The most interesting twist in a so-far humdrum 700MHz spectrum auction in the US came on Monday, when bidding in the hotly watched block C took an unusual turn. The maximum bid of $4.7bn for licenses in all 50 states had stood unchanged for several rounds, and had already triggered the open access provision. Now a new bidder, hotly tipped to be AT&T, has selectively bid up a number of regions so that the bids for the regions now exceed the $4.7bn high bid for the national block. It is widely thought that the national bid was Verizon’s and that Google, despite all the furore about its possible spectrum ambitions, has either dropped out or will do shortly.
Google said last year that it would bid the $4.6bn required to trigger a compulsory open access provision on part of block C, provided the FCC met its four key openness demands. In fact, the FCC upheld only two, but the search giant was still expected to put up the money to ensure this valuable block of spectrum will support open access, and therefore boost the Google business model. However, it always seemed likely that Google would rather not take on the burden of managing and building out spectrum ‘ even with the objective of creating a wholesale system that could be genuinely disruptive to AT&T and Verizon ‘ and that provided open access had come into force, it would withdraw and content itself with having speeded up the giant telcos’ reluctant shift towards openness.
Jamie Townsend, analyst with JRPG, commented: ‘If the previous winning bid had been placed by Google, than the new bidder in the block C regions could be either Verizon or AT&T. In this scenario, we don’t expect Google to raise its bid and the bidding will probably cease with the winner being whoever is in the regions.’ If a carrier now wants to get the block C license as a nationwide package, they will have to bid more than $5bn in Round 31 to secure the bundle. Otherwise, the spectrum will be awarded in eight separate regional licenses that cover the 50 states. (The FCC does not reveal which companies are bidding on what spectrum, in order to prevent collusion).
It is still early in the auction process, and already the 700MHz market is seeing very mixed fortunes in the US. The auction had already raised over $18bn at the end of last week, after 26 rounds of bidding, far outstripping the $13.8bn raised by the AWS sale at the end of 2006, and already exceeding the $15bn revenue target set for the whole 62MHz on offer by the FCC.
While the open access supporters have got their wish, even if block C still falls into the hands of the traditional telcos, there is less good news in block D, which is the one that mandates a national public safety network be built as part of a public/private venture. With the demise of the major contender for this project, Frontline Wireless, after failing to raise sufficient funding, it has been doubtful whether block D could reach its reserve price of $1.3bn. There has been no new bid on this license since a $472m offer in round one, though FCC chair Kevin Martin says he remains optimistic that a bidder will come forward to meet the reserve price FCC rules do not dictate that any particular action be taken if the reserve price is not met, only that agency officials review the situation before deciding what to do next, and Martin has not given any signals that he plans to back away from the public-private sector approach even if the spectrum has to be re-auctioned, though he would likely be forced to lower the reserve price or be more flexible on safety requirements.
Meanwhile, the reserve has been met for block B (734 licenses) which mirror the existing licenses for cellular and PCS coverage and so are largely likely to be contested by operators with existing systems, but which need more spectrum in specific cities or areas. However, block A (176 licenses), except in a few specific areas, is not drawing much interest at this early stage.