing large amounts of its plentiful cash into developments and purchases of its own to consolidate its position in the PC base and kickstart its mobile efforts ‘ perhaps with a shift away from initiatives with longer term pay-off, such as buying spectrum, and a stronger focus on readymade products and services, and on alliances with powerful carriers.
The other company that will be eyeing this potential deal with trepidation will be Nokia, whose CEO Olli-Pekka Kallasvuo has pinned such high hopes on turning the company into one driven by internet services. Although Nokia has formulated a credible sounding strategy to achieve this, and announced some strong products and start-up acquisitions, it is very early days, and it has certainly benefited so far from taking a different, sometimes almost complementary, approach from that of Yahoo, enabling it to focus on Google, whose mobile web offering is even more immature than Nokia’s. While Nokia has been pursuing a direct to consumer approach, Yahoo has been signing with carriers, and there was even potential for the two companies to work together against Google, rather than in opposition. Having to face up to Yahoo head-to-head ‘ and a Yahoo strengthened by the money and marketing weight of Microsoft ‘ will be daunting for the Finnish giant and may provoke a new attitude to Microsoft. Under previous CEO Jorma Olilla, Microsoft was explicitly identified as the enemy, with Nokia challenging Windows Mobile via Symbian/S60, and also seeking to wrest the whole mobile client business away from a shrunken PC and towards a smartphone format. But in the past year, Nokia’s view of Microsoft has softened, with the OS debate shifting upwards towards higher software layers and web applications, an area where Google is a greater threat. Of course, by the time a Yahoo takeover might be completed, Nokia will have made progress with Ovi and will have a clearer view of how strong a position it can realistically expect in the mobile web. At that point, it will need to make some key decisions on whether it would be better to exploit the inevitable teething troubles in the merger and remain positioned against Microsoft, or whether to seek some accommodation with the Redmond major, ploughing an easier furrow for its web devices and presenting a united front to Google.